What the lawsuit is about and why it matters to car owners
California has stricter vehicle emissions standards than the federal government sets. In 2023, the state sued several major automakers—including BMW, Mercedes-Benz, Volkswagen, and Audi—claiming they installed software that made their vehicles emit far more nitrogen oxides (NOx) during real-world driving than they did during official EPA tests. This is the same type of violation that Volkswagen faced in the 2015 "dieselgate" scandal.
The lawsuit alleges that these manufacturers knew their vehicles would fail California's strict emissions tests, so they programmed the engines to detect when the car was being tested and run in a cleaner mode only during those tests. Once on the road, the software switched to a mode that prioritized engine performance over emissions control, releasing pollutants at levels far above what the vehicles were certified to emit.
If you own one of the vehicles named in the lawsuit, you may be may have access to to compensation or a remedy. The outcome could also affect the resale value of these vehicles and set a precedent for how California enforces its emissions standards against other manufacturers.
Key Takeaways
- California sued automakers for using software that made vehicles emit more pollution during real driving than during official tests, violating state emissions standards.
- Owners of affected vehicles may be able to join a settlement or lawsuit to recover damages or obtain engine repairs or buybacks.
- The lawsuit covers specific model years and engine types, so you need to check whether your vehicle is included before taking action.
- Settlements typically offer owners a choice between a cash payment, an engine software update, or in some cases a vehicle buyback or trade-in allowance.
- You do not need a lawyer to join a class action settlement, though you can hire one if you choose to pursue an individual claim.
Which vehicles are covered by the lawsuit
The lawsuit names specific model years and engine types. The vehicles most commonly involved are diesel-powered models from BMW, Mercedes-Benz, Volkswagen, and Audi sold between roughly 2009 and 2016, though the exact years vary by manufacturer and model. Gasoline-powered vehicles have also been named in some cases.
To find out whether your vehicle is covered, you need to know your vehicle identification number (VIN), which appears on your registration, insurance card, and the driver's side dashboard. You can cross-reference your VIN and model year against the list of vehicles named in the lawsuit. California's Attorney General website and the court documents for each case list the specific models and years included.
If your vehicle is covered, you will typically receive a notice in the mail from the court or the settlement administrator. Do not wait for the notice to act—if you own an affected vehicle, you can contact the settlement administrator or the court directly to confirm your may be able to access and learn about your options.
How settlements work and what owners can receive
When a lawsuit against an automaker settles, the court approves a settlement agreement that outlines what owners receive. In emissions cases, owners typically have several options: a cash payment, an engine software update (reflash), a vehicle buyback, or a trade-in allowance toward a new vehicle.
A cash payment is a one-time sum paid directly to the vehicle owner. The amount depends on the vehicle's age, mileage, and condition at the time of settlement. Older vehicles with higher mileage typically receive smaller payments than newer ones.
A software update (reflash) reprograms the engine control module to remove the emissions-cheating code and bring the vehicle into compliance with California standards. This option allows you to keep your vehicle but may reduce fuel economy or engine performance slightly. Some owners choose this route if they plan to keep the car long-term.
A buyback or trade-in allowance lets you return the vehicle to the manufacturer or a dealer and receive a payment based on the vehicle's pre-violation value. This option is usually available only if the vehicle's value has dropped significantly due to the emissions violation.
Steps to take if your vehicle is affected
First, confirm that your vehicle is covered. Gather your VIN and check the court documents or settlement website for your specific case. The settlement administrator's website will have a VIN lookup tool or a list of covered models and years.
Second, if you receive a notice in the mail, read it carefully. The notice will explain your options, the important date to submit a claim, and how to contact the settlement administrator. Keep this notice—you will need information from it to file your claim.
Third, decide which remedy you want. If you are unsure, contact the settlement administrator by phone or email. They can explain the financial difference between a cash payment, a software update, and a buyback for your specific vehicle. This decision is important because you typically cannot change your choice after you submit your claim.
Fourth, submit your claim before the important date. Most settlements require you to submit a claim form, a copy of your vehicle registration or title, and proof of ownership. You can usually submit these documents online, by mail, or in person at a claims center. Missing the important date means you lose your right to compensation.
The difference between joining a settlement and filing your own lawsuit
A class action settlement is a court-approved agreement that covers all owners of affected vehicles. You do not need to hire a lawyer or file paperwork in court. You straightforward submit a claim to the settlement administrator, and if approved, you receive your remedy. The settlement covers your legal costs—you do not pay a lawyer fee unless you hire one voluntarily.
An individual lawsuit means you sue the automaker on your own or with a lawyer. This route takes longer, costs more upfront, and requires you to prove your damages. However, you may recover more money if your vehicle suffered unusual harm or if you can show additional losses beyond the vehicle's depreciation.
Most owners benefit from joining the class action settlement because it is faster, requires less paperwork, and covers everyone equally. You should consider an individual lawsuit only if your situation is unusual—for example, if you can prove the vehicle caused you specific financial harm beyond what the settlement offers, or if you missed the settlement important date.
How the lawsuit affects your vehicle's value and your legal options
An emissions violation typically reduces a vehicle's resale value because buyers know the vehicle failed to meet emissions standards and may face future repairs or restrictions. The amount of depreciation varies by market, but vehicles involved in major emissions lawsuits often lose 5 to 15 percent of their pre-violation value.
If you sold your vehicle before the lawsuit was filed or before you knew about the violation, you may still have legal options. Some settlements allow former owners to file claims if they can prove they owned the vehicle during the violation period. Check the settlement documents to see whether former owners are included.
If you are still deciding whether to keep your vehicle or sell it, the settlement may help you decide. A cash payment or buyback offer gives you a concrete number to compare against what you might get by selling privately. A software update lets you keep the vehicle and restore it to compliance, which may stabilize its resale value.
What happens after you submit your claim
After you submit your claim, the settlement administrator will review it to confirm that your vehicle is covered and that you provided all required documents. This process typically takes 30 to 90 days, though it can be longer if the administrator needs to contact you for missing information.
Once your claim is approved, you will receive a notice telling you which remedy you are may have access to to and how to proceed. If you chose a cash payment, the check will be mailed to you or deposited directly into your bank account. If you chose a software update, you will receive instructions on how to schedule an appointment at a dealership. If you chose a buyback, the settlement administrator will guide you through the process of returning the vehicle and receiving payment.
Keep all documents related to your claim, including the approval notice, receipts, and any correspondence with the settlement administrator. These documents may be needed if you have questions about your payment or if you need to file a tax return showing the settlement income.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do I have to hire a lawyer to join the settlement?
No. Class action settlements are designed so that owners can file claims without a lawyer. The settlement administrator handles the process, and the automaker pays the settlement costs. You can hire a lawyer if you want help, but it is not required to receive your remedy.
What if I already sold my vehicle before the lawsuit was filed?
Some settlements allow former owners to file claims if they owned the vehicle during the violation period. Check the settlement documents or contact the settlement administrator to ask whether former owners are covered. You will need to provide proof of prior ownership, such as a title transfer or registration.
Will the software update hurt my car's performance or fuel economy?
A software update removes the emissions-cheating code, which may result in a small decrease in fuel economy or engine power. The exact impact depends on the vehicle and engine type. The settlement documents or the dealership can tell you what to expect for your specific vehicle before you commit to the update.
Can I get a buyback if my vehicle has high mileage?
Buyback offers are based on the vehicle's pre-violation value, which factors in age and mileage. High-mileage vehicles typically receive lower buyback offers than low-mileage ones. You can compare the buyback offer to a cash payment or software update to decide which option makes the most sense for your situation.
What if I miss the important date to file my claim?
Missing the important date means you lose your right to compensation from the settlement. However, you may still have the option to file an individual lawsuit against the automaker, though this route is more expensive and time-consuming. Contact a lawyer when ready if you missed the important date and want to explore other options.