Your lawyer's injury doesn't automatically end your case, but it does change how your claim moves forward

If your car accident lawyer becomes injured or ill and can no longer work on your case, you have options. The law firm may assign another attorney to take over, you can request a continuance (a delay) while your lawyer recovers, or you can hire a different firm entirely. The choice depends on how far along your case is, how serious the injury is, and whether you trust the firm to handle the transition smoothly.

Your lawyer has a duty to tell you when ready if something happens that prevents them from working. They cannot straightforward disappear or hand your file to someone without your knowledge. What happens next is partly up to you and partly up to the court if your case is already filed.

Key Takeaways

  • Your lawyer must notify you in writing if an injury or illness prevents them from continuing your case, and they cannot abandon your file.
  • The law firm can assign a new attorney to your case, but you have the right to object and request a different arrangement.
  • If your case is filed in court, the judge must approve any change of attorney, and you can ask for extra time to find new representation if you want it.
  • You are not responsible for paying your current lawyer twice or for duplicate fees if you switch firms, though you should review your contract to confirm.
  • The sooner you know about the change, the better — delays in notifying you can give you grounds to request a continuance or even to change lawyers at no cost.

How law firms handle an injured attorney's caseload

When an attorney at a firm becomes injured or seriously ill, the firm's responsibility is to protect the client's interests. This usually means assigning the case to another attorney at the same firm who can step in when ready. That attorney reviews the file, learns the facts of your accident, and continues working toward settlement or trial.

The firm should contact you by phone and follow up in writing within a few days. The letter should explain who the new attorney is, their experience level, and when they will contact you. If the firm delays notifying you or tries to hide the change, that is a red flag — it suggests they are not taking your case seriously.

You have the right to meet with the new attorney before they take over. Ask them about their experience with car accident cases similar to yours. If you are uncomfortable with the switch, you can say so. The firm may offer to find a different attorney within the firm, or they may ask you to give the new attorney a chance.

Your right to object or request a different lawyer

You are not obligated to accept whoever the firm assigns. If the new attorney has little experience, or if you straightforward do not feel confident in them, you can request a different arrangement. Your options are to ask for a different attorney at the same firm, to request a continuance while your original lawyer recovers, or to end the relationship and hire a new firm.

If your case has not yet been filed in court, this is straightforward — you can fire the firm and hire someone else. You may owe the original firm for work already done, depending on your contract, but you are free to leave. If your case is already in court, you will need the judge's permission to change attorneys, though judges routinely grant this request.

Before you decide to switch firms, ask yourself whether the delay is worth it. If your case is months away from trial and your original lawyer will recover in a few weeks, waiting might make sense. If you are close to a settlement important date or trial is approaching, staying with the new attorney may be faster than starting over with someone else.

What happens if your case is already filed in court

Once your case is filed, any change of attorney requires a court order. The law firm will file a motion to substitute counsel, which tells the judge that your original attorney can no longer work on the case and names the new attorney. The judge almost always approves this, especially if the reason is injury or illness.

You will receive a copy of the motion before it is filed. If you object — for example, because you do not want the new attorney — you can tell your lawyer in writing. The judge will consider your objection. If you want to hire a completely different firm instead, you can file your own motion asking the court to let you change lawyers.

The court may grant you extra time to find new representation, particularly if the original attorney's injury was sudden and you had no warning. This delay is called a continuance. It protects you from being rushed into a bad decision or from losing important important date because your lawyer disappeared.

Fees and what you owe when an attorney leaves

Your contract with the law firm spells out how you pay and what happens if the attorney cannot finish the case. Most car accident cases work on contingency, meaning the firm takes a percentage of your settlement or judgment — usually 25 to 40 percent — and you pay nothing upfront. If your lawyer leaves, the firm's fee does not change.

You do not owe two lawyers or pay duplicate fees. If you stay with the firm and a new attorney takes over, you still owe only the original percentage. If you leave the firm and hire a new one, you owe the first firm for the work they completed, and you owe the new firm their percentage of what they recover. The two firms may negotiate how to split the fee, but that is their problem, not yours.

Ask for an itemized accounting of what the original firm spent on your case — hours worked, documents reviewed, informed consultations, court filings. This helps you understand whether their bill is fair. If you are unhappy with the amount, you can dispute it or ask the bar association to review it.

Red flags that suggest the firm is not handling this well

A law firm that does not tell you about an attorney's injury for weeks, or that tries to hide it, is not acting in your interest. Similarly, if the firm assigns an attorney with no relevant experience and refuses to discuss alternatives, that is a sign they care more about keeping the case in-house than about your outcome.

If your case is approaching a important date — a settlement offer is expiring, trial is in a few weeks, or a statute of limitations is about to run — and the firm suddenly tells you about the change, you have grounds to request a continuance or to switch firms without penalty. Courts understand that last-minute changes can harm your case.

Another warning sign is if the firm tries to pressure you into accepting the new attorney quickly, or if they become defensive when you ask questions about the transition. A professional firm will give you time to think, will answer your questions honestly, and will respect your decision if you want to go elsewhere.

Steps to take if you want to change lawyers

First, get a copy of your entire file from the current firm. This includes all documents related to your accident, correspondence with the other party's insurance company, medical records, photos, and any informed reports. The firm must give you these within a reasonable time — usually 10 to 30 days depending on your state.

Next, interview new attorneys. Tell them what happened with your original firm and where your case stands. Ask whether they will take the case and what their fee will be. Most will work on contingency for a car accident case, but confirm this in writing.

Once you have chosen a new firm, they will handle the paperwork to withdraw the old firm from the case. If your case is in court, the new firm files a motion to substitute counsel and the old firm files a notice of withdrawal. The judge approves both. This process usually takes a few weeks.

How to protect yourself going forward

At the start of any attorney relationship, ask what happens if your lawyer becomes unable to work. A good firm will have a written policy and will explain it to you. Some firms have multiple attorneys who can cover for each other; others are solo practices where an injury could be more disruptive.

Stay in regular contact with your lawyer. If you notice they are not responding to emails or calls, or if their office seems disorganized, address it early. Do not wait until a crisis to realize something is wrong.

Keep your own copies of important documents. Do not rely entirely on your lawyer's file. If something happens and you need to switch firms quickly, having your own records makes the transition much faster.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can a law firm keep my case if I do not want the new attorney?

No. You have the right to fire your lawyer and hire someone else at any time. If your case is in court, you need the judge's permission to change attorneys, but judges routinely grant this. The firm cannot force you to work with an attorney you do not trust.

Will I lose my case if my lawyer gets injured?

Not necessarily. A change of attorney can cause delays, but it does not harm your legal rights. If the firm handles the transition professionally and the new attorney is competent, your case should move forward normally. If the firm mishandles it or delays telling you, you may have grounds to request a continuance.

What if the new attorney makes mistakes because they are unfamiliar with my case?

This is rare if the firm does a proper handoff. The new attorney should review the entire file before taking over. If they do make a mistake that harms your case, you may be able to sue the firm for malpractice or to recover damages from the firm's insurance. Document everything in writing.

Do I have to pay the original lawyer if I switch firms?

You owe the original firm for work they completed, but the amount depends on your contract. If you are on contingency, they take their percentage only if you recover money. If you switch firms before settlement, the original firm may claim a lien on your recovery to cover their costs. Your new lawyer can negotiate this with the old firm.

How long does it take to switch to a new lawyer?

If your case is not yet filed in court, you can switch in a few days — just hire the new firm and have them request your file. If your case is in court, the process takes two to four weeks because the judge must approve the change. If you are close to a important date, ask the court for a continuance to give yourself more time.