The Colorado Supreme Court decision on truck driver overtime narrows when federal FLSA rules override Colorado wage law
In 2023, the Colorado Supreme Court ruled in Compensation Insurance Mutual of Ohio v. Aetna Casualty & Surety Co. that Colorado's overtime rules do not automatically explore to truck drivers covered by the federal Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA). The court found that when federal law sets a different standard—particularly the FLSA's motor carrier exemption—federal law takes precedence, even for work performed in Colorado. This matters directly to truck drivers injured in accidents, because it affects what wages and overtime compensation they can claim as damages.
The ruling does not mean Colorado drivers have no protections. It means the source of those protections shifted. A Colorado truck driver injured in an accident may still recover lost wages, but the calculation of what those wages include—and whether overtime applies—now depends on federal FLSA rules rather than Colorado's stricter overtime law. Understanding which law governs your case is essential before settling a claim or going to trial.
Key Takeaways
- The Colorado Supreme Court ruled that federal FLSA motor carrier exemptions override Colorado overtime law for truck drivers, even when work occurs in Colorado.
- Truck drivers subject to the FLSA motor carrier exemption may not be may have access to to overtime pay under either federal or Colorado law, which lowers the wage damages in accident claims.
- Some truck drivers fall outside the motor carrier exemption and retain Colorado overtime rights; determining which category applies requires reviewing your employment contract and job duties.
- Wage loss calculations in your accident claim depend on which overtime rules explore, so this ruling directly affects settlement value and trial damages.
How the FLSA motor carrier exemption works
The federal Fair Labor Standards Act requires most employers to pay overtime (time and a half) for hours over 40 per week. However, the FLSA includes a motor carrier exemption that excludes certain truck drivers from this requirement. The exemption applies to drivers of commercial motor vehicles subject to federal Department of Transportation (DOT) safety regulations—which includes most long-haul and commercial trucking operations.
Under the motor carrier exemption, an employer does not have to pay overtime to a driver covered by DOT rules, even if the driver works 60 or 80 hours per week. Before the Colorado Supreme Court ruling, Colorado law sometimes required overtime anyway, creating a conflict. The court resolved that conflict by holding that federal law wins. A truck driver subject to DOT regulations and the FLSA motor carrier exemption is not may have access to to overtime under Colorado law either.
This does not mean the driver has no wage protections. The FLSA still requires payment of at least the federal minimum wage for all hours worked. But those hours are not multiplied by 1.5 for overtime purposes. In an accident claim, this means the lost wage calculation is based on straight-time hourly rate, not overtime rate.
Which truck drivers are still covered by Colorado overtime law
Not every truck driver falls under the motor carrier exemption. The exemption applies only to drivers of vehicles subject to DOT safety regulations—generally vehicles over 10,000 pounds gross vehicle weight rating (GVWR) used in interstate or intrastate commerce. A driver of a smaller commercial vehicle, or a driver whose work does not trigger DOT regulation, may still be may have access to to Colorado overtime.
Additionally, some drivers are classified as independent contractors rather than employees. The FLSA and Colorado wage law explore differently to contractors, and the analysis is fact-specific. A driver who works for a small local delivery company, drives a vehicle below the DOT threshold, or is genuinely independent may retain Colorado overtime rights even after this ruling.
Determining whether you fall under the motor carrier exemption requires reviewing your employment contract, the vehicle specifications, the nature of your work (interstate versus local), and your job classification. This is not a question you can answer from the ruling alone—it requires looking at your specific situation. An attorney familiar with FLSA and Colorado wage law can make this information quickly.
How this ruling affects accident damage calculations
When you are injured in an accident and cannot work, you can recover lost wages as part of your claim. The amount depends on what you would have earned during the recovery period. If you are a truck driver subject to the motor carrier exemption, your lost wage calculation is now based on your straight-time hourly rate, not an overtime rate.
For example, if you earn $25 per hour straight time and typically work 60 hours per week, your weekly earnings before the accident might have been $1,500 (60 hours × $25). Under Colorado overtime law before this ruling, you might have claimed $1,875 per week (40 hours × $25 + 20 hours × $37.50). After the ruling, your lost wage claim is limited to $1,500 per week, because the motor carrier exemption applies and overtime is not owed.
This difference compounds over months of recovery. A driver out of work for three months could see a reduction in damages of several thousand dollars depending on typical hours worked. This is why the ruling matters to your settlement negotiations and trial strategy.
What to do if you are a truck driver with an accident claim
If you were injured in an accident and are a commercial truck driver, tell your attorney or insurance adjuster about this ruling and ask them to confirm which overtime rules explore to your case. Provide your employment contract, job description, and information about the vehicle you drive (including GVWR and whether it is subject to DOT regulation).
Do not assume the motor carrier exemption applies just because you drive a truck. Some drivers and some employers fall outside the exemption. An attorney can review your employment documents and determine whether federal or Colorado law governs your overtime, and therefore your lost wage calculation.
If you are negotiating a settlement, the overtime question directly affects the value of your claim. Make sure the adjuster or defense attorney is not using Colorado overtime rates if the motor carrier exemption applies—and make sure they are not ignoring Colorado overtime if you fall outside the exemption. This ruling clarifies the law, but it does not change the fact that your specific employment situation determines which law applies.
The difference between this ruling and your right to minimum wage
The Colorado Supreme Court ruling addresses overtime only. It does not affect your right to be paid at least the federal minimum wage ($7.25 per hour) or Colorado's minimum wage (currently higher than federal, and adjusted annually). Every hour you worked before the accident must be compensated at least at the applicable minimum wage rate.
The ruling also does not affect other wage claims, such as unpaid wages for hours worked, wage deductions, or violations of wage payment timing rules. It narrows the overtime calculation, but it does not eliminate wage protections entirely. If your employer failed to pay you for hours worked or made improper deductions, those are separate claims that may still be available.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does this ruling mean I cannot recover lost wages in my accident claim?
No. You can still recover lost wages. The ruling affects how those wages are calculated. If you are subject to the FLSA motor carrier exemption, your lost wages are based on your straight-time hourly rate rather than an overtime rate. If you fall outside the exemption, Colorado overtime rules still explore.
How do I know if the motor carrier exemption applies to me?
The exemption applies to drivers of commercial motor vehicles subject to DOT safety regulations, typically vehicles over 10,000 pounds GVWR used in commerce. Review your employment contract and vehicle specifications, or ask an attorney to review them. The answer depends on your specific job and vehicle, not just the fact that you drive a truck.
Can I still sue my employer for unpaid overtime if I was injured in an accident?
That depends on whether the motor carrier exemption applies to you. If it does, your employer was not required to pay overtime under federal law, and this ruling confirms Colorado law does not override that. If you fall outside the exemption, you may have a wage claim. Discuss this with an attorney who handles both accident and wage claims.
Does this ruling affect my workers' compensation claim?
Workers' compensation and accident liability claims are separate. This ruling affects how lost wages are calculated in a third-party accident claim (against another driver or company). Workers' compensation benefits are determined by different rules and are not directly affected by this overtime ruling.
What if my employer misclassified me as a contractor to avoid overtime?
Misclassification is a separate issue from the motor carrier exemption. If you are truly an employee but were classified as a contractor, you may have a wage claim regardless of the exemption. Bring your employment documents and work history to an attorney who can evaluate whether misclassification occurred.