What the Indiana Toll Road Bill Does
Indiana's toll road bill, formally called the Indiana Toll Road Concession Agreement, transferred operation of the Indiana Toll Road (I-90) to a private company in 2006. The road runs 157 miles across northern Indiana from the Ohio border to the Illinois border. This matters for accident claims because toll road accidents involve different reporting procedures, different insurance considerations, and sometimes different liability rules than accidents on state highways.
When you have an accident on the Indiana Toll Road, you are dealing with a private operator's property and procedures, not the Indiana Department of Transportation. That distinction affects who investigates, who you contact, and what documentation you need for your claim.
Key Takeaways
- The Indiana Toll Road is operated by a private company under a long-term concession agreement, not by the state, which changes accident reporting and investigation procedures.
- You must report toll road accidents to the toll road operator's emergency line and local police, not just to your insurance company.
- Toll road operators maintain their own incident records and may have video footage from toll plazas and cameras along the road that your insurance adjuster will need to request.
- Liability on toll roads can include claims against the operator itself if poor maintenance, signage, or road conditions contributed to the accident.
- Your insurance company may need to file a separate claim with the toll road operator's insurance if the operator bears any responsibility for the crash.
Reporting an Accident on the Indiana Toll Road
If you are in an accident on I-90 in Indiana, call 911 first if anyone is injured or the vehicles are blocking traffic. For accidents with minor damage and no injuries, you can call the Indiana Toll Road's customer service line to report the incident. The toll road operator dispatches its own incident response team to document the scene, separate from state police.
You must also file a police report with the local law enforcement agency that has jurisdiction over that section of the toll road. In most cases this is the Indiana State Police, but some sections fall under county sheriff jurisdiction. Ask the toll road operator's responder which agency to contact, or call the non-emergency line for the county where the accident occurred.
Keep the toll road incident report number and the police report number. Your insurance company will need both to investigate your claim. The toll road operator's report is separate from the police report and contains information specific to toll road operations, maintenance, and any toll road equipment involved.
Insurance and Liability on Toll Roads
Your own auto insurance covers accidents on toll roads the same way it covers accidents on any road — your collision coverage pays for your vehicle's damage (minus your deductible), and liability coverage pays for damage you cause to others. The toll road operator's status as a private company does not change your insurance obligations.
However, toll road accidents can involve a third party: the toll road operator itself. If poor road maintenance, missing or unclear signage, inadequate lighting, or debris on the roadway contributed to the accident, the operator may bear some liability. Your insurance company's adjuster will investigate whether the toll road operator's negligence played a role.
If the operator is found partially at fault, your insurance company may file a separate claim against the operator's liability insurance. This is called a subrogation claim. The operator's insurance is typically very large because the company maintains 157 miles of high-speed highway and handles thousands of vehicles daily.
Toll Road Operator Records and Evidence
The Indiana Toll Road operator maintains incident logs, maintenance records, and video footage from cameras along the highway and at toll plazas. This evidence is crucial for accident reconstruction and determining fault. Your insurance adjuster will request this information directly from the operator's claims department.
Video footage is particularly important because toll road cameras often capture the moments before and after a crash. The operator typically retains footage for 30 to 90 days, so your adjuster must request it quickly. If you believe the toll road operator's negligence caused the accident, your attorney (if you hire one) can also request this evidence through the discovery process if the case goes to litigation.
Maintenance records show whether the road surface, drainage, guardrails, or signage were in proper condition at the time of the accident. If the operator failed to repair a known hazard or failed to post warnings about road conditions, those records become evidence of negligence.
When to Consider Legal Action Against the Toll Road Operator
Most toll road accidents result in standard insurance claims between drivers. However, if you believe the operator's negligence caused or worsened the accident, you may have grounds for a separate claim. Common scenarios include accidents caused by potholes, debris, inadequate drainage causing hydroplaning, missing or obscured warning signs, or poor lighting at night.
Before pursuing legal action, you need evidence that the operator knew or should have known about the hazard and failed to fix it. Maintenance records, prior complaints from other drivers, and informed testimony about road conditions all support this. Your insurance adjuster's investigation may uncover this evidence, or you may need to hire an attorney to conduct a more thorough investigation.
Indiana has a comparative fault rule, meaning you can recover damages even if you are partially at fault for the accident. However, you cannot recover if you are more than 50 percent at fault. If the toll road operator is partially responsible, the damages are split according to each party's percentage of fault.
Toll Road Operator Insurance and Damage Caps
The Indiana Toll Road operator carries commercial liability insurance with high coverage limits because of the volume of traffic and the potential for serious accidents. However, the operator may also have contractual protections or damage caps written into its concession agreement with the state.
These caps limit how much you can recover from the operator in certain types of claims. Your attorney can review the concession agreement and the operator's insurance policy to determine what recovery is possible. This is one reason to consult an attorney if you believe the operator bears significant fault — the rules governing recovery against a private toll road operator differ from recovery against a private driver.
Working with Your Insurance Company on a Toll Road Claim
Report the accident to your insurance company as soon as possible, just as you would for any accident. Provide the toll road incident report number, the police report number, and the names and contact information of any witnesses. Tell your adjuster that the accident occurred on the Indiana Toll Road and that the operator may have records relevant to the claim.
Your adjuster will contact the toll road operator's claims department to request incident records, video footage, and maintenance documentation. This process typically takes one to two weeks. Do not sign any settlement offer until your adjuster has reviewed all available evidence, including the toll road operator's records.
If you hired an attorney, your attorney will handle communication with the toll road operator's insurance company and may negotiate a settlement that accounts for the operator's potential liability. If you are handling the claim yourself, ask your adjuster to explain what evidence the operator provided and how it affects fault information.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do I have to pay tolls if I am in an accident on the Indiana Toll Road?
No. If you are in an accident and cannot proceed through the toll plaza, the toll road operator will not charge you. Report the accident to the operator's emergency line and explain that you cannot pay. The operator will document the incident and waive the toll.
Can I sue the toll road operator directly, or do I have to go through insurance?
You can pursue a claim against the operator through your insurance company's subrogation process, or you can hire an attorney to file a lawsuit if the operator's negligence was significant. You do not have to choose one path — your attorney can explore both. However, the operator's concession agreement may include limits on liability that an attorney will need to research.
What if the toll road operator's video footage shows the accident was not my fault?
Video evidence that clearly shows you were not at fault strengthens your claim significantly. Your insurance adjuster will use this footage to deny the other driver's claim and close your liability exposure. If you are found not at fault, your insurance company will not charge your deductible and your rates should not increase.
How long does the toll road operator keep accident video footage?
Most toll road operators retain video for 30 to 90 days. Your insurance adjuster must request footage when ready after the accident. If you believe the footage is critical to your case and the operator has already deleted it, your attorney can file a preservation notice demanding that the operator retain all remaining evidence related to your accident.
What if I was injured in a toll road accident — can I claim against the operator for negligence?
Yes, if the operator's negligence caused your injuries, you may have a personal injury claim. This is separate from your property damage claim. You will need medical records documenting your injuries and informed testimony linking those injuries to the operator's negligence. An attorney can evaluate whether your case is strong enough to pursue.