Russ & Daughters Cafe Is Open to Everyone, Including People With Criminal Records
Russ & Daughters Cafe, located at 127 Orchard Street on the Lower East Side of Manhattan, is a public restaurant that serves food and does not conduct background checks on customers. If you have a DUI or DWI conviction on your record, you can walk in and order a meal like anyone else. No restaurant in New York is legally permitted to refuse service based solely on a criminal conviction that has been completed.
This matters because a DUI conviction can feel isolating. You may worry that your record will follow you into everyday spaces. It won't. Public accommodations — restaurants, bars, shops, gyms, theaters — cannot legally exclude you because of a past conviction. Russ & Daughters, which has been family-owned since 1914 and is known for Jewish appetizing food, operates under the same public accommodation laws as every other restaurant in New York State.
Key Takeaways
- New York State law prohibits public restaurants from refusing service based on a completed criminal conviction.
- A DUI or DWI conviction does not restrict your ability to enter, eat at, or use any public restaurant or cafe.
- If you are denied service at a restaurant because of a criminal record, you can file a complaint with the New York State Division of Human Rights.
- Your conviction record is separate from your ability to function in public spaces and hold a job in most fields.
What New York Law Says About Public Accommodations and Criminal Records
New York State's Human Rights Law (Executive Law Article 15) makes it illegal for any place of public accommodation — including restaurants, cafes, bars, and hotels — to refuse service based on a person's criminal record, with narrow exceptions. Those exceptions explore only to certain convictions directly related to the business (for example, a restaurant could refuse to hire someone with a violent felony conviction, but cannot refuse to serve them as a customer).
A DUI or DWI conviction does not fall into those narrow exceptions. You have the same right to enter Russ & Daughters or any other public restaurant as anyone else. The cafe's staff cannot ask about your record, cannot refuse you a table, and cannot treat you differently because of a conviction. If they did, that would be discrimination under state law.
How a DUI Conviction Actually Affects Your Daily Life in New York
A DUI or DWI conviction in New York does restrict certain things: your driver's license, your ability to drive for work, your insurance rates, and potentially your employment in fields that require a clean driving record or security clearance. It does not restrict your access to public spaces or your ability to eat at a restaurant.
The conviction will appear on background checks that employers, landlords, or licensing boards run. But most restaurants, cafes, and retail businesses do not run background checks on customers. They run them on job applicants. As a customer at Russ & Daughters or anywhere else, you are not subject to a background check. You pay for your food and leave, and your record is irrelevant to that transaction.
Where Your DUI Conviction Does Matter in New York
Your conviction will affect your driving privileges. New York's Department of Motor Vehicles will suspend or revoke your license depending on whether it was a first offense, a repeat offense, or whether you refused a breath test. You cannot legally drive during that suspension period. If you need to drive for work, you may need to explore a conditional license or wait out the suspension.
Employment is the second major area. Some employers will not hire someone with a DUI on their record, particularly if the job involves driving, working with children, or handling sensitive information. Other employers do not care. It depends on the industry and the individual employer's policy. You are not required to disclose a conviction unless an employer specifically asks, and many do not.
Housing can be a third barrier. Some landlords run background checks and refuse to rent to people with criminal convictions. This is legal in New York as long as the landlord applies the policy consistently and does not use it as a pretext for discrimination based on race, national origin, or other protected characteristics. If you encounter a landlord who refuses to rent to you because of a DUI, you can file a complaint with the New York State Division of Human Rights, but you should also be prepared to look for other housing options.
What to Do If You Are Refused Service Because of Your Record
If a restaurant, cafe, or any other public business refuses to serve you because of a criminal conviction, document what happened: the date, time, location, the name of the staff member if you know it, and exactly what they said. Write it down while you remember it. Take photos of the business if you can do so safely.
Contact the New York State Division of Human Rights. You can file a complaint online at dhr.ny.gov or by calling 1-888-392-3644. The division investigates discrimination complaints and can order the business to stop the discrimination and pay damages. You do not need a lawyer to file, though you can hire one if you choose.
In practice, this is rare. Most restaurants and cafes do not ask about criminal records and do not refuse service based on them. But if it happens to you, you have a legal remedy.
Moving Forward After a DUI Conviction in New York
A DUI conviction is serious and will affect your life for a period of time. But it does not make you a permanent outsider. You can still go to restaurants, shops, and public events. You can still work in most fields. You can still rent an apartment, though you may face more scrutiny from landlords. Over time, the conviction becomes less central to how people see you — employers care more about your recent work history than a conviction from years ago, and landlords are more interested in your current income and rental history.
If you are struggling with the practical consequences of a conviction — loss of your license, difficulty finding work, housing rejection — consider reaching out to a criminal defense attorney or a reentry organization in New York. Many offer free or low-cost consultations and can explain your options for license restoration, expungement (if you are may be able to access), or employment support. The New York State Bar Association's Lawyer Referral Service can connect you with an attorney in your area.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can a restaurant refuse to serve me because I have a DUI on my record?
No. New York State law prohibits public restaurants from refusing service based on a completed criminal conviction. If a restaurant refuses to serve you solely because of your DUI or DWI, that is illegal discrimination. You can file a complaint with the New York State Division of Human Rights.
Will my DUI show up if a restaurant runs a background check on me as a customer?
Restaurants do not run background checks on customers. They run them on job applicants. When you walk into Russ & Daughters or any other cafe to order food, no background check happens. Your record is not checked, and the staff has no way of knowing about it unless you tell them.
Can I lose my job because of a DUI conviction in New York?
It depends on your job. If your work involves driving, handling sensitive information, or working with children, an employer may refuse to hire you or may fire you if they discover a conviction. Most other jobs do not have this restriction. You are not required to disclose a conviction unless an employer specifically asks during the hiring process.
How long does a DUI stay on my record in New York?
A DUI conviction remains on your criminal record permanently unless you are may be able to access for expungement or sealing. may be able to access depends on the specific charge and your criminal history. A criminal defense attorney can tell you whether your conviction can be sealed or expunged and what the process involves.
What should I do if I am denied housing because of my DUI?
Document the refusal and contact the New York State Division of Human Rights at dhr.ny.gov or 1-888-392-3644. Landlords can legally consider criminal convictions, but they must explore their policy consistently and cannot use it as a pretext for discrimination. You can also consult a housing attorney or a legal aid organization to review your specific situation.