You can order a custom sandwich at Subway by choosing your bread, protein, vegetables, and toppings instead of ordering a preset menu item

Subway's "Create Your Own" option lets you build a sandwich from the ground up rather than ordering a named combo. You start by picking your bread type, then add a protein, then vegetables and condiments. The final price depends on which protein you choose — some cost more than others — and whether you add extras like double meat or premium toppings.

This approach costs more than ordering a footlong or six-inch from the value menu, but less than ordering multiple premium items. The exact price varies by location and region, so asking at your local Subway before you order is the fastest way to know what you'll pay.

Key Takeaways

  • You build your sandwich by selecting bread, protein, vegetables, and condiments in that order at the counter.
  • Protein choice determines most of the cost — chicken costs less than steak or seafood, and double meat adds to the price.
  • Prices vary by Subway location and region, so the cost of your custom sandwich is not the same everywhere.
  • You can request modifications like extra vegetables, no onions, or light sauce without additional charge in most cases.
  • Ordering a preset menu item usually costs less than building an equivalent sandwich from scratch.

How the Build-Your-Own Process Works at the Counter

When you tell the employee you want to create your own sandwich, they will ask you to choose your bread first. Subway offers Italian, Italian herbs and cheese, flatbread, and sometimes regional or seasonal options. The bread choice does not change the price — you pay the same whether you pick Italian or herbs and cheese.

Next, you choose your protein. This is where cost differences appear. Chicken breast is the lowest-cost protein option. Turkey, ham, and roast beef fall in the middle range. Steak, bacon, and seafood (shrimp or crab) cost more. If you want double meat, you pay an additional charge on top of the base protein price.

After protein, you move to vegetables. You can load your sandwich with lettuce, tomatoes, cucumbers, onions, peppers, spinach, and other vegetables at no extra cost. The employee will typically ask what vegetables you want and in what quantity — you can request extra of any vegetable without paying more.

Finally, you choose condiments and sauces. Oil, vinegar, salt, pepper, and most sauces (mayo, mustard, ranch, chipotle) do not cost extra. Some locations charge for premium sauces or specialty additions, so ask if you are unsure.

Price Differences Between Proteins and Sandwich Sizes

Your sandwich comes in two sizes: six-inch or footlong. A footlong costs roughly double what a six-inch costs, regardless of protein choice. The protein you select determines the base price for each size.

Chicken breast is the starting price point. Turkey and ham typically cost slightly more than chicken. Roast beef and steak cost more than poultry. Seafood options (shrimp or crab) are usually the most expensive protein choice. Double meat means you pay the protein surcharge twice.

Because prices vary by location and change over time, you cannot know your exact cost without asking your local Subway. Regional pricing, franchise differences, and local market conditions all affect what you pay. Calling ahead or checking the menu board when you arrive is more reliable than assuming a price based on another location.

When Create Your Own Costs More Than Menu Items

Subway's preset menu items — like the Italian BMT or the Turkey Breast six-inch — are usually priced lower than building the same sandwich from scratch. This is because Subway discounts bundled items to encourage customers to order them.

If you build a sandwich with the same ingredients as a menu item, you will likely pay more. For example, ordering a preset Italian BMT footlong costs less than building a footlong with ham, pepperoni, and beef from the create-your-own option, even though the sandwiches are identical.

The create-your-own option makes sense when you want a combination that is not on the menu, or when you want to skip an ingredient that comes standard on a preset item. If you are trying to keep costs down, checking the menu prices first and comparing them to what your custom sandwich would cost is worth the time.

Modifications and Special Requests

You can request changes to your sandwich without paying extra in most cases. Common requests include extra vegetables, no onions, light sauce, or sauce on the side. Subway employees are accustomed to these requests and will honor them as part of the standard build process.

If you want to remove a standard ingredient entirely — for example, ordering a sandwich with no bread (salad-style) — ask the employee whether that changes the price. Most locations will not charge extra, but some may have different pricing for non-standard formats.

Requesting double vegetables or extra toppings that are not normally included (like extra bacon or extra cheese) may trigger an upcharge depending on your location. Ask before the employee starts building your sandwich so you know the final cost.

Comparing Create Your Own to Other Ordering Options

Subway offers three main ways to order: preset menu items, value menu combos, and create your own. Preset items are usually the cheapest because they are discounted bundles. Value menu items offer smaller portions at lower prices. Create your own gives you the most control but typically costs the most.

If you know exactly what you want and it matches a menu item, ordering the menu item saves money. If you want something custom or want to avoid certain ingredients, create your own is your only option — and the cost difference may be worth it to you.

Some locations offer combo deals for create-your-own sandwiches (sandwich plus drink plus chips), which can reduce the total cost compared to ordering items separately. Ask whether your Subway offers this option.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does creating your own sandwich take longer than ordering a menu item?

Yes, usually. Building a sandwich from scratch takes a few extra minutes because the employee has to ask you about each component. During busy times, this can mean a longer wait. Ordering a preset item is faster because the employee already knows what goes on it.

Can I order a create-your-own sandwich online or through the app?

Most Subway locations allow create-your-own orders through their app or website, though the interface varies. You select your bread, protein, vegetables, and toppings in the same order as you would at the counter. Check your local Subway's app to see if this option is available.

What happens if I change my mind about an ingredient after the employee starts building?

You can ask the employee to stop and remove an ingredient or add something different at any point during the build. There is no penalty for changing your mind, though if you ask for major changes after they have already added ingredients, they may need to start over.

Are there any vegetables or toppings that cost extra?

Standard vegetables (lettuce, tomato, cucumber, onion, peppers, spinach) do not cost extra. Some locations charge for premium additions like extra bacon, extra cheese, or specialty sauces. Ask your Subway employee which items, if any, have an upcharge.

Can I get a create-your-own salad instead of a sandwich?

Yes. You can order a salad with the same build-your-own process — choose your base, protein, vegetables, and dressing. Pricing for salads may differ from sandwich pricing at your location, so ask before you order.