The best place to refinance depends on your credit score and how fast you need the money
Credit unions typically offer the lowest rates for borrowers with good or fair credit, while online lenders move fastest and accept lower credit scores. Banks are middle ground — familiar and stable, but often more expensive than credit unions and slower than online lenders. Where you refinance matters because the difference between a 5% rate and a 7% rate on a $20,000 loan costs you real money over the life of the loan. The right choice depends on whether you prioritize the lowest possible rate, speed, or the ability to refinance with damaged credit.
Start by checking your credit score before you shop. Your score determines which lenders will work with you and what rates they'll offer. If you don't know your score, pull it free from AnnualCreditReport.com (the only federally authorized site) or ask your current lender — many show it on your statement or online account.
Key Takeaways
- Credit unions charge lower rates than banks and online lenders on average, but you must be a member and have decent credit to may have access to.
- Online lenders close refinances in days rather than weeks and accept credit scores as low as 580, making them the fastest option for people with poor credit.
- Banks offer familiar service and moderate rates, but typically take longer to close and charge more than credit unions for the same credit profile.
- You should get quotes from at least three lenders before deciding, because rates vary widely even for the same borrower.
- A soft credit inquiry (which doesn't hurt your score) lets you compare rates; only hard inquiries from lenders you're seriously considering will show on your credit report.
Credit unions: lowest rates, membership required
Credit unions consistently offer the lowest refinance rates, often 0.5% to 1.5% lower than banks for the same borrower. They're nonprofit organizations owned by their members, which means they return profits to members through lower rates and fees. The catch: you must be a member to borrow, and membership rules vary by union.
Some credit unions are open to anyone in a geographic area. Others require you to work for a specific employer, belong to a certain organization, or have a family member who's already a member. Start by searching the CO-OP Network or Alliant Credit Union's site to see which unions you can join. If you're not currently a member of any credit union, joining takes a few days and usually costs nothing or a small one-time fee ($5 to $25).
Credit unions typically take 5 to 10 business days to close a refinance once you've submitted your process. They require good or fair credit — most won't work with scores below 620 — and they'll want your current loan documents and proof of income. Call your local credit union directly to ask about their refinance rates and requirements; rates change weekly and vary by loan term.
Online lenders: fastest closing, widest credit range
Online lenders close refinances in 2 to 5 business days, sometimes faster. They accept credit scores as low as 580 and don't require you to be a member of anything. You explore entirely online, upload documents digitally, and get a decision within hours. If you need cash quickly or have damaged credit, this is usually the fastest path.
The tradeoff is rate. Online lenders charge more than credit unions on average — typically 1% to 3% higher — because they accept riskier borrowers and have higher operating costs. Companies like LendingClub, Upgrade, and Lightstream are established players, but dozens of others exist. Rates vary dramatically between lenders, so you must get multiple quotes.
When you explore online, ask whether the lender does a soft inquiry first (which doesn't affect your credit score) or a hard inquiry (which does). Reputable lenders let you see a rate estimate with a soft inquiry before they pull your credit hard. Never give your Social Security number or authorize a hard inquiry until you're ready to move forward with that specific lender.
Banks: familiar service, middle-ground rates
Banks are where most people already have checking accounts, which makes refinancing feel straightforward. Rates are typically 0.5% to 1% higher than credit unions but lower than many online lenders. Closing takes 7 to 14 business days, longer than online lenders but comparable to credit unions.
Banks require good credit (usually 660 or higher) and stable income. They'll ask for your current loan documents, recent pay stubs, and proof of insurance. Some banks offer rate discounts if you have other accounts with them — a checking account or savings account can knock 0.25% off your rate. Ask about this when you call.
The main reason to refinance through your current bank is convenience: they already have your information and your account history. But don't assume they'll offer you the best rate just because you're a customer. Get quotes from at least one credit union and one online lender before accepting your bank's offer.
How to compare offers across lenders
Get quotes from at least three lenders — one credit union, one online lender, and one bank — before you decide. Each quote should show the interest rate, the monthly payment, the total interest you'll pay over the life of the loan, and any fees (origination, prepayment penalties, or closing costs).
When comparing, look at the total cost, not just the monthly payment. A lower monthly payment sometimes means a longer loan term, which means you pay more interest overall. Use an online car loan calculator to see the total interest cost for each offer. A 0.5% rate difference might save you $500 to $1,000 over five years.
Ask each lender whether they charge an origination fee (usually 0% to 3% of the loan amount) or prepayment penalty (a fee if you pay off the loan early). Some lenders advertise low rates but charge high fees; others charge no fees but higher rates. The total cost is what matters.
What to do if your credit is damaged
If your credit score is below 620, credit unions and most banks won't work with you. Online lenders are your main option. Companies like LendingClub, Upgrade, and Lightstream work with scores as low as 580, though your rate will be higher — often 8% to 12% or more depending on how low your score is.
Before you refinance with poor credit, consider whether refinancing makes sense. If your current loan has only a year or two left, the savings might not justify the cost of a new loan. If you have several years left and your current rate is very high (10% or more), refinancing could still save money even at a higher rate than someone with good credit would get.
Some online lenders also offer credit-building tools or report your on-time payments to the credit bureaus, which can help rebuild your score over time. Ask whether the lender reports to all three bureaus (Equifax, Experian, and TransUnion) before you commit.
Red flags and what to avoid
Avoid lenders who may provide a rate without a hard inquiry, promise to refinance regardless of credit, or pressure you to decide quickly. Legitimate lenders always do a hard inquiry before offering a final rate, and they give you time to think.
Don't refinance with a lender that charges a prepayment penalty unless the rate savings are substantial enough to justify it. Prepayment penalties lock you into the loan and cost you money if you want to refinance again or pay off the car early.
Watch out for lenders that advertise "no credit check" refinancing. This usually means they're not checking your credit at all, which is a sign they're either not legitimate or they're charging rates so high that they don't care about your creditworthiness. Stick with established lenders you can verify through the Better Business Bureau or your state's banking regulator.
Frequently Asked Questions
How many times can I refinance my car loan?
There's no legal limit, but lenders get cautious after two or three refinances in a short time. Each refinance involves a hard inquiry that temporarily lowers your credit score. Refinance when rates drop significantly or your credit improves, not just to lower your payment by $20 a month.
Will refinancing hurt my credit score?
The hard inquiry will lower your score by 5 to 10 points temporarily. But if you make on-time payments on the new loan, your score usually recovers within a few months. The long-term benefit of a lower rate often outweighs the short-term hit.
Can I refinance if I'm underwater on my loan?
It depends on the lender. If you owe more than the car is worth, most lenders won't refinance because they have no collateral if you default. Some credit unions and online lenders will work with you if you have good credit and a stable income, but rates will be higher. Ask each lender directly.
What documents do I need to refinance?
You'll need your current loan documents (showing the balance and interest rate), proof of income (recent pay stubs or tax returns), proof of insurance, and your vehicle's title or registration. Have these ready before you explore so you can move quickly once you find a lender.
Should I refinance with my current lender?
Not automatically. Your current lender has no incentive to offer you their best rate — they already have your business. Always get quotes from at least two other lenders. You might find a better rate elsewhere, and the threat of leaving sometimes prompts your current lender to match or beat outside offers.