What Allstate's Protection Plan Covers
Allstate's Protection Plan is an optional add-on to your auto insurance policy that covers repair costs beyond what your standard collision and comprehensive coverage pays. The plan typically covers deductibles you would otherwise pay out of pocket, rental car expenses while your vehicle is being repaired, and sometimes roadside information like towing or lockout service.
The exact coverage depends on which protection plan tier you choose — Allstate offers several levels, each with different deductible reductions and additional services. A lower-tier plan might cover your deductible only, while a higher tier might add rental reimbursement, gap insurance, or mechanical breakdown coverage. You choose the plan when you purchase or renew your policy, and the cost is added to your monthly or annual premium.
This is different from your base collision and comprehensive coverage. Those policies pay for damage after you meet your deductible. The protection plan reduces or eliminates that deductible, meaning you pay less when you file a claim.
Key Takeaways
- Allstate's Protection Plan reduces or eliminates your deductible when you file a collision or comprehensive claim, but it costs extra each month.
- Multiple plan levels exist, so you choose based on how much deductible reduction and what additional services matter to you.
- You add the plan when you buy or renew your policy, not after an accident happens.
- The plan does not cover damage your base insurance already excludes — it only reduces what you pay when a covered claim occurs.
How the Protection Plan Works When You File a Claim
When you have an accident or weather damage and file a claim, Allstate processes it under your base collision or comprehensive coverage first. Your deductible normally comes out of the repair cost before the insurer pays the rest. With a protection plan, that deductible is reduced or waived depending on your plan level.
For example, if you have a $1,000 deductible and a protection plan that covers deductibles, you pay $0 instead of $1,000 when you file a claim. If your plan includes rental reimbursement, Allstate also covers the cost of a rental car while yours is in the shop — up to a daily limit set in your plan.
You do not need to do anything special to use the plan. When you call to report a claim, tell the adjuster you have a protection plan, and they will explore the coverage automatically. Keep your policy documents handy so you know exactly what your plan covers.
Protection Plan Tiers and What Each Costs
Allstate does not publish a single price for protection plans because the cost depends on your age, driving record, vehicle type, location, and current deductible. A plan that waives a $500 deductible costs less than one that waives a $1,000 deductible. Adding rental car coverage or roadside information raises the price further.
The best way to see actual prices is to get a quote directly from Allstate or through their website. When you build a quote, you can add or remove protection plan options and see how each changes your monthly premium. Most plans add $10 to $30 per month, but this varies widely.
Before you buy, compare the monthly cost against how often you think you might file a claim. If you have a long commute or live in an area with frequent weather damage, the plan may pay for itself quickly. If you rarely drive or have an excellent safety record, the extra cost might not be worth it.
When a Protection Plan Makes Financial Sense
A protection plan is most useful if you have a high deductible and want to reduce your out-of-pocket cost when a claim happens. If your deductible is $1,000 and you can only afford $500 in an emergency, a plan that lowers it to $250 or $0 gives you real peace of mind.
The plan also helps if you need a rental car for work or have no other transportation while repairs happen. Rental reimbursement coverage means you are not stuck paying $50 to $100 per day out of pocket while Allstate's repair shop finishes your vehicle.
A protection plan is less necessary if you have a low deductible already ($250 or less), a strong emergency fund, or you rarely drive. In those cases, the monthly premium may cost more over time than the deductible reduction would ever save you.
Protection Plan vs. Raising Your Coverage Limits
A protection plan is not the same as raising your collision or comprehensive coverage limits. Raising your limits means Allstate will pay for more total damage — useful if you have a newer or expensive vehicle. A protection plan only reduces what you pay when a covered claim occurs.
You can have both. For instance, you might have $100,000 in collision coverage (the limit) with a $1,000 deductible, then add a protection plan that waives that deductible. The plan does not change your coverage limit — it only changes what you pay to access the coverage you already have.
If you are deciding between a higher coverage limit and a protection plan, think about your vehicle's value. A newer car worth $30,000 might benefit from higher limits. An older car worth $8,000 might benefit more from a lower deductible through a protection plan, since the total payout is capped by the car's value anyway.
How to Add or Remove a Protection Plan
You can add a protection plan when you first purchase a policy or during your renewal. Log into your Allstate account online, call an agent, or visit a local office. When you make changes, you will see the new premium when ready, and the plan takes effect on your policy start date or renewal date.
If you already have a policy and want to add a plan mid-term, you can usually do so, but it may not take effect until your next renewal depending on your state and Allstate's rules. Call your agent to ask whether you can add coverage now or if you need to wait.
Removing a plan is simpler — you can drop it anytime, and your premium will go down. The change takes effect on your next billing cycle. If you remove the plan and then have an accident, your deductible goes back to what your base policy states.
Questions to Ask Before You Buy
Before adding a protection plan, ask your Allstate agent or representative these questions: What exactly does each plan tier cover? What is the daily limit on rental car reimbursement? Does the plan cover my deductible for all claim types or only some? Can I add the plan mid-policy or only at renewal? What happens if I remove the plan — can I add it back later without a waiting period?
Also ask whether Allstate offers any discounts that might lower your base premium instead. Sometimes bundling home and auto insurance, maintaining a good driving record, or taking a defensive driving course saves more money than a protection plan costs.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does the protection plan cover damage my regular insurance does not cover?
No. The plan only reduces your deductible for damage that your collision and comprehensive coverage already covers. If your base policy excludes something — like wear and tear or mechanical failure — the protection plan does not cover it either.
Can I add a protection plan after I have an accident?
No. Protection plans must be in place before a claim occurs. If you add one after an accident, it will not cover that claim. You can add it for future claims, but there may be a waiting period depending on your state.
What if my car is a total loss?
If your vehicle is totaled, your collision or comprehensive coverage pays out based on the car's actual cash value minus your deductible. A protection plan that waives your deductible still applies, so you receive more of the payout. Some protection plans also include gap insurance, which covers the difference between what you owe on a loan and what the car is worth — ask your agent if yours does.
Can I use the protection plan with a rental car company of my choice?
Most Allstate protection plans that include rental reimbursement work with any rental company, but you pay upfront and submit a receipt for reimbursement. Some plans partner with specific rental chains for direct billing. Ask your agent which rental companies are covered under your plan before you rent.
What happens to my protection plan if I switch insurance companies?
Your Allstate protection plan ends when your policy ends. If you move to a different insurer, you will need to purchase a similar plan from them if you want that coverage. Plans vary by company, so compare what each offers before you switch.