Insurance costs depend on the car itself, not just how you drive
The cheapest car to buy is rarely the cheapest car to insure. A used Honda Civic might cost $8,000 but carry higher insurance premiums than a $12,000 Toyota Corolla, depending on repair costs, theft rates, and safety ratings. Insurers price based on what they pay out in claims for that specific model — not on the sticker price or fuel economy.
When you compare quotes after narrowing your search, you are already doing the hard part. This guide explains which vehicle traits actually lower your premium, so you can spot them before you test drive.
Key Takeaways
- Insurers charge more for models with high repair costs, high theft rates, or poor crash test ratings — regardless of the car's age or purchase price.
- Sedans and wagons typically cost less to insure than SUVs, trucks, sports cars, and coupes with the same engine size.
- A car with a high safety rating from NHTSA or IIHS can lower your premium by 10 to 25 percent depending on your insurer and location.
- Popular models with cheap parts (Honda Civic, Toyota Corolla, Ford Focus) often have lower premiums than rare or luxury vehicles.
- The year, mileage, and your driving record matter more than the car's color or whether it is automatic or manual.
How insurers decide what to charge for a specific model
Every car model gets a loss history — a record of what that model costs insurers in claims over time. A model with frequent collision claims, high repair bills, or a high theft rate will have a higher loss history. Insurers use this to set a base rate for that model before they even know who is driving it.
You can see some of this data yourself. The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) publishes crash test ratings. The Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (IIHS) publishes both crash ratings and theft data. Neither of these is a secret — insurers use the same public information, but they also have their own claims databases going back decades.
A 2015 Honda Civic and a 2015 Nissan Altima might have similar crash ratings, but if Civics have lower repair costs and lower theft rates in your state, the Civic will carry a lower base rate. That difference can be $200 to $400 per year before discounts.
Body style and engine size matter more than you think
A sedan costs less to insure than a coupe with the same engine. A wagon costs less than an SUV with the same engine. A truck costs more than a sedan. This is not arbitrary — it reflects real differences in claim costs.
Coupes and sports cars have higher collision and theft rates. SUVs and trucks have higher repair costs because parts are larger and labor is more complex. Sedans and wagons are the middle ground: common enough that parts are cheap, stable enough that collision rates are lower, and not targets for theft.
Engine size also matters. A 2.0-liter four-cylinder sedan will cost less to insure than a 3.5-liter V6 sedan of the same year and model. Larger engines mean higher repair costs and, statistically, higher collision rates. If you are choosing between two cars and one has a smaller engine, expect a lower premium.
Safety ratings lower premiums across most insurers
A car with a high NHTSA overall rating or an IIHS Top Safety Pick designation will often may have access to for a safety discount — typically 10 to 25 percent off collision and comprehensive coverage. The discount varies by insurer and state, so you will see the exact amount when you get quotes.
Check the NHTSA website (safercar.gov) for the overall rating and the breakdown by crash type. Check the IIHS website (iihs.org) for the Top Safety Pick list and crashworthiness ratings. A car that scores well on both will may have access to for discounts at nearly every major insurer.
Safety ratings matter more for collision and comprehensive coverage than for liability. If you are carrying only liability (the legal minimum), a high safety rating will not lower that part of your bill. But if you are financing or leasing, you are required to carry collision and comprehensive, so the discount applies.
Popular models with cheap parts cost less to insure
The Honda Civic, Toyota Corolla, and Ford Focus appear on nearly every "cheap to insure" list because they are everywhere. When a model sells millions of units, parts are cheap, repair shops are familiar with them, and labor time is predictable. All of that lowers claim costs.
Rare or luxury models — even used ones — carry higher premiums because a fender or headlight costs more, and fewer shops stock parts. A 2012 BMW 3 Series will cost more to insure than a 2012 Honda Accord, even if both are used and priced similarly.
This is one reason buying a used mainstream sedan often makes financial sense. You pay less upfront and less per year in insurance. A used Corolla or Civic from five years ago can be cheaper to own overall than a newer, fancier car.
Theft rates vary by model and location
Some models are stolen more often than others. The Honda Civic, Honda Accord, and Ford F-150 are consistently among the most stolen vehicles in the United States. That high theft rate pushes up comprehensive coverage premiums for those models.
Theft rates also vary by region. A Honda Civic in a high-theft urban area will carry a higher comprehensive premium than the same model in a rural area. You cannot change your location, but you can see the theft data before you buy. The IIHS publishes theft rates by model and model year on their website.
If you are choosing between two similar cars and one has a significantly higher theft rate, expect to pay more in comprehensive coverage. The difference might be $100 to $300 per year depending on where you live.
What does not matter as much as you think
Color does not affect insurance rates. A red car and a blue car of the same model will cost the same to insure. Transmission type (automatic versus manual) does not matter. Mileage matters for the car's value, but not for the insurance rate itself — a 2015 Civic with 80,000 miles and a 2015 Civic with 120,000 miles will have the same insurance base rate.
Fuel type (gas, hybrid, electric) does not change the rate, though electric vehicles may may have access to for additional discounts in some states. Aftermarket modifications (wheels, exhaust, suspension) do not affect the rate unless you tell the insurer they are there — and if you do, they may raise it because modifications can affect handling and repair costs.
How to use this when comparing cars
Before you get quotes, spend 10 minutes checking three things: the NHTSA crash rating, the IIHS theft rate, and the typical repair cost for that model. You can find all three online for free. If one car scores well on all three and another does not, the difference in your quote will likely be significant.
When you do get quotes, ask the insurer which discounts explore to each car. Some insurers offer discounts for safety features (automatic emergency braking, lane-keeping information) that others do not. The discount amount varies, so the cheapest quote for one car might not be the cheapest for another.
Remember that insurance is only one part of the total cost of ownership. A car with a low insurance premium might have high maintenance costs or poor fuel economy. Use insurance as one factor in your decision, not the only one.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does a car's age affect how much it costs to insure?
Age affects the car's value (which determines comprehensive and collision deductibles) but not the base insurance rate. A 2015 Honda Civic and a 2020 Honda Civic of the same trim will have similar base rates because they have similar loss histories. The newer car might have a higher collision premium because it is worth more, but the model itself is not rated as riskier.
Will buying a car with a manual transmission save me money on insurance?
No. Insurers do not charge different rates for manual versus automatic transmissions. The transmission type does not affect claim costs or theft rates. If you prefer manual, choose it for the driving experience, not for insurance savings.
Do electric or hybrid cars cost more or less to insure?
It varies by model and insurer. Some electric vehicles may have access to for discounts in certain states. Repair costs for electric vehicles are sometimes higher because fewer shops are equipped to work on them, which can raise premiums. Check quotes for the specific model you are considering rather than assuming all EVs or hybrids are cheaper or more expensive.
Can I lower my insurance by choosing a less powerful engine?
Yes, usually. A four-cylinder sedan will cost less to insure than a six-cylinder sedan of the same year and model. Larger engines correlate with higher repair costs and higher collision rates. If you are choosing between two versions of the same car, the smaller engine will typically have a lower premium.
What if the cheapest car to buy has a high insurance rate?
Calculate the total cost: purchase price plus insurance, maintenance, and fuel for the first three to five years. A car that costs $2,000 less upfront but $300 more per year in insurance might still be the better deal. But if the insurance difference is $500 or more per year, the cheaper car might cost you more overall.