Why Some Cars Cost Less to Insure Than Others

Insurance companies charge based on what it costs them to repair or replace your car after a claim, how often that car gets stolen, and how often drivers of that model end up in accidents. A Honda Civic costs less to insure than a BMW M440i because repair parts are cheaper, theft is less common, and the accident history for Civics is better. A Subaru Outback costs less than a Dodge Charger because Outback drivers file fewer claims overall. The car itself—not just your age or driving record—determines a significant part of your premium.

The cheapest cars to insure share three traits: they are common (so parts are inexpensive and mechanics know how to fix them), they have good safety ratings (which reduces injury claims), and they attract drivers with lower accident rates. A ten-year-old Toyota Corolla meets all three. A sports car or luxury sedan, even if it is old, usually does not.

Key Takeaways

  • Common sedans and hatchbacks like the Honda Civic, Toyota Corolla, and Hyundai Elantra cost less to insure because repair parts are cheap and widely available.
  • Vehicles with high safety ratings and low theft rates—typically mainstream brands rather than luxury or performance models—keep insurance premiums lower.
  • Older model years of reliable cars often cost less to insure than newer sports cars or luxury vehicles, even if the older car is less safe.
  • Your actual premium depends on your age, driving history, location, and coverage choices, so comparing quotes from multiple insurers is the only way to know your real cost.

Sedans That Cost Less to Insure

The Honda Civic, Toyota Corolla, and Hyundai Elantra are the three most common affordable sedans on the road. All three have large parts inventories, low repair costs, and strong safety records. Insurance companies see millions of claims on these models, so they have precise data on what goes wrong and how much it costs to fix. That certainty keeps premiums down.

The Nissan Altima and Kia Forte also fall into this category. Both are mainstream, widely repaired, and attract drivers who file fewer claims than owners of performance or luxury sedans. A 2015 Corolla will cost less to insure than a 2015 Infiniti Q50, even though the Infiniti is newer and has more safety features, because Infiniti repair costs are higher and Infiniti owners have a different accident profile.

Avoid sedans marketed as "sporty" or "performance" versions—the Dodge Charger, Chrysler 300, or Infiniti Q50—because insurance companies charge more for them regardless of age. These models attract younger drivers and drivers with more aggressive driving patterns, which raises claims frequency.

Hatchbacks and Compact Cars

Hatchbacks like the Honda Fit, Toyota Corolla Hatchback, and Hyundai Elantra GT are cheaper to insure than their sedan counterparts because they are lighter, have lower repair costs, and appeal to practical drivers rather than performance-focused ones. The Fit in particular has one of the lowest insurance costs in its class because it is so common and so inexpensive to repair.

The Mazda3 hatchback sits in the middle: it costs slightly more to insure than a Civic or Fit because Mazda parts are less universally available, but it is still well below luxury or performance hatchbacks. The Mini Cooper, by contrast, costs significantly more to insure despite being small, because Mini parts are expensive and Mini owners file more claims.

Used Model Years That Keep Premiums Low

A 2012 Honda Civic will cost less to insure than a 2020 Honda Civic because the older car is worth less and therefore costs less to replace. However, the difference is smaller than you might expect—insurance is based partly on repair cost, not just replacement value. A 2012 Civic with 120,000 miles still has cheap parts and a clear repair history, so the premium stays low.

The sweet spot for cheap insurance is usually five to ten years old. The car is old enough that its value has dropped significantly, but new enough that parts are still common and mechanics are familiar with the model. A 2016 Toyota Corolla will cost less to insure than a 2022 Corolla, and less than a 2010 Corolla (which may have parts availability issues or higher repair costs due to age-related wear).

Avoid very old cars with low market value if they have poor safety ratings or are no longer in wide production. A 2005 Pontiac Grand Am might seem cheap to insure because it is worth almost nothing, but some insurers will charge more because the safety features are outdated and repair shops may struggle to find parts.

What to Avoid if You Want Lower Premiums

Sports cars and performance models cost more to insure regardless of age or actual performance. A Dodge Charger, Chevrolet Camaro, or Ford Mustang will have higher premiums than a Honda Accord, even if both are the same year. Insurance companies use model history, not just individual car condition, to set rates. Drivers of these cars file more claims, so the entire model class costs more.

Luxury brands—BMW, Audi, Mercedes-Benz, Lexus—cost more to insure because parts are expensive, repair shops charge more labor, and replacement vehicles are costly. A ten-year-old BMW 3 Series will cost more to insure than a new Honda Civic, because a fender for the BMW costs three times as much and takes longer to install.

Trucks and SUVs cost more to insure than sedans of the same age and brand, partly because they are heavier and cause more damage in accidents, and partly because they are more often stolen. A Ford F-150 costs more than a Ford Fusion. A Jeep Wrangler costs more than a Honda CR-V, even though both are SUVs, because Wranglers are frequently stolen.

How to Compare Your Actual Cost

Your insurance premium depends on the car, but also on your age, driving history, location, coverage limits, and deductible. A 25-year-old with a speeding ticket will pay more for a Honda Civic than a 45-year-old with a clean record, even though the car is the same. A driver in a rural area pays less than a driver in a city where theft and accidents are more common.

The only way to know what a specific car will cost you is to get quotes from multiple insurers. Most insurers offer free quotes online in minutes. Enter the car's year, make, model, and VIN, along with your driving history and coverage choices. Compare the quotes side by side. You may find that one insurer charges significantly less for the same car and coverage than another.

When comparing, keep your coverage limits and deductible the same across all quotes. A $500 deductible will always be cheaper than a $250 deductible, but that does not mean the insurer is cheaper overall. Adjust the variables one at a time so you can see what actually changes the price.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does a hybrid or electric car cost more or less to insure?

Hybrids like the Toyota Prius cost about the same or slightly less to insure as their gas-only counterparts because parts are becoming more common and repair data is solid. Electric vehicles vary widely—a Tesla Model 3 costs more because parts are expensive and specialized, while a Nissan Leaf costs less because it is simpler and cheaper to repair. Get a quote on the specific model you are considering.

Will buying a cheap car to insure save me money overall?

Not always. A very old cheap car may have high repair costs outside of insurance, poor fuel economy, and frequent breakdowns. A five-year-old Honda Civic with low mileage may cost more upfront but less per year when you factor in insurance, maintenance, and fuel. Calculate your total cost of ownership, not just insurance.

Can I lower my insurance by choosing a different trim level of the same car?

Sometimes. A base Honda Civic may cost slightly less to insure than a fully loaded Civic Si, because the Si is marketed as a performance version and attracts different drivers. However, the difference is usually small—maybe 5 to 10 percent. The bigger factor is the model itself, not the trim.

Does the color of the car affect insurance cost?

No. Insurance companies do not charge different rates based on color, despite the myth that red cars cost more. They charge based on the model, year, and your personal driving history. Color does not appear on your insurance quote.

What if I buy a car that is cheap to insure but gets poor gas mileage?

You will save on insurance but spend more on fuel. A 2015 Dodge Charger might be cheap to insure in some cases, but it gets 16 to 25 miles per gallon depending on driving. A Honda Civic gets 28 to 38 miles per gallon. Calculate fuel cost over the year and add it to your insurance quote to see the real total.