What "best rated" means and why it matters

Car insurance ratings come from three separate sources, and they measure different things. J.D. Power measures customer satisfaction after a claim. AM Best measures financial strength — whether the company can actually pay claims. National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC) tracks complaint ratios, which show how many complaints a company gets per policy sold. A company can rank high on one scale and lower on another, so knowing which rating answers your actual question matters.

When you see "best rated" in marketing, it usually means one of these three. The company is telling the truth, but it is also choosing the metric where it performs best. You need to know what you are actually looking at before you decide whether that rating means anything to you.

Key Takeaways

  • J.D. Power customer satisfaction ratings reflect how people feel after filing a claim, not whether premiums are low or coverage is broad.
  • AM Best financial strength ratings tell you the company can pay claims, but say nothing about customer service or how fast claims move.
  • NAIC complaint ratios show how many complaints per 1,000 policies a company receives, and lower is better, but the ratio varies widely by state.
  • A company rated highly by one source may rank differently on another, so read which metric is being claimed before assuming it matches what you care about.
  • Your own experience with a company matters more than any national rating — price, local agent availability, and how they handle your specific claim type are what you will actually live with.

J.D. Power customer satisfaction scores

J.D. Power publishes an annual U.S. Auto Insurance Study that ranks companies on how satisfied customers are after filing a claim. The study surveys people who have recently gone through the claims process and asks about ease of filing, speed of payment, and whether the company treated them fairly. Scores range from around 700 to 850 points, and higher is better.

This rating tells you something real: it reflects actual customer experience with claims. But it does not tell you about your premium, your coverage options, or how the company treats you before you have a problem. It also does not measure whether the company will be in business in five years or whether it will deny your claim. If you file a claim often or you are very concerned about the claims experience, this rating is worth checking. If you rarely file claims, it matters less.

AM Best financial strength ratings

AM Best is a credit-rating agency for insurance companies. It assigns letter grades — A++, A+, A, B++, and so on — based on whether the company has enough money to pay all the claims it receives. An A or A+ rating means the company is financially stable. A B rating means it is still solvent but weaker. Anything below B is a warning sign.

This rating answers one question only: will the company be able to pay your claim when the time comes? It does not measure customer service, claims speed, or whether you will like dealing with them. Every major insurance company you have heard of carries an A or A+ rating. If you are comparing a large national company to a smaller regional one, checking AM Best is worth a few minutes to make sure the smaller company is not in financial trouble.

NAIC complaint ratios and what they show

The National Association of Insurance Commissioners publishes complaint data by company and state. The ratio shows how many complaints the NAIC received per 1,000 policies sold. A company with a ratio of 0.5 receives half as many complaints per policy as a company with a ratio of 1.0. The national average varies by year but typically falls between 0.6 and 0.8.

This number is useful because it is based on actual complaints filed with a regulator, not on a survey or a company's own data. But the ratio varies significantly by state — a company might have a low ratio in one state and a higher one in another. Complaints also skew toward claims disputes and billing problems, so a high ratio might mean the company denies claims more often, or it might mean the company has poor billing systems. You cannot tell from the ratio alone.

How ratings differ by company and what to compare

Large national companies like State Farm, Geico, and Progressive typically rank in the middle to upper range on J.D. Power scores, carry A or A+ AM Best ratings, and have complaint ratios near or slightly below the national average. Regional companies and newer online-only insurers vary more widely — some rank very high on customer satisfaction, others lower. No single company ranks first on all three metrics.

When you are comparing companies, pull the specific rating for your state if you can. NAIC data is state-specific, and J.D. Power publishes regional breakdowns. A company's national average may not match its performance where you live. You can find NAIC complaint ratios on your state insurance commissioner's website, J.D. Power scores on their website, and AM Best ratings on their website or by asking the company directly.

What ratings do not tell you about price and coverage

None of these ratings measure whether a company's premiums are competitive or whether its coverage options fit your needs. A highly rated company might charge more than a lower-rated one. A company with excellent claims service might offer fewer discount options. Ratings are one piece of information, not the whole picture.

The most useful approach is to get quotes from three to five companies, check their ratings on the metrics that matter to you, and then decide based on both price and reputation. If two companies quote you similar prices and one has a noticeably better J.D. Power score, that difference might be worth paying attention to. If one company is significantly cheaper but has a higher complaint ratio, you have a real trade-off to weigh.

How to find and read ratings yourself

Start with your state insurance commissioner's website. Every state publishes NAIC complaint data, usually in a searchable database. Search for the companies you are considering and note their complaint ratios. Next, visit J.D. Power's website and look for their latest U.S. Auto Insurance Study. The study ranks companies nationally and by region. Finally, visit AM Best's website or call the companies directly and ask for their financial strength rating.

Write down the three numbers for each company you are considering. Do not weight them equally — decide which one matters most to you. If claims experience is your priority, J.D. Power matters most. If you are worried the company might not survive a major disaster, AM Best matters most. If you want to avoid a company with a pattern of complaints, NAIC ratios matter most. Then use that priority to narrow your choice.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can a company have a good J.D. Power score but a high complaint ratio?

Yes. J.D. Power surveys people who filed claims and asks about their experience. NAIC complaints include billing disputes, coverage questions, and claim denials. A company might handle claims well but have poor billing systems, or vice versa. Check both numbers to get the full picture.

What does an AM Best rating of A mean versus A+?

Both A and A+ mean the company is financially strong and can pay claims. A+ is slightly stronger, but both are considered safe. Anything below A is less common among major insurers and worth asking about. You can ask your agent or call the company directly for their current rating.

Do complaint ratios change year to year?

Yes. A company's ratio can improve or worsen depending on how many complaints it receives and how many policies it sells. Check the most recent year available on your state commissioner's website. If a company's ratio has been rising for several years, that is worth noting.

Should I only buy insurance from a company with the highest ratings?

No. The highest-rated company might not offer the best price for your situation, and price matters. A company with good but not top ratings might serve you better if the premium is significantly lower. Use ratings to rule out companies with serious red flags, then compare price among the remaining options.

Where do online insurance companies rank on these ratings?

Online-only companies vary widely. Some rank very high on J.D. Power and have low complaint ratios. Others rank lower. Check the specific company you are considering rather than assuming all online insurers perform the same way. They all carry AM Best ratings, which you can verify before buying.