What customer ratings actually tell you about an insurance company
Customer ratings measure how people feel about their experience with a company — how quickly claims get paid, whether the agent answers the phone, whether the bill matches what you were quoted. They do not measure whether the company will be solvent when you file a claim, or whether the policy language favors you in a dispute. Both matter, but they measure different things.
The most widely used ratings come from J.D. Power (which surveys customers about their experience), the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (which tracks complaints filed against each company), and the Better Business Bureau (which logs complaints and how the company responds). Each one ranks companies differently because each one asks a different question. A company might score high on speed but low on complaint handling, or vice versa.
When you see a company advertised as "highly rated," check which rating system they mean. A company ranked high by J.D. Power may not rank high by NAIC complaint data. Read the actual numbers — a company with 4.5 stars from 200 reviews tells you something different than one with 4.5 stars from 8,000 reviews.
Key Takeaways
- J.D. Power, NAIC complaint ratios, and the Better Business Bureau each measure different aspects of how an insurance company treats customers, so check which rating system a company is citing.
- Complaint ratios from the NAIC show how many complaints a company gets per policy sold, which accounts for company size — a large company with many complaints may still have a lower ratio than a small one.
- The lowest price and the highest customer rating often belong to different companies, so decide whether you prioritize cost, service speed, or claims handling before comparing.
- State insurance regulators publish complaint data and financial ratings, so you can verify a company's track record without relying on the company's own marketing.
Where to find official customer complaint data
The National Association of Insurance Commissioners publishes a complaint index that shows how many complaints each company receives per 1,000 policies sold. This number accounts for company size — a company with 100,000 policies and 50 complaints has a lower ratio than a company with 10,000 policies and 40 complaints, even though it received more total complaints. You can search by company name and state at the NAIC website.
Each state's insurance commissioner also publishes complaint data specific to that state. If you live in California, you can see how State Farm, Geico, and others perform in California specifically, which may differ from their national average. State regulators also publish financial ratings that show whether a company has enough money to pay claims — this is separate from customer satisfaction but equally important.
J.D. Power publishes annual rankings of home and auto insurers based on customer surveys. Their rankings break down by region (Northeast, Midwest, South, West) and by company size, so you can see how a company performs in your area specifically. The survey measures claims handling, billing accuracy, and ease of contact, among other factors.
How to read complaint ratios and what they mean
A complaint ratio of 0.50 means the company received 0.50 complaints per 1,000 policies. A ratio of 1.25 means 1.25 complaints per 1,000 policies. Lower is better. The national average varies by year and by line of insurance (home complaints and auto complaints are tracked separately), but a ratio below 1.0 is generally considered good, and above 2.0 suggests the company receives more complaints than average.
Complaint ratios do not tell you whether the complaints were valid or how the company resolved them. A company might receive many complaints because it denies more claims than competitors, or because it has a difficult claims process, or because it attracts customers who file more claims. The Better Business Bureau tracks not just the number of complaints but how the company responds to them — whether they resolve disputes or ignore them.
One large complaint can skew the ratio if a company is small. If a company has 5,000 policies and receives 10 complaints, that is a ratio of 2.0. If another company has 500,000 policies and receives 1,000 complaints, that is a ratio of 2.0 as well — but the second company's experience is based on far more data. Look at both the ratio and the total number of complaints before deciding.
Differences between home and auto insurance ratings
A company might rank high for auto insurance but lower for home insurance, or vice versa. Geico, for example, is often rated highly for auto claims handling but may rank differently for homeowners claims. State Farm ranks high for availability and local service but may not rank lowest on price. Check ratings separately for the type of insurance you need.
Home insurance complaints often center on claim denials, coverage disputes, and the time it takes to settle. Auto insurance complaints often center on billing, quote accuracy, and claims speed. A company that excels at paying auto claims quickly may have a slower process for home damage claims, which are typically more complex.
Regional differences matter more for home insurance than auto insurance. A company might be highly rated in Florida (where hurricane claims are common) but less experienced in Colorado (where hail claims are common). Check your state's specific data rather than relying on national rankings alone.
What ratings do not tell you about price
A highly rated company is not necessarily the cheapest. Some companies keep prices low by handling claims more strictly or by using online-only service. Others charge more but employ local agents and process claims faster. The company with the best customer ratings might cost 30 percent more than the company with average ratings for the same coverage.
Price also varies dramatically by your personal situation — your age, driving record, home location, and claims history. A company that offers the lowest rate for a 35-year-old with a clean record in a suburban area might not offer the lowest rate for a 65-year-old with one accident in a rural area. You need quotes from multiple companies to know which one is cheapest for you specifically.
Some companies specialize in customers that others consider high-risk. A company with lower overall ratings might have excellent ratings from customers in your specific situation — for example, customers over 55, or customers with one prior accident. Read reviews from people in your demographic, not just the overall average.
How to use ratings alongside price quotes
Start by getting quotes from at least three companies. Then look up the complaint ratio and J.D. Power ranking for each one. Create a straightforward table: company name, quote amount, complaint ratio, and J.D. Power rank. This shows you the trade-off between price and service quality for your specific situation.
If two companies quote within 10 percent of each other, the one with better ratings is usually the better choice — the difference in price is small enough that better service is worth it. If one company quotes significantly lower (20 percent or more), decide whether the savings are worth accepting a higher complaint ratio. Only you can make that choice.
Read a few actual customer reviews on Google, the Better Business Bureau, or Trustpilot, but focus on reviews from people in your situation. A review from someone who had a major claim is more relevant to you than a review from someone who only paid premiums and never filed. Look for patterns — if multiple people mention slow claims processing, that is a real issue. If one person complains about a single bad agent, that may not reflect the company overall.
State insurance regulators and financial stability ratings
Your state's insurance commissioner publishes not just complaint data but also financial ratings that show whether a company has enough reserves to pay claims. A.M. Best and Standard & Poor's also rate insurance companies' financial strength. A company with excellent customer ratings but weak financial ratings is risky — if they go insolvent, your claims may not be paid in full.
Most large national insurers are financially stable, but smaller regional companies vary. Before choosing a company you have never heard of, spend two minutes checking its financial rating on your state's insurance commissioner website or on A.M. Best's website. You want to see a rating of A or higher.
Your state also has a guaranty fund that protects policyholders if an insurer fails, but the protection has limits and takes time. It is far better to choose a financially stable company from the start than to rely on the guaranty fund later.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I trust online review sites like Google and Trustpilot for insurance ratings?
Online reviews are useful for spotting patterns — if dozens of people mention slow claims processing, that is real — but they are not representative. People who had a good experience often do not leave reviews. People who had one bad interaction may leave a harsh review. Use online reviews to ask specific questions (like "How long did your claim take?"), but rely on NAIC complaint ratios and J.D. Power rankings for overall company performance.
What does it mean if a company has a high complaint ratio but good J.D. Power ratings?
It usually means the company receives many complaints but resolves them to customers' satisfaction. J.D. Power measures satisfaction with the resolution process, not the number of complaints. A company might deny more claims than competitors (leading to more complaints) but handle the denial process professionally (leading to good satisfaction ratings). Check both numbers to understand the full picture.
Should I choose the lowest-rated company if they quote significantly lower?
That depends on your risk tolerance and financial situation. If you have never filed a claim and do not expect to, a lower-rated company might be fine. If you have filed claims before or live in an area with frequent weather damage, the better-rated company is usually worth the extra cost. Run the numbers: if the difference is $200 per year but the lower-rated company has twice the complaint ratio, is $200 worth the risk?
How often do insurance company ratings change?
NAIC complaint data is updated monthly, so a company's ratio can shift throughout the year. J.D. Power publishes new rankings annually, usually in the spring for auto and summer for home. Financial ratings are updated as needed when a company's financial situation changes. Check current data before you buy, not data from last year.
Do I need to check ratings in my specific state, or are national ratings enough?
Check your state's data. A company might rank high nationally but have a higher complaint ratio in your state, or vice versa. State regulators also know which companies are licensed to sell in your state and which have had enforcement actions. Your state's insurance commissioner website is the most reliable source for your specific situation.