Cars that cost less to insure have lower repair bills, fewer theft claims, and safer crash records
Insurance companies set premiums based on what they expect to pay out in claims. A car that is expensive to repair, frequently stolen, or involved in costly accidents will cost more to insure—regardless of its purchase price. A ten-year-old Honda Civic with a strong safety rating and cheap parts might cost half as much to insure as a newer sports car, even though the sports car is worth more money.
The cars that stay cheapest to insure share three things: they are not targets for theft, they survive crashes well, and repair shops can fix them without ordering parts from across the country. Insurers also look at how often owners of a particular model file claims, which means a car's real-world safety record matters more than its crash-test score alone.
Key Takeaways
- Sedans and wagons cost less to insure than sports cars, SUVs, or trucks because they are stolen less often and have lower repair costs.
- Older model years of popular cars (Honda, Toyota, Mazda) stay cheap to insure because parts are abundant and repair shops know how to fix them quickly.
- A car's theft rate in your specific state or region affects your premium more than its national average, so check local data before buying.
- Safety features like automatic emergency braking and stability control lower premiums with most insurers, but only if the car was built with them from the factory.
- High-performance engines, all-wheel drive, and luxury badges all raise insurance costs, even on otherwise reliable vehicles.
Body style and theft risk matter more than engine size
A four-door sedan costs less to insure than a two-door coupe with the same engine because coupes are stolen more often. Pickup trucks and SUVs also carry higher premiums because they are popular theft targets and expensive to repair when damaged. Minivans and station wagons are among the cheapest to insure because almost nobody steals them and parts are inexpensive.
Theft rates vary by region. In some areas, older Honda Civics and Accords are stolen so frequently that insurers charge high premiums for them despite their low repair costs. In other regions, the same cars cost almost nothing to insure. Before you buy a specific model, check the National Insurance Crime Bureau (NICB) theft rankings for your state—not just the national average.
All-wheel drive and turbocharged engines also raise premiums because they cost more to repair. A base-model sedan with front-wheel drive will always be cheaper to insure than the all-wheel-drive version of the same car, even if both have the same safety rating.
Popular, older cars from reliable brands keep insurance costs down
Honda, Toyota, and Mazda models from five to ten years ago are often the cheapest to insure because repair shops have seen thousands of them, parts are straightforward to find, and insurance claim histories show they do not break down unexpectedly. A 2015 Honda Accord or 2016 Toyota Camry will cost far less to insure than a 2015 Dodge Charger or Chrysler 300, even though the Dodge and Chrysler are larger cars.
Luxury brands (BMW, Mercedes, Audi, Lexus) cost significantly more to insure because parts are expensive and specialized repair shops charge higher labor rates. A Lexus may be reliable, but an insurance company still has to account for the cost of replacing a damaged door panel or transmission. The same damage on a Honda costs a fraction as much.
Vehicles with a history of engine or transmission problems also carry higher premiums because insurers know they will pay for more claims. If a model year is known for transmission failure, insurers price that risk into the premium. Checking reliability ratings from Consumer Reports or J.D. Power before you buy helps you avoid models that will cost more to insure over time.
Safety features and crash test ratings affect your rate
Cars with automatic emergency braking, electronic stability control, and forward collision warning often may have access to for insurance discounts—usually 5 to 10 percent off collision and comprehensive coverage. These features must be factory-installed; aftermarket systems do not may have access to. Check your insurer's discount list before buying, because not all companies offer the same discounts.
A high crash-test rating from the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) or Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (IIHS) does lower premiums, but only slightly. The real cost driver is repair expense: a car that survives a crash with less damage costs insurers less money, so it costs you less to insure. A car with a five-star NHTSA rating but expensive parts will still cost more than a three-star car with cheap parts.
Performance and luxury features raise premiums significantly
Sports cars, high-performance versions of regular cars, and vehicles with powerful engines cost more to insure because they are involved in more accidents. A Dodge Charger R/T costs roughly twice as much to insure as a Dodge Charger SE with the same body style, even though both are the same car mechanically. Insurers know that owners of high-performance vehicles file more claims.
Luxury features like leather seats, panoramic sunroofs, and premium sound systems do not directly raise your premium, but they are expensive to replace if damaged. A car with a $3,000 sunroof costs more to insure than the same car without one because the repair bill is higher. Convertibles also cost more because the roof mechanism is expensive to repair and the car is more vulnerable to theft.
What to check before you buy to keep insurance costs down
Call your insurance company and ask for a quote on the specific year, make, model, and trim level you are considering. Do not rely on general statements like "Hondas are cheap to insure"—the difference between a Honda Civic and a Honda Civic Si can be $300 or more per year. Get quotes on two or three alternatives so you can compare the total cost of ownership, not just the purchase price.
Check the NICB website for theft rates in your state and zip code. If a car you like is frequently stolen in your area, your comprehensive coverage premium will be higher. You can also look up reliability ratings and common problems for the specific year and model on Consumer Reports or manufacturer service bulletins to understand what repairs might come up.
Ask about discounts for safety features, bundling policies, good driving records, and completing a defensive driving course. Some insurers offer discounts for paying in full or setting up automatic payments. These discounts can add up to 20 or 30 percent off your base premium, which sometimes matters more than the car itself.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do hybrid and electric cars cost more to insure?
Hybrids usually cost about the same as their gas-only equivalents because repair costs are similar and they are not stolen frequently. Electric vehicles often cost more to insure because battery replacement is expensive and fewer repair shops are equipped to work on them. Get a quote on the specific model before assuming it will be cheaper.
Does the color of the car affect insurance cost?
No. Insurance companies do not use color as a rating factor. The myth that red cars cost more to insure comes from the fact that sports cars are often red, but the color itself does not change your premium.
Will buying a used car instead of new save me money on insurance?
Usually yes, because older cars cost less to repair. However, a five-year-old sports car may cost more to insure than a new economy sedan. The model and trim level matter more than the age. Get quotes on both before deciding.
Can I lower my insurance by choosing a higher deductible?
Yes. Raising your deductible from $500 to $1,000 typically lowers your collision and comprehensive premiums by 10 to 15 percent. Make sure you have enough savings to cover the deductible if you need to file a claim.
Do insurance companies give discounts for safety features I add after I buy the car?
Most do not. Aftermarket safety systems and alarms rarely may have access to for discounts. Factory-installed features like automatic emergency braking do may have access to, so check what comes standard on the model you are buying.