Haggerty is a specialty insurer focused on collector and classic vehicles, not everyday cars
Haggerty Insurance writes policies for cars you own for passion or investment rather than daily transportation. If you drive a 1987 Porsche 911, a restored 1960s muscle car, or a limited-production modern sports car, Haggerty's underwriting and pricing reflect that use pattern. If you drive a 2022 Honda Civic to work five days a week, a standard auto insurer will give you a better rate.
The company operates in all 50 states and has been writing collector car policies since 1991. Their policies are built around the assumption that your classic car sits in a garage most of the time, gets driven on weekends or to car shows, and is worth more to you as a preserved object than as transportation. That changes what they cover, what they charge, and what they ask you to prove.
Key Takeaways
- Haggerty insures collector, classic, and specialty vehicles — not everyday cars — and their rates reflect limited annual mileage and garage storage.
- Policies include agreed value coverage, meaning you and Haggerty agree on the car's worth upfront, rather than paying what it was worth at the time of loss.
- You must meet storage and use requirements: the car typically cannot be your primary vehicle, and it must be parked in a garage or carport when not in use.
- Haggerty's quotes depend on detailed information about the car's condition, modifications, and how often you actually drive it, so online quotes are estimates only.
- Standard auto insurers often will not cover collector cars at all, or will undervalue them, making Haggerty the only practical option for many owners.
How Haggerty's agreed value model differs from standard coverage
A standard auto policy uses actual cash value, which means the insurer pays what the car was worth the moment before the loss. For a 2024 sedan, that works fine — the market value is clear and depreciates predictably. For a 1972 Chevelle SS in restored condition, it does not. The car might be worth $45,000 to you and a knowledgeable buyer, but an adjuster using NADA Guides or Kelley Blue Book might value it at $18,000 because those tools are built for common cars.
Haggerty uses agreed value instead. Before you buy the policy, you and Haggerty agree on what the car is worth — say, $45,000. If the car is totaled, Haggerty pays you $45,000, not what some national database says it was worth. You typically need to provide photos, maintenance records, or a professional appraisal to support that value, and Haggerty may ask a claims adjuster to inspect the car before agreeing to the amount. But once you have a policy in force, the value is locked in.
This matters because collector cars often appreciate or hold value in ways standard cars do not. A well-maintained classic can be worth more five years after you insure it than it was when you bought the policy. Agreed value protects you from being undercompensated if that car is destroyed.
Storage, mileage, and use restrictions you need to meet
Haggerty will not insure a car you drive every day. Most policies require that the vehicle be stored in a garage, carport, or enclosed storage facility when not in use. Some policies allow limited outdoor storage under a car cover, but that varies by state and by the specific policy. You will need to tell Haggerty where the car lives.
Annual mileage limits are standard. Many Haggerty policies cap you at 2,500 to 5,000 miles per year, though some owners negotiate higher limits for a higher premium. The company tracks this through your own reporting — they do not install a device — so you are expected to keep records. Exceeding the limit without notifying Haggerty can void coverage or trigger a rate adjustment when you renew.
The car also cannot be your primary vehicle. Haggerty will ask how you get to work, whether you have another car for daily use, and whether this is a weekend or show car. If you tell them you drive it to work four days a week, they will decline coverage or cancel the policy if they find out later.
What Haggerty policies typically cover and exclude
Haggerty offers liability coverage (bodily injury and property damage to others), collision, comprehensive, and uninsured motorist protection — the same basic categories as a standard policy. The difference is in how much you can insure the car for and what happens when you file a claim.
Liability limits work the same way: you choose a limit, and if you cause an accident, Haggerty pays up to that limit for injuries and damage to the other party. Collision and comprehensive cover damage to your own car from accidents, weather, theft, and vandalism. Uninsured motorist covers you if an uninsured driver hits you.
What Haggerty typically does not cover includes normal wear and tear, mechanical breakdown, and damage from racing or track use. If your classic car's engine fails because of age, that is not a covered loss. If you take the car to a track day and it gets damaged, Haggerty will not pay. Some policies also exclude coverage if the car is being restored or is not in running condition — you will need to ask about that when you quote.
How to get a Haggerty quote and what information you will need
Haggerty quotes online, but the process is more detailed than a standard auto quote. You will need the vehicle identification number (VIN), the year, make, model, and body style. You will also need to describe the car's condition: is it original, restored, modified, or a mix? What is the current mileage? Has it been in any accidents?
You will answer questions about how you use the car: how many miles per year, whether it is stored in a garage, whether you have other vehicles for daily use, and whether you plan to drive it to work or only on weekends. Haggerty may also ask about any modifications, custom paint, interior work, or engine upgrades, because those affect the car's value and risk profile.
The online quote gives you a starting point, but the final premium may change after Haggerty reviews your answers or requests an inspection. If you are insuring a car worth $50,000 or more, or if the car has significant modifications or restoration work, expect Haggerty to ask for photos, service records, or a professional appraisal before binding coverage.
Comparing Haggerty to standard insurers and other specialty carriers
If you own a collector car, you have three realistic options: a standard auto insurer, a specialty carrier like Haggerty, or a dedicated collector car insurer like Grundy or American Collectors Insurance.
Standard insurers (State Farm, Geico, Progressive) will often decline to cover a collector car at all, or will insure it under a standard auto policy that undervalues it. They use actual cash value, not agreed value, and they may not understand the car's true worth or its limited use. Premiums are sometimes lower, but the coverage gap is usually not worth it.
Haggerty, Grundy, and American Collectors all use agreed value and cater to collector owners. Haggerty tends to have the broadest reach and the most flexible underwriting — they will insure newer collectibles, modified cars, and vehicles still being restored. Grundy and American Collectors often focus on older, more traditional classics. Rates vary by company and by the specific car, so getting quotes from two or three is worth the time.
If you own multiple collector cars, some specialty insurers offer multi-car discounts or a single policy that covers several vehicles. Haggerty offers this through their Hagerty Drivers Club membership, which bundles insurance with roadside information and other perks.
Common reasons Haggerty will decline or cancel coverage
Haggerty will not insure a car if it is your primary vehicle, if you drive it more than the mileage limit allows, or if it is stored outdoors without proper cover. They will also decline if the car is being actively restored and is not in running condition, though some policies allow for cars in restoration if you disclose that upfront.
Policies can be canceled if you misrepresent how you use the car. If you tell Haggerty the car is a weekend driver and then file a claim that reveals you drive it to work every day, they may deny the claim or cancel the policy. Similarly, if you exceed the annual mileage limit significantly, Haggerty may not renew or may adjust your premium sharply at renewal.
Some cars are declined because of their value or condition. If Haggerty cannot agree with you on a fair value, or if the car's condition is too poor to insure reliably, they will pass. This is rare, but it happens with cars that are heavily modified, in very poor condition, or of uncertain value.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I insure a car I am actively restoring with Haggerty?
Some Haggerty policies cover cars in restoration, but you must disclose that the car is not currently running or is partially disassembled. Coverage may be limited to theft and vandalism while the car is stored, not collision or comprehensive. Ask Haggerty directly about your specific situation before you buy a policy.
What happens if I drive my collector car more than the mileage limit?
If you exceed the limit, Haggerty may adjust your premium at renewal or decline to renew. Some owners negotiate a higher mileage limit upfront if they know they will drive the car more. It is better to be honest about expected use than to exceed the limit and risk a claim denial.
Do I need a professional appraisal to get a Haggerty policy?
Not always. For cars worth under $10,000 or $15,000, photos and maintenance records may be enough. For higher values or heavily modified cars, Haggerty often requests a professional appraisal or inspection. Ask during the quote process what documentation they need.
Is Haggerty more expensive than a standard auto policy?
It depends on the car. For a collector car worth $30,000 or more, Haggerty is usually cheaper than a standard insurer because standard insurers either decline the car or charge a premium for the undervaluation risk. For a newer car you drive daily, a standard insurer will be much cheaper.
Can I add roadside information or other coverage to a Haggerty policy?
Haggerty offers roadside information, towing, and other add-ons. They also offer Hagerty Drivers Club membership, which bundles insurance with concierge roadside service, event invitations, and other collector-car perks. Ask about these options when you quote.