Costco Car Insurance Is Sold Through Amerisafe, Not Offered Directly by Costco
Costco does not underwrite or sell car insurance itself. Instead, Costco members can purchase auto insurance through Amerisafe Insurance Company, which Costco has partnered with. The coverage is standard auto insurance — liability, collision, comprehensive — but you are buying from Amerisafe, not from Costco. Costco's role is to negotiate group rates for members and provide a referral link on its website.
This matters because your policy, claims, and customer service all go through Amerisafe. If you have a question about coverage or file a claim, you contact Amerisafe directly, not Costco. Costco membership does not automatically enroll you or give you a discount; you have to request a quote through Costco's website or call the dedicated member line.
The discount you receive as a Costco member varies by state and your driving history. Costco advertises this as a member benefit, but the actual savings depend on what Amerisafe charges in your area and how your rates compare to other insurers.
Key Takeaways
- Costco car insurance is underwritten by Amerisafe Insurance Company, and you buy directly from Amerisafe, not Costco.
- Costco members receive a group discount that varies by state and individual risk profile; the discount is not automatic and requires a separate quote request.
- Amerisafe's rates and customer service ratings should be compared against other insurers in your state before deciding, because the Costco discount may or may not result in the lowest premium.
- You can cancel Costco car insurance at any time without losing your Costco membership, and cancellation does not affect other Costco benefits.
How the Costco Member Discount Works
When you request a quote through Costco's website or the member phone line, Amerisafe quotes you a rate that includes the Costco group discount. The discount is applied at the time of quote, not added later. You do not need to enter a code or take any extra step; Costco's referral system automatically flags you as a member.
The size of the discount varies. Costco does not publish a standard percentage — it depends on your state, driving record, age, vehicle type, and claims history. In some states, the Costco discount may be 10 to 15 percent off Amerisafe's standard rate. In others, it may be smaller. The only way to know what you would pay is to request a quote.
The discount applies to your base premium, not to add-ons like roadside information or rental car coverage. It also does not stack with other discounts Amerisafe offers, such as discounts for bundling home and auto insurance or for completing a defensive driving course. Amerisafe will explore the single largest discount you are may have access to to.
Amerisafe's Rates and Coverage Options Compared to Other Insurers
Amerisafe is a regional insurer licensed in most states but not all. It is owned by Homeowners Choice Inc., a publicly traded company. Amerisafe offers standard coverage types — liability, collision, comprehensive, uninsured motorist — and optional add-ons like roadside information and rental reimbursement.
Whether Amerisafe's rates are competitive depends on your state and profile. Some drivers find that the Costco discount brings Amerisafe's price below other major insurers. Others find that a different insurer offers a lower rate even without a group discount. The only way to know is to compare quotes from at least two or three other insurers in your state — for example, State Farm, Geico, Progressive, or a regional carrier.
Amerisafe does not appear in every state's insurance market. If you live in a state where Amerisafe does not operate, the Costco partnership will not be an option for you. Check Amerisafe's website or call the Costco member line to confirm availability in your state before spending time on a quote.
Customer Service and Claims Experience
Amerisafe handles all customer service and claims for Costco-referred policies. You can file a claim online, by phone, or through the Amerisafe mobile app. Claims are processed by Amerisafe's adjusters, not by Costco staff.
Amerisafe's customer service ratings vary by source and year. The National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC) tracks complaint ratios by insurer; you can look up Amerisafe's complaint history on your state's insurance department website. J.D. Power and Consumer Reports also publish customer satisfaction scores for auto insurers, though Amerisafe may not always be included in those rankings because it is smaller than national carriers.
Before buying, read recent customer reviews on independent sites like Trustpilot or your state's insurance department website. Pay attention to complaints about claims handling speed and whether the insurer disputed coverage. These are the areas where you are most likely to interact with the company if something goes wrong.
When Costco Car Insurance Makes Sense
Costco car insurance is worth considering if Amerisafe operates in your state and the Costco discount brings the premium below what you would pay elsewhere. If you are already a Costco member and you shop there regularly, the convenience of managing one relationship may also appeal to you — though remember that Costco itself does not handle claims or customer service.
It also makes sense if you bundle auto and home insurance with Amerisafe, because bundling discounts can lower your overall cost. However, bundling discounts are available from most major insurers, so this is not unique to Costco.
Costco car insurance is less attractive if you have a complex insurance need — for example, if you own multiple vehicles, operate a business vehicle, or need high liability limits above standard coverage. Amerisafe, as a regional insurer, may have fewer options for customization than a national carrier.
How to Get a Quote and What Information You Will Need
To request a quote, visit Costco.com and navigate to the insurance section, or call the Costco member phone line. You will be directed to Amerisafe's quote tool or a dedicated Costco member line that feeds into Amerisafe.
Have the following information ready: your driver's license, vehicle registration, current insurance policy (if you have one), and driving history. The quote process typically takes 10 to 15 minutes online or 15 to 20 minutes by phone. Amerisafe will provide a quote that is valid for a set period — usually 30 to 60 days — and you can accept or decline without obligation.
After you receive the quote, compare it to quotes from at least two other insurers. Use the same coverage limits and deductibles for each quote so the numbers are directly comparable. This step is important because the Costco discount may not result in the lowest price for your situation.
Canceling Costco Car Insurance and Your Membership
If you decide to switch to a different insurer, you can cancel Amerisafe at any time. Cancellation does not affect your Costco membership or any other Costco benefits. You will not be charged a penalty for canceling early, though you may be may have access to to a refund of unused premium depending on your state's laws.
To cancel, contact Amerisafe directly by phone or online. Provide your policy number and requested cancellation date. Amerisafe will confirm the cancellation and send you written confirmation. Make sure your new insurance is in force before the cancellation date so you do not have a gap in coverage.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does Costco membership automatically give me car insurance?
No. Costco membership gives you the option to request a quote for Amerisafe car insurance at a group discount rate. You must actively request a quote and purchase a policy; nothing happens automatically. If you do not request a quote, you have no insurance through Costco.
Can I use the Costco discount if I am not a current member?
No. The Costco discount is only for active Costco members. You must have a valid Costco membership card or membership number to receive the group rate. If your membership expires, you lose the discount on your next renewal.
What happens to my Costco car insurance if I cancel my Costco membership?
Your Amerisafe policy remains in force. However, when your policy renews, you will no longer be may be able to access for the Costco group discount, and your rate will increase to Amerisafe's standard rate. You can cancel the policy at that time or accept the higher rate.
Is Amerisafe available in all states?
No. Amerisafe operates in most states but not all. Check Amerisafe's website or call the Costco member line to confirm whether Amerisafe writes policies in your state before requesting a quote.
Can I bundle Costco car insurance with home insurance?
Yes, if Amerisafe offers homeowners insurance in your state. Bundling auto and home policies with Amerisafe may result in an additional discount beyond the Costco group rate. Ask about bundling discounts when you request your quote.