Mendota Insurance is a regional auto insurer serving the upper Midwest

Mendota Insurance is a mutual insurance company based in Madison, Wisconsin, that writes auto and home policies across Wisconsin and Minnesota. It is not a national carrier—you will not find it in all 50 states—but it has been operating since 1946 and remains one of the larger regional options in those two states. If you live in Wisconsin or Minnesota and are comparing quotes, Mendota will appear as an option alongside national names like State Farm and Allstate.

The company is structured as a mutual insurer, which means it is owned by its policyholders rather than by shareholders. This ownership structure can affect how the company sets rates and returns profits, though it does not automatically mean lower or higher premiums than stock companies. What matters to you is whether Mendota's rates, coverage options, and claims handling work for your situation.

Key Takeaways

  • Mendota Insurance operates only in Wisconsin and Minnesota, so it is available only if you live in one of those states.
  • As a mutual company, Mendota is owned by its policyholders, which can influence how it manages rates and surplus earnings.
  • You can request a quote directly from Mendota or through comparison tools that serve the Midwest region.
  • Comparing Mendota's rates and coverage options against other regional and national carriers in your state will show you where it sits on price and service.

Coverage options Mendota offers

Mendota writes standard auto insurance coverage: liability (bodily injury and property damage), collision, comprehensive, uninsured and underinsured motorist protection, and medical payments. You can also add optional coverages like roadside information and rental reimbursement. The specific limits and deductibles available depend on your state—Wisconsin and Minnesota have different minimum liability requirements—so the options you see will reflect your location.

The company also writes homeowners insurance in both states, but if you are comparing auto quotes, that is separate from your auto decision. Some people bundle auto and home with the same insurer for a discount; Mendota offers bundling, but you should compare the bundled price against buying auto and home separately from different companies, because the discount does not always make the combined cost lower.

How to get a quote from Mendota

You can contact Mendota directly through its website or by phone to request a quote. You will need standard information: driver's license details, driving history, vehicle identification number (VIN), and current coverage details if you are switching from another insurer. The quote process typically takes a few days, though some online quote tools offer estimates in minutes.

You can also use comparison platforms that include Mendota if you are in Wisconsin or Minnesota. These tools let you enter your information once and see quotes from multiple carriers side by side. Not all comparison sites include regional insurers, so if Mendota does not appear, you may need to contact the company directly to may support you have a complete picture of your options.

Mendota's financial strength and claims handling

Mendota is rated by AM Best, the insurance industry's primary financial strength rater. You can check the company's current rating on AM Best's website—a rating of A or higher indicates the company has the financial reserves to pay claims. This is a basic check you should do for any insurer you are considering, not just Mendota.

Claims handling varies by company and by individual claim. You can read customer reviews on independent sites like the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC) complaint database, which tracks complaints filed against insurers in each state. This shows you whether Mendota receives more or fewer complaints than other carriers in Wisconsin and Minnesota, though a single complaint review does not predict how your claim will be handled.

Comparing Mendota to other options

Because Mendota operates only in two states, your comparison set is limited to insurers that also write in Wisconsin or Minnesota. National carriers like State Farm, Allstate, Progressive, and Geico all operate there, as do other regional companies. The rate difference between Mendota and a national carrier can be significant—sometimes Mendota is cheaper, sometimes not—and it depends on your age, driving record, vehicle type, and location within the state.

The best way to know where Mendota sits is to get quotes from at least three other carriers in your state and compare the total premium, the deductibles offered, and any discounts you may have access to for. Some insurers offer discounts for bundling, good driving records, safety features, or completing a defensive driving course; Mendota offers these too, but the discount amounts vary. Do not assume the lowest quote is the best choice—check the coverage limits and deductibles to make sure you are comparing the same thing.

Discounts and rate factors

Mendota offers discounts similar to those of other regional and national insurers: multi-policy bundling, good driver discounts, safety feature discounts (for anti-theft devices, airbags, and electronic stability control), and sometimes discounts for completing a defensive driving course. The size of these discounts is not set in stone—it varies by state and by individual underwriting, so the discount you receive may differ from what another customer receives.

Your rate is also affected by factors you cannot control directly: your age, driving record, the vehicle you drive, where you live (urban areas typically cost more), and how far you drive annually. Mendota uses these factors the same way other insurers do, though the weight given to each factor can differ slightly between companies. This is why two people with identical driving records can receive different quotes from Mendota and from State Farm.

When Mendota might not be available

If you live outside Wisconsin and Minnesota, Mendota is not an option. If you live in one of those states but have a high-risk driving record or own a vehicle type Mendota does not insure (such as a commercial vehicle or a motorcycle), the company may decline to quote you or may offer only limited coverage. In those cases, you will need to focus on carriers that do serve your situation.

You should also check whether Mendota writes in your specific county or area within Wisconsin or Minnesota. Most regional insurers have service territories, and some areas may not be served. A quick call to the company or a check of its website will tell you whether you are in a service area.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I get a Mendota insurance quote if I live in Illinois or Iowa?

No. Mendota operates only in Wisconsin and Minnesota. If you live outside those states, you will need to compare quotes from carriers that serve your state.

Is Mendota cheaper than State Farm or Progressive?

It depends on your age, driving record, vehicle, and location. The only way to know is to request quotes from all three and compare the total premium for the same coverage limits and deductibles. Price varies significantly between individuals.

What happens if Mendota goes out of business?

State insurance regulators require insurers to maintain financial reserves and have guaranty funds in place to protect policyholders if an insurer fails. Wisconsin and Minnesota both have guaranty associations that would step in. Mendota's AM Best rating shows whether it has the financial strength to continue operating.

Does bundling auto and home insurance with Mendota always save money?

Not always. Compare the bundled price against buying auto and home separately from different insurers. Sometimes the bundle discount is smaller than the difference in rates between carriers, so you may pay less by splitting your policies.

How do I file a claim with Mendota?

You can file a claim by phone, online, or through a mobile app, depending on what Mendota offers at the time. Contact information is on your policy documents and on the company's website. Have your policy number and details of the incident ready when you call.