Safe Auto is a regional insurer focused on drivers with accidents, tickets, or lapses in coverage
Safe Auto Insurance Group operates in about a dozen states, primarily in the Midwest and South, and specializes in covering drivers who have had trouble getting standard rates elsewhere. If you have a recent accident, a traffic violation, or a gap in your insurance history, Safe Auto may quote you when other insurers decline or charge significantly more. The company is not a discount carrier — it prices policies for higher-risk drivers, which means your premium will reflect your driving record.
Safe Auto is a legitimate, licensed insurer regulated by state insurance departments. It is not a government program or a last-resort pool. You contact Safe Auto directly through its website or local agents to get a quote, and you pay the company for coverage just as you would with any other insurer. The company has been operating since 1993 and holds licenses in multiple states, though availability depends on where you live.
Key Takeaways
- Safe Auto quotes drivers with accidents, tickets, or coverage lapses that other insurers may reject or charge more for.
- The company operates in select states only — check its website to see if it writes policies in your state.
- Safe Auto's rates are higher than standard insurers because it covers higher-risk drivers, not because it offers fewer benefits.
- You can get a quote online or through a local agent, and you will need your driver's license and vehicle information.
- Safe Auto policies include the same coverage types as other insurers — liability, collision, comprehensive — but the cost structure differs.
Which states Safe Auto operates in and how to check availability
Safe Auto is not available everywhere. The company writes policies in roughly 12 states, with the heaviest presence in Ohio, Indiana, Kentucky, and surrounding regions. If you live in a state where Safe Auto does not operate, you will need to contact other insurers that specialize in high-risk drivers, such as Acceptance Insurance, Bristol West, or your state's assigned risk pool.
To find out whether Safe Auto serves your state, visit safeauto.com and enter your ZIP code, or call a local Safe Auto agent. The website will tell you when ready whether the company can quote you. If Safe Auto is not available in your state, your state insurance department's website lists other carriers that write policies for drivers with accidents or violations.
What coverage types Safe Auto offers and how they compare
Safe Auto sells the same basic coverage types as any other car insurer: liability (covers damage you cause to others), collision (covers damage to your car from a crash), comprehensive (covers theft, weather, vandalism), and uninsured motorist (covers you if hit by an uninsured driver). Your state sets minimum liability limits; Safe Auto lets you choose higher limits if you want them.
The difference between Safe Auto and standard insurers is not the coverage menu — it is the price. Because Safe Auto insures drivers with recent accidents or violations, its base rates are higher. You will not save money by choosing Safe Auto over a standard insurer if you have a clean record. You choose Safe Auto because other insurers have declined you or quoted you much higher rates, and Safe Auto's quote is lower than those alternatives.
Safe Auto does not offer the discount programs that major carriers advertise — bundling, good driver discounts, or usage-based monitoring discounts. The company focuses on getting you a quote quickly rather than layering discounts on top of a base rate.
How to get a quote from Safe Auto
You can request a quote online through safeauto.com or by phone. You will need your driver's license, vehicle identification number (VIN), and current insurance information if you have it. The online quote tool asks for your driving history and the coverage limits you want, then shows you a premium estimate. Phone quotes take longer but let you ask questions as you go.
Safe Auto will pull your driving record from your state's motor vehicle department, so the company will see accidents, violations, and license suspensions. Do not omit or misrepresent this information — insurers verify it, and lying on an process can void your policy later. If you have had a lapse in coverage, tell Safe Auto the dates; the company factors that into the quote.
Once you receive a quote, you can bind coverage when ready if you accept it. Safe Auto will issue a proof of insurance document (sometimes called a binder) that you can show to law enforcement or your lender right away. Your physical insurance card arrives by mail within days.
How Safe Auto's rates work and what affects your premium
Safe Auto calculates your premium based on your driving record, age, vehicle type, coverage limits, and deductible. A recent accident or violation will raise your rate significantly. A lapse in coverage — even a short one — also increases the premium because it signals higher risk to the insurer. If you are under 25 or over 65, your rate will be higher regardless of your record.
Your deductible (the amount you pay out of pocket before insurance kicks in) also affects the premium. Choosing a $1,000 deductible instead of $500 will lower your monthly cost, but it means you pay more if you have a claim. Safe Auto lets you adjust deductibles when you quote, so you can see how different choices change the price.
Safe Auto does not publish its rates publicly, and they vary by state and individual risk factors. The only way to know what Safe Auto will charge you is to get a quote. Comparing Safe Auto's quote to quotes from other high-risk insurers in your state will show you whether it is competitive for your situation.
What happens after you buy a Safe Auto policy
Once your policy is active, you pay your premium on the schedule you chose — monthly, quarterly, or annually. You can manage your policy online through Safe Auto's website or by calling customer service. If you have an accident or need to file a claim, you contact Safe Auto's claims department by phone or through the website.
Safe Auto will assign a claims adjuster to your case. The adjuster will ask about the accident, request photos or a police report if applicable, and get repair estimates. The process typically takes a few days to a couple of weeks, depending on whether the claim is straightforward or contested. Safe Auto will either authorize repairs at a network shop, send you a check, or both.
Your policy renews annually. At renewal, Safe Auto will recalculate your rate based on any new accidents or violations since you bought the policy. If your driving record improves, your rate may go down at renewal. If you have another accident, your rate will go up. After three to five years of clean driving, you may become may be able to access for standard insurers at lower rates, at which point you can shop around.
Alternatives if Safe Auto is not available in your state or if you want other options
If Safe Auto does not serve your state, several other insurers specialize in high-risk drivers. Acceptance Insurance operates in the South and Midwest. Bristol West covers drivers with accidents and violations in multiple states. National General and Infinity also write policies for drivers with poor records. Your state insurance department's website lists all licensed insurers in your state and can point you toward carriers that accept high-risk drivers.
If you have been denied coverage by multiple insurers, your state may operate an assigned risk pool (also called a FAIR plan in some states). This is a last-resort program run by insurers collectively to may support that every driver can get liability coverage. Assigned risk policies are more expensive than Safe Auto, but they exist specifically for drivers who cannot find coverage elsewhere. Contact your state insurance department to learn whether your state has an assigned risk pool and how to access it.
You can also work with an independent insurance agent who represents multiple carriers. An agent can shop your information to several high-risk insurers at once and show you which one offers the best rate for your situation. This takes more time than getting a quote directly from Safe Auto, but it may save you money if another carrier quotes lower.
Frequently Asked Questions
Will Safe Auto insure me if I have a suspended license?
Safe Auto will not write a policy if your license is currently suspended. You must have a valid, active license to purchase coverage. If your suspension is temporary, you can contact Safe Auto once your license is reinstated. If your suspension is permanent or you are unsure of its status, contact your state's motor vehicle department to confirm.
Can I get Safe Auto coverage if I have been denied by other insurers?
Safe Auto is designed for drivers with accidents and violations, so denial by another insurer does not automatically disqualify you. Get a quote from Safe Auto directly — the company will review your record and tell you whether it can cover you. If Safe Auto also declines, ask about your state's assigned risk pool, which must cover you if you have a valid license.
How long does it take to get a Safe Auto policy active?
If you quote and bind coverage online, your policy can be active the same day. Safe Auto will email you a proof of insurance document when ready. Your physical insurance card arrives by mail within a few days. If you quote by phone, binding takes a few minutes, and the timeline is the same.
Will my Safe Auto rate go down if I take a defensive driving course?
Safe Auto does not advertise defensive driving discounts the way standard insurers do. However, some states require insurers to offer a discount for completing an approved course. Contact Safe Auto directly to ask whether your state's rules allow a discount and what course it recognizes.
What if I want to switch from Safe Auto to another insurer?
You can cancel your Safe Auto policy at any time, usually with a phone call or online request. Check your policy for any cancellation fees — most states allow a small fee if you cancel mid-term. Once you have a quote from another insurer, you can bind that coverage and then cancel Safe Auto. Do not let your coverage lapse between policies.