How insurance ratings work and what they actually measure
When you see "top rated" attached to an insurance company, it usually comes from one of a handful of organizations that grade insurers on different things — and those things are not always the same. The National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC) tracks complaint ratios. J.D. Power measures customer satisfaction. AM Best rates financial strength. Consumer Reports runs its own surveys. A company can rank high on one scale and lower on another, so the rating that matters depends on what you actually need to know.
Complaint ratios tell you how many people filed complaints relative to the number of policies sold. Financial strength ratings tell you whether the company can pay claims when disaster hits. Customer satisfaction scores reflect whether people felt heard when they called. None of these is a measure of price — a highly rated company might still charge more than an unrated one for your specific situation. Ratings are one piece of information, not a shortcut to the best choice.
Key Takeaways
- Different rating organizations measure different things: NAIC tracks complaints, J.D. Power tracks satisfaction, AM Best tracks whether the company can pay claims, and Consumer Reports surveys actual customers.
- A company rated highly for customer service might have higher premiums than a lower-rated competitor, so ratings do not replace price comparison.
- Financial strength ratings matter most if you are worried the company will not be around or able to pay a large claim.
- Complaint ratios are useful for spotting patterns of claim denials or billing problems, but a single complaint does not mean the company is bad.
- Your state insurance commissioner's office publishes complaint data for free and can tell you which companies get the most complaints in your state.
Where ratings come from and what each one measures
NAIC complaint ratios are published by your state insurance commissioner. They show how many complaints came in per 1,000 policies sold. A company with 0.5 complaints per 1,000 policies is getting fewer complaints than one with 1.2 per 1,000. The complaints tracked include claim denials, billing disputes, and service issues. You can look up your state's data for free on your state insurance commissioner's website — search "[your state] insurance commissioner complaint data" or "[your state] insurance department complaint ratios."
J.D. Power ratings come from surveys of people who actually own policies. They ask about the claims process, customer service, billing clarity, and overall satisfaction. J.D. Power publishes regional rankings and national rankings. A company might rank high nationally but lower in your region, or vice versa. These scores reflect customer experience, not price or financial stability.
AM Best financial strength ratings use letter grades (A++, A+, A, B++, and so on) to show whether an insurance company has enough money to pay claims even in a bad year. An A or A+ rating means the company is very unlikely to fail. A B rating means it is still stable but has less cushion. This matters most if you are filing a large claim and want confidence the check will clear. You can look up any company's AM Best rating free on their website.
Consumer Reports ratings are based on surveys of their own subscribers about their insurance experience. They do not rate every company — only those with enough responses to be statistically sound. Their ratings focus on customer experience and value, not on price alone.
Why a high rating does not mean the lowest price for you
Insurance pricing is individual. Two people with the same car, same driving record, and same coverage can get wildly different quotes from the same company because of how that company weights factors like age, location, credit score, or claims history. A company rated highly for customer service might charge you $200 more per month than a company with lower ratings but a different pricing model.
Ratings measure how a company treats its customers on average. They do not measure whether that company's algorithm will price your specific risk low. The only way to know your price is to get a quote. You can use ratings to narrow down which companies to request quotes from — for instance, avoiding companies with unusually high complaint ratios — but you still need to compare actual numbers.
How to find ratings for companies you are considering
Start with your state insurance commissioner's office. Search "[your state] insurance commissioner" and look for a section on complaints or consumer information. Most states publish complaint ratios by company, updated annually. This is free and specific to your state.
For financial strength, go to AM Best's website (ambest.com) and search the company name. You will see their rating and a brief explanation. For customer satisfaction, search "J.D. Power auto insurance" and look for the most recent year's rankings. Consumer Reports requires a subscription, but your library may offer free access.
Do not rely on ratings published on the insurance company's own website — they will only show the ratings that make them look good. Go to the rating organization's site directly.
What a high complaint ratio actually means
A complaint ratio of 0.5 per 1,000 policies is generally considered low. A ratio above 1.0 per 1,000 is higher than average. But one complaint does not mean the company is bad, and a company with zero complaints does not exist — complaints are normal. What matters is the pattern: Does the company have more complaints than others in your state? Are the complaints about the same issue (like claim denials) or spread across different problems?
Your state insurance commissioner's office can sometimes tell you what the complaints are about. Some states publish summaries. If you see a company with a high ratio, you can call your state commissioner's office and ask what kinds of complaints they received — that tells you whether the problem is something that would affect you.
Red flags when comparing rated companies
A company with an AM Best rating below B is a red flag for financial stability — it means the rating agency has concerns about whether they can pay large claims. A complaint ratio significantly higher than competitors in your state is worth investigating further. If you call the company and have a bad experience, that is a sign to get quotes elsewhere.
Do not assume that a company with lower ratings is automatically worse for you. Some smaller or newer companies have fewer complaints straightforward because they have fewer customers. Some companies have high satisfaction ratings but also high prices. Use ratings to screen out obvious problems, then compare quotes and read recent reviews from people in your situation.
How to use ratings alongside price comparison
Get quotes from at least three companies, including at least one with a strong rating in your state. Compare the price first — that is the number you will pay. Then check the complaint ratio and financial strength of the companies offering the lowest prices. If the cheapest option has an unusually high complaint ratio or a weak financial rating, consider paying a bit more for a company with better marks. If the cheapest option has ratings in line with competitors, price is your main decision point.
Read recent customer reviews on independent sites (not the company's own site) from people in your state and with your type of coverage. A review from someone with a similar car and driving record tells you more than a national average rating.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is a company with a high J.D. Power rating always cheaper?
No. J.D. Power measures customer satisfaction, not price. A highly rated company might charge more because they invest more in customer service. Compare quotes directly — ratings help you pick which companies to request quotes from, but they do not tell you the price.
What does an AM Best rating of A+ mean?
It means the rating agency believes the company has very strong financial stability and can pay claims even in difficult years. An A+ is one of the highest ratings. Anything A or above is generally considered safe. Below B is a warning sign.
Can I trust complaint ratios from my state insurance commissioner?
Yes. State insurance commissioners publish complaint data as a public record. The data is usually one year old by the time it is published, so it is not real-time, but it is accurate and unbiased. It does not include every complaint — only those filed with the state — but it is the most reliable source.
Should I avoid a company just because it has some complaints?
No. Every insurance company gets complaints. What matters is whether the complaint ratio is higher than competitors in your state and whether the complaints are about something that would affect you. One complaint does not mean the company is bad.
Do ratings change every year?
Yes. Complaint ratios are usually updated once a year by state insurance commissioners. J.D. Power publishes new rankings annually. AM Best updates financial ratings as the company's situation changes. Check the date on any rating you find to make sure it is current.