What insurance ratings tell you and what they don't

Insurance company ratings measure financial strength and customer service track records, not whether a company will give you the lowest price. A highly rated insurer might cost more than a lower-rated one for your specific situation—ratings show you which companies are stable enough to pay claims and which ones customers complain about least, but they don't predict your premium.

Three major rating systems exist: AM Best rates financial stability (whether the company can actually pay your claim), J.D. Power measures customer satisfaction with claims and service, and the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC) tracks complaint volume relative to company size. Each answers a different question about the company. A strong rating from AM Best means the insurer won't go bankrupt. A high J.D. Power score means customers report fewer hassles when filing claims. A low NAIC complaint ratio means fewer people file formal complaints per policy sold.

Your state's insurance department also publishes complaint data. You can search your state's insurance commissioner website to see how many complaints each company received in the past year and what those complaints were about—denied claims, billing problems, delayed responses, or coverage disputes.

Key Takeaways

  • AM Best ratings (A++, A+, A, etc.) tell you whether an insurance company has the money to pay claims; anything A or higher is considered financially stable.
  • J.D. Power scores rank customer satisfaction with the actual claims process and customer service, with higher scores meaning fewer complaints about handling.
  • NAIC complaint ratios show how many formal complaints a company received per 1,000 policies, letting you compare complaint volume fairly across large and small insurers.
  • Your state insurance commissioner publishes free complaint data showing what customers complained about and how each company responded.
  • A highly rated company may still charge more than a lower-rated competitor for your specific vehicle, location, and driving history.

AM Best financial strength ratings

AM Best assigns letter grades based on whether an insurance company has enough cash and assets to pay all the claims it receives. The scale runs from A++ (superior) down to D (poor), with anything below B+ considered risky. An A or A+ rating means the company has been stress-tested and has reserves to handle a major disaster—a hurricane, a widespread accident, a pandemic that floods the system with claims.

You can look up any insurer's AM Best rating free on the AM Best website. Search by company name and you will see the current rating, the date it was assigned, and sometimes a brief outlook (stable, negative, or positive). Most major insurers carry an A or A+ rating. If a company rates below B+, that is a warning sign that it may struggle to pay claims during a crisis or may not survive a major loss.

This rating protects you from a worst-case scenario: you file a legitimate claim and the company cannot pay it because it has run out of money. It is rare but it happens. AM Best ratings exist specifically to prevent that. If you are comparing two insurers and one has a significantly lower AM Best rating, that is worth asking about before you switch.

J.D. Power customer satisfaction scores

J.D. Power surveys customers about their experience filing claims and dealing with customer service. The company publishes annual rankings for auto insurance companies, breaking down satisfaction by region and by how customers interact with the company (online, phone, agent). Scores range from roughly 700 to 900, with higher scores indicating fewer complaints about claims handling, response time, and clarity.

J.D. Power ratings tell you what to expect when you actually need to file a claim. A company with a high score means customers reported that claims were processed quickly, that the company explained what was covered and what was not, and that they felt treated fairly. A lower score suggests customers experienced delays, confusion, or frustration. The difference between a 750 and an 850 is real—it reflects whether most customers felt the company made the process smooth or difficult.

You can find J.D. Power rankings on their website, broken down by state and by company. They update annually, usually in the spring. Keep in mind that J.D. Power surveys only customers who filed claims, so the score reflects the claims experience specifically, not the cost of the policy or how straightforward it is to buy one.

NAIC complaint ratios and what they measure

The National Association of Insurance Commissioners collects complaints filed against insurance companies and publishes them as a ratio: complaints per 1,000 policies sold. This matters because a large company will naturally receive more total complaints than a small one, so comparing raw numbers is unfair. The ratio levels the playing field.

A complaint ratio of 0.5 means the company received one complaint for every 2,000 policies. A ratio of 2.0 means one complaint per 500 policies. Lower is better. You can find NAIC complaint data on your state insurance commissioner's website—most states publish it in a searchable database. The data usually lags by a few months, so you are looking at the previous year's complaints, but the pattern is stable enough to be useful.

NAIC complaints include denied claims, billing disputes, coverage questions, and delays. The database often shows what the complaint was about and whether the company resolved it. If a company has a high complaint ratio and most complaints are about denied claims, that is different from a high ratio driven by billing errors. Read the actual complaints, not just the number.

State insurance department complaint data

Your state's insurance commissioner maintains a public record of complaints filed against every licensed insurer in that state. This is often the most useful source because it is free, it is specific to your state, and it shows real complaints from real customers in your area. Search your state's name plus "insurance commissioner complaint database" or "insurance department complaint search."

Most state databases let you search by company name and show you the number of complaints received in the past year, what they were about, and sometimes how the company responded. Some states publish a summary ratio; others show the raw data. Either way, you can see which companies customers in your state complained about most and what the complaints were.

State complaint data is slower to update than company websites—it usually reflects the previous calendar year—but it is authoritative and unfiltered. If you are deciding between two companies and one has significantly more complaints in your state, that is worth considering. If most complaints are about a specific issue (like claim denials), ask the company directly how they handle that situation.

How to use ratings when comparing insurers

Start by checking AM Best ratings for any company you are seriously considering. If a company rates below B+, move on. If it rates A or higher, you know it has the financial strength to pay claims. That is your baseline.

Next, look at J.D. Power scores and your state's complaint data for the companies that passed the AM Best test. Compare their scores in your region if J.D. Power breaks it down by state. Read a few actual complaints from your state's database to see whether the issues match your concerns. If you care most about fast claims processing, look for high J.D. Power scores. If you are worried about claim denials, check what your state's complaints say about each company.

Then get quotes from the companies that rank well on all three measures. Your final choice will likely come down to price and coverage options, not ratings—but ratings narrow the field to companies you can trust to handle a claim fairly and pay it. A company with excellent ratings that charges twice as much as a competitor with average ratings is not necessarily the better choice, but a company with poor ratings is a risk you should avoid.

What ratings don't tell you about price

Insurance ratings measure stability and service quality, not cost. The highest-rated company in your state may charge significantly more or less than a lower-rated competitor for your specific vehicle, age, location, and driving history. Ratings do not predict your premium.

This is why you need to get quotes from multiple companies. A company with a 750 J.D. Power score might charge $1,200 a year for your coverage, while a company with a 780 score might charge $1,500. The difference in rating does not justify the price difference for you. Conversely, a company with a lower rating might offer a discount you cannot pass up—but you are making that choice with your eyes open, knowing that the company has a higher complaint ratio or a lower financial strength score.

Use ratings to build a short list of trustworthy companies, then use quotes to find the best price among them. That is the practical way to balance safety and cost.

Frequently Asked Questions

What does an AM Best rating of A+ actually mean?

An A+ rating means the company has been evaluated by AM Best and found to have strong financial reserves and the ability to pay claims even during a major crisis. It is one of the highest ratings available. Anything A or higher is considered safe; below B+ is considered risky.

Can I trust a company with a lower J.D. Power score?

A lower J.D. Power score means customers reported more frustration with claims handling or customer service, but it does not mean the company is unsafe or will deny your claim. It means you may experience more delays or confusion. If the price is significantly lower and you can tolerate slower service, it may still be worth it.

Where do I find my state's insurance complaint database?

Search your state's name plus "insurance commissioner" or "department of insurance" and look for a link to complaint data or a searchable database. Most states publish this free on their website. You can also call your state insurance commissioner's office and ask how to look up complaints against a specific company.

If a company has a high complaint ratio, should I avoid it?

Not automatically. Read what the complaints were about. If most complaints are about billing and the company resolved them, that is different from a pattern of denied claims. Also check whether the company's complaint ratio is higher than the state average for its size. Context matters more than the number alone.

Do insurance ratings change often?

AM Best ratings change when a company's financial situation changes significantly, which is rare—usually once a year or less. J.D. Power scores update annually. NAIC complaint data updates yearly. You do not need to check ratings constantly, but it is worth reviewing them every few years or before you renew your policy.