Insurance cost depends on the car itself, not just the driver

The cheapest cars to insure are usually older, common sedans with strong safety records and low repair costs. A Honda Civic, Toyota Corolla, or Hyundai Elantra will cost less to insure than a sports car, luxury vehicle, or truck—even if two drivers have identical records. Insurance companies price based on what the car costs to repair, how often it gets stolen, how well it protects occupants in a crash, and how much damage it typically causes in an accident.

A car that is cheap to buy is not always cheap to insure. A used sports car might cost $8,000 but carry high insurance because repair parts are expensive and the model attracts higher-risk drivers. A five-year-old sedan might cost $12,000 but insure for less because parts are abundant and cheap, and the car has a calm safety profile.

Key Takeaways

  • Insurance cost is driven by repair expenses, theft rates, safety ratings, and accident history for that specific model—not by the car's purchase price alone.
  • Sedans and hatchbacks from Honda, Toyota, Hyundai, and Mazda typically have the lowest insurance rates because parts are cheap and the models are common.
  • Sports cars, luxury brands, and trucks cost significantly more to insure even when used, because repairs are expensive and damage claims are higher.
  • A car's safety rating, particularly its crashworthiness score from NHTSA, directly affects what insurers charge.
  • Theft rates for specific models and colors influence insurance cost; popular theft targets cost more to insure.

What insurers actually measure when they price a car

Insurance companies use five main factors to decide what a model costs to insure. The first is repair cost—how much a typical collision or comprehensive claim will run. A Honda Civic has cheap, widely available parts. A BMW or Audi has expensive proprietary parts and requires specialist labor. That difference alone can double the insurance rate.

The second is safety rating. The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) crash-tests vehicles and publishes ratings for frontal crash, side crash, and rollover. Cars that score well in these tests cause fewer injuries per accident, so insurers charge less. The Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (IIHS) also publishes ratings; some insurers weight these heavily.

The third is theft rate. The National Insurance Crime Bureau (NICB) publishes annual theft data by model and model year. If a particular car is stolen frequently in your area, insurance costs more. Some colors are stolen more often than others—silver and white vehicles are stolen at higher rates than red or yellow ones, though this varies by region and model.

The fourth is accident history for that model. Insurers track claims data by vehicle type. If a model is involved in more accidents than average, or if accidents involving that model tend to be expensive, the rate goes up. Sports cars and high-performance vehicles fall into this category.

The fifth is engine size and power. Larger engines and higher horsepower correlate with more aggressive driving and more severe accidents. A V8 truck will cost more to insure than a four-cylinder truck, even if they are the same year and model.

Car models with the lowest insurance costs

Honda Civic and Honda Accord rank among the cheapest to insure across most age groups. Parts are abundant, repair shops are everywhere, safety ratings are strong, and theft rates are moderate. A 2019 or 2020 Civic will cost significantly less to insure than a 2019 or 2020 Mustang or Charger.

Toyota Corolla and Toyota Camry are similarly affordable. These cars are built to last, have excellent safety records, and are so common that parts and labor are inexpensive. Insurance companies have decades of claims data showing these models are reliable and cause predictable damage in accidents.

Hyundai Elantra and Hyundai Sonata have become cheaper to insure in recent years as the brand's safety ratings improved and repair networks expanded. These cars offer good value because they are newer to the market, so used examples are plentiful but not yet old enough to have high repair costs.

Mazda3 and Mazda6 fall into the same category—affordable, safe, and cheap to repair. Mazda parts are reasonably priced, and the brand has a reputation for reliability that keeps claims down.

Toyota Prius costs less to insure than many sedans because collision damage is often minor (the car is light), and comprehensive claims are rare. However, hybrid battery repairs are expensive, so a Prius with a damaged battery can be totaled. Check the specific model year with your insurer before buying.

Cars that cost the most to insure

Sports cars like the Dodge Charger, Chevrolet Camaro, Ford Mustang, and Dodge Challenger carry the highest insurance rates. These cars are involved in more accidents, cause more damage when they crash, and attract drivers who take more risk. A 2020 Charger will cost two to three times as much to insure as a 2020 Civic, all else equal.

Luxury vehicles from BMW, Mercedes-Benz, Audi, and Porsche are expensive to insure because parts are costly and specialized labor is required. A fender-bender on a BMW can run $3,000 to $5,000 in repairs; the same damage on a Honda might be $800 to $1,200.

Full-size pickup trucks, particularly those with larger engines, cost more to insure than sedans. Trucks cause more damage in collisions because of their weight and size. A Ford F-150 with a V8 will cost more than an F-150 with a smaller engine.

High-end SUVs and crossovers from luxury brands follow the same pattern as luxury sedans. A Range Rover or Cadillac Escalade will cost significantly more to insure than a Honda CR-V or Toyota RAV4.

How age and mileage affect insurance cost for the same model

Newer cars cost more to insure than older ones, even within the same model line. A 2023 Honda Civic costs more than a 2018 Honda Civic because the newer car has more expensive parts, more complex electronics, and higher repair labor rates. However, the relationship is not linear—a 2010 Civic might cost less than a 2018 Civic because it is older, but if it has high mileage or poor safety ratings, the cost can reverse.

Mileage affects insurance cost indirectly. High-mileage cars are more likely to have pre-existing damage or mechanical issues that complicate repairs. Some insurers charge slightly more for high-mileage vehicles, but most focus on the model year and repair cost instead.

Safety features matter more as cars age. A 2015 car with modern safety features (automatic emergency braking, lane-keeping information, adaptive headlights) may cost less to insure than a 2012 car without them, even though the 2012 is older. Check the specific model year's safety ratings before comparing.

Where to find insurance rates for specific cars before you buy

Most insurance companies publish sample rates by vehicle model on their websites. You can enter a specific year, make, and model and see what collision, comprehensive, and liability coverage would cost. This is free and does not require you to provide personal information. Start with the major insurers: State Farm, Geico, Progressive, Allstate, and USAA (if you are military or a veteran).

The NHTSA website (safercar.gov) shows crash test ratings and safety features for any model year. The IIHS website (iihs.org) shows additional safety ratings and lists which models earn their Top Safety Pick award. These ratings directly influence insurance cost.

The NICB website (nicb.org) publishes annual theft reports by model. You can search for a specific car and see its theft rank in your state. If a model ranks high for theft, expect higher insurance rates.

Insurance.com and NerdWallet allow you to enter a vehicle and see average rates across multiple insurers. These tools do not bind you to anything and show you the range of what different companies charge for the same car.

Why the same car costs different amounts at different insurers

Two insurers may quote very different rates for the same car because they weight the pricing factors differently. One insurer may heavily penalize sports cars; another may focus more on theft rates. One may offer discounts for safety features that another does not recognize. One may have better claims experience with a particular model in your state.

Your personal driving record, age, and location also matter. A 25-year-old with a speeding ticket will see a bigger rate jump on a sports car than a 45-year-old with a clean record. A car parked on the street in a high-theft neighborhood will cost more to insure than the same car parked in a garage in a low-theft area.

This is why comparing quotes across at least three insurers is necessary before buying a car. The cheapest car to insure in theory might not be the cheapest for you, given your specific situation and the insurers available in your state.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does buying a used car instead of new save money on insurance?

Usually yes, but not always. A used sports car or luxury vehicle can cost more to insure than a new, common sedan. The model and its repair cost matter more than age alone. A 2015 Honda Civic will cost less to insure than a 2023 Dodge Charger, even though the Civic is older.

Will adding safety features to an older car lower my insurance?

Some insurers offer small discounts for aftermarket safety features like backup cameras or dash cams, but the discount is usually modest—$10 to $50 per year. The car's built-in safety rating (determined at manufacture) has a much larger effect on cost. Upgrading the car's safety rating is not possible after purchase.

Does the color of the car affect insurance cost?

Color affects theft rates, which can influence comprehensive coverage cost slightly. Silver and white cars are stolen more often, so they may cost a few dollars more per month to insure. This varies by region and model. Collision and liability rates are not affected by color.

Is a hybrid or electric car cheaper to insure?

Hybrids like the Prius are often cheaper to insure because they are light and cause less damage in collisions. Electric vehicles vary widely. Some have high repair costs because battery and electric motor repairs are specialized and expensive. Check the specific model with insurers before buying.

Can I lower my insurance by choosing a car with a manual transmission?

Most insurers do not adjust rates based on transmission type. A few may offer tiny discounts for manual transmissions because they are less common and less likely to be stolen, but the savings are negligible—usually under $5 per month. The car's model, safety rating, and repair cost matter far more.