Cars that insurers charge less to cover
Insurance companies charge less for cars that are cheap to repair, have good safety records, and are less likely to be stolen. A Honda Civic, Toyota Corolla, or Subaru Outback will typically cost less to insure than a sports car, luxury sedan, or truck with expensive parts. The difference between insuring a Honda Accord and a Dodge Charger can be $500 to $1,500 per year, depending on your age, location, and driving history.
The cars that cost the most to insure are high-performance vehicles (Mustangs, Challengers, Camaros), luxury brands (BMW, Mercedes, Audi), and models with expensive repair costs or high theft rates. Pickup trucks, especially newer ones, also carry higher premiums because parts are costly and claims tend to be larger.
Older cars—typically five to ten years old—often have lower premiums than brand-new ones, even though they may be worth less. A 2015 Honda Civic will usually cost less to insure than a 2024 Honda Civic, because the newer car's repair costs are higher and its replacement value is greater.
Key Takeaways
- Sedans and compact cars from Honda, Toyota, and Subaru tend to have the lowest insurance rates because parts are affordable and repair shops are common.
- Sports cars, luxury vehicles, and trucks with expensive components carry premiums that can be $1,000 or more per year higher than economy sedans.
- Older model years (five to ten years old) usually cost less to insure than current-year vehicles, even if they are the same make and model.
- Your age, location, and driving record affect your rate far more than the car itself, so a cheap-to-insure car does not may provide a low premium.
- Checking insurance quotes before you buy a car is the only way to know what you will actually pay, because rates vary by insurer and by your personal details.
Why repair costs matter more than the car's price tag
Insurance companies do not charge based on what you paid for the car—they charge based on what it costs them to fix it. A Toyota Corolla costs $400 to repair a fender because the part is common and shops have the tools. A BMW 3 Series costs $2,000 for the same repair because the part is proprietary, fewer shops can do the work, and labor rates are higher.
When you file a claim, the insurer pays the repair bill. If your car is totaled, they pay its current market value. Either way, they want to minimize that payout. A car with cheap, widely available parts and straightforward repairs keeps their costs down, so they charge you less.
Parts availability also affects how long you are without your car. If your Honda needs a replacement door, the shop can order it and install it in days. If your Audi needs one, it may take weeks. Insurers factor in rental car costs while yours is being fixed, so cars with faster repair timelines cost less to insure.
Safety ratings and theft risk
Cars with high crash-test ratings from the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) or Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (IIHS) often may have access to for safety discounts. These discounts can lower your premium by 5 to 15 percent. A Volvo or Subaru with top safety scores may cost less to insure than a cheaper car with poor ratings, because fewer claims result from crashes.
Theft risk also drives rates. The National Insurance Crime Bureau (NICB) publishes annual lists of the most-stolen vehicles. Older Honda Civics and Accords appear on these lists almost every year, which means insurers charge more to cover them—even though the cars themselves are cheap to repair. A Chevy Malibu, by contrast, is rarely stolen, so theft coverage costs less.
Some cars are stolen for parts rather than resale. Pickup trucks and Jeeps are common targets because their parts are valuable and fit multiple model years. If you own one of these vehicles, comprehensive coverage (which covers theft) will cost more than it would for a sedan.
How age and mileage affect what you pay
A five-year-old Honda Civic will almost always cost less to insure than a brand-new one, even though it is worth less money. Insurers charge based on repair and replacement costs, not on what you owe. A new Civic's parts are more expensive, and the car itself is worth more, so a total loss claim costs the insurer more.
Mileage also matters. A car with 80,000 miles costs less to insure than the same model with 20,000 miles, because it is worth less and is closer to the end of its useful life. Once a car reaches 10 to 15 years old or 150,000 miles, some insurers stop offering comprehensive and collision coverage, or charge rates that make it uneconomical to carry those coverages.
The sweet spot for cheap insurance is usually a car that is five to eight years old, has moderate mileage (60,000 to 100,000 miles), and is a common model from a reliable brand. These cars have low repair costs, are not targets for theft, and are not so old that insurers avoid them.
Specific models with consistently low premiums
Honda Civic and Accord rank among the cheapest to insure because parts are inexpensive, repair shops are everywhere, and the cars are reliable. The downside is that older Civics are frequently stolen, so comprehensive coverage costs more than it would for less-popular models.
Toyota Corolla and Camry have low insurance costs due to affordable parts, high reliability, and low theft rates. These cars hold their value well, so even older models do not drop in price as steeply as other brands, but insurance rates remain low.
Subaru Outback and Forester offer good safety ratings and low repair costs, which keeps premiums down. All-wheel drive adds slightly to the cost compared to front-wheel-drive sedans, but not by much.
Hyundai Elantra and Kia Forte are budget-friendly cars with low insurance premiums. Parts are affordable, and these brands have improved their reliability reputation, so insurers price them competitively.
Mazda3 combines fun-to-drive handling with low insurance costs. It is not as common as a Civic or Corolla, so theft is less of a concern, and repair costs are moderate.
Avoid: Dodge Charger, Dodge Challenger, Ford Mustang, Chevrolet Camaro, BMW 3 Series, Mercedes C-Class, Jeep Wrangler, Ford F-150 (newer models), Nissan Altima (high theft rate).
What your personal details cost you compared to the car
Your age, driving record, location, and coverage limits affect your rate far more than whether you drive a Civic or a Corolla. A 25-year-old with a speeding ticket will pay more to insure a Honda Civic than a 55-year-old with a clean record will pay to insure a Dodge Charger. A driver in rural Montana will pay less than a driver in Los Angeles, even in the same car.
This means that buying a cheap-to-insure car does not may provide a low premium. You still need to get quotes from multiple insurers, because rates vary widely. One company might charge $1,200 per year for a Civic and another might charge $1,600 for the same car, same driver, same coverage.
The car's characteristics—repair cost, safety rating, theft risk—create a baseline. Your personal profile determines how much you pay above or below that baseline. A cheap car with a bad driving record can cost more than an expensive car with a perfect record.
Getting quotes before you buy
The only way to know what a car will actually cost to insure is to get quotes from insurers before you buy it. Most insurers let you enter the vehicle identification number (VIN) or the year, make, and model on their website and see an estimate in minutes. Some will give you a quote over the phone.
Compare quotes from at least three insurers—State Farm, GEICO, Progressive, Allstate, and regional carriers in your state all have different rates. A car that is cheap to insure with one company might be expensive with another, depending on how that insurer prices theft risk, repair costs, and safety features.
If you are shopping for a used car, run quotes on several models in your price range before you make an offer. The difference in insurance cost between two cars might be $300 to $500 per year, which adds up over the time you own the vehicle. That information should factor into your decision.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do hybrid and electric cars cost more to insure?
Hybrid cars usually cost about the same as their gas-powered equivalents because parts are becoming more common and repair shops are trained to handle them. Electric vehicles often cost more to insure because battery replacement is expensive and fewer shops can repair them, though this is changing as EVs become more common.
Does the color of the car affect insurance rates?
No. Insurance companies do not charge different rates based on color. The myth that red cars cost more to insure is false. The only things that matter are the make, model, year, and how much it costs to repair.
Will buying a used car instead of new save me money on insurance?
Yes, usually. A used car is worth less, so replacement cost is lower. Repair parts for older model years are often cheaper and more available. However, if the used car is a model with high theft rates or expensive parts, it might cost more to insure than a newer, safer model.
Can I lower my insurance by choosing a car with more safety features?
Yes. Cars with high crash-test ratings and advanced safety features like automatic emergency braking may may have access to for discounts. Check with your insurer about what discounts they offer before you buy, because not all insurers reward the same features.
What if I already own an expensive car to insure?
You can lower your premium by raising your deductible (the amount you pay out of pocket for a claim), dropping comprehensive or collision coverage if the car is paid off and worth little, or shopping around for better rates. You cannot change what the car costs to repair, but you can change how much risk you transfer to the insurer.