Insurance costs depend more on the car's safety record and repair costs than on the price tag
A cheap car to buy is not the same as a cheap car to insure. Insurers set rates based on how often that specific model gets into accidents, how much damage typically results, and how expensive parts are to replace — not on the sticker price. A five-year-old Honda Civic might cost $800 a year to insure, while a brand-new economy sedan could run $1,200 because the new model has a higher theft rate or pricier parts.
Before you choose a vehicle, checking insurance costs for that exact year and model takes minutes and can save you hundreds annually. The car itself — its model, age, and built-in safety features — matters far more than whether you found a good deal on the purchase price.
Key Takeaways
- Insurance companies rate individual car models based on accident frequency, injury severity, and repair costs for that specific year and trim — not on the car's purchase price.
- Sedans and wagons typically cost less to insure than SUVs and sports cars, because they have lower theft rates and cheaper parts.
- Older model years usually cost less to insure than new ones, even if the older car is the same model, because comprehensive and collision coverage drops in value as the car ages.
- You can get a real insurance quote for any specific car before you buy it by providing the VIN or year, make, model, and trim to an insurer or quote site.
- Safety features like automatic emergency braking and stability control lower rates at most insurers, though the discount amount varies by company.
Why the car itself matters more than its price
Insurance rates for a specific car model come from claims data — how many drivers of that car filed claims, how much those claims cost, and whether injuries were common. A model with a high accident rate or expensive repairs will have a higher base rate, regardless of whether the car is cheap or expensive to buy. For example, a Subaru WRX (a performance sedan) typically costs more to insure than a Toyota Camry (a mainstream sedan) even though the Camry may cost more to purchase, because the WRX has a higher accident rate and attracts younger, riskier drivers.
Repair costs also drive rates up. If a model uses proprietary parts or requires specialized labor, insurance companies know claims will be expensive. A Tesla, even a lower-priced model, often has higher insurance costs than a comparable Honda because Tesla parts are harder to source and repairs require certified technicians. Conversely, a Toyota or Honda model with common parts and straightforward repairs will have lower rates even if the car itself is less luxurious.
Car types that typically have lower insurance costs
Sedans and wagons are generally the cheapest to insure because they have lower theft rates, lower accident rates, and cheaper parts than SUVs and sports cars. A Honda Accord or Toyota Camry will almost always cost less to insure than a Ford F-150 or Jeep Wrangler of the same year, even though trucks and SUVs may cost more to buy. The difference can be $200 to $400 per year depending on your location and driving record.
Minivans and crossovers sit in the middle. They cost more to insure than sedans but less than full-size SUVs. Sports cars and performance vehicles — anything marketed for speed or handling — carry the highest rates because they attract drivers who take more risks and because accident severity tends to be higher. Luxury brands also cost more to insure than mainstream brands, partly because parts are expensive and partly because repair shops charge more labor.
Electric vehicles have mixed insurance costs. Some insurers offer discounts for EVs because they have fewer moving parts and lower repair costs for routine maintenance. Others charge more because battery replacement is extremely expensive if the vehicle is damaged. Get a quote for the specific EV model you are considering rather than assuming it will be cheaper.
How model year affects your insurance rate
Older cars typically cost less to insure than new ones, even if they are the same model. This is because comprehensive and collision coverage — which protect against theft, weather, and accidents — are based on the car's current market value. A five-year-old car is worth less, so the maximum payout is lower, and your premium reflects that. Once a car is paid off and you drop collision coverage entirely, insurance becomes very cheap.
However, very old cars (15+ years) sometimes cost more to insure if they lack modern safety features like electronic stability control or automatic emergency braking. Some insurers also charge more for older vehicles because repair shops may struggle to find parts or because the car is more likely to break down and need towing. The sweet spot for low insurance costs is usually 5 to 10 years old — old enough that the value has dropped significantly, but new enough to have current safety technology.
Safety features that lower your rate
Most insurers offer discounts for cars equipped with automatic emergency braking, lane-keeping information, blind-spot monitoring, and electronic stability control. These features reduce accident frequency and severity, so insurers reward owners with discounts ranging from 5% to 15% depending on the company. Some insurers also discount for passive safety features like multiple airbags and reinforced frames, though the discount is usually smaller.
The discount amount varies significantly by insurer, so a car with a particular safety feature might get a 10% discount from one company and a 5% discount from another. When you are comparing cars, ask each insurer whether they discount for the specific features you are considering. A car with advanced safety tech might end up cheaper to insure at one company than a simpler car at another company, even though the simpler car has a lower base rate.
How to check insurance costs before you buy
Get a quote for the exact car you are considering by providing the year, make, model, trim, and VIN if you have it. Most major insurers (State Farm, Geico, Progressive, Allstate, and others) allow you to enter this information on their websites and receive a quote in minutes without committing to anything. You do not need to own the car yet — insurers can quote based on the vehicle details alone.
Contact at least three insurers to compare, because rates vary widely for the same car. One company might charge $1,100 per year for a Honda Civic while another charges $950 for the identical car, depending on how that insurer rates the model and what discounts explore to your situation. Spending 20 minutes getting three quotes can reveal $300 or more in annual savings.
If you are shopping for a car and have narrowed it down to two or three models, get insurance quotes for each before you decide. The difference in insurance cost might tip the decision toward the cheaper-to-insure option, especially if you plan to keep the car for several years. Some dealerships can also provide insurance estimates, though getting quotes directly from insurers is more reliable.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do hybrid and electric cars cost more to insure?
It depends on the insurer and the specific model. Some companies offer discounts for hybrids and EVs because they have fewer moving parts and lower maintenance costs. Others charge more because battery replacement is expensive if the car is damaged. Get a quote for the specific vehicle from multiple insurers rather than assuming it will be cheaper or more expensive.
Will my insurance go down if I buy a car with a good safety rating?
A high safety rating from NHTSA or IIHS does not automatically lower your rate, but the safety features that earn those ratings often do. Automatic emergency braking, stability control, and other active safety systems may may have access to for discounts at your insurer. Ask your insurance company which features on your car may have access to for discounts before you buy.
Is it cheaper to insure a used car than a new one?
Usually yes, because comprehensive and collision coverage are based on the car's market value. A three-year-old car is worth less than a brand-new one, so the potential payout is lower and your premium is lower. However, if the used car is a model with a high accident rate or expensive repairs, it could cost more to insure than a newer, safer model.
What's the cheapest car to insure overall?
There is no single cheapest car because rates depend on your age, location, driving record, and which insurer you use. Generally, a five- to ten-year-old Honda Civic, Toyota Camry, or similar mainstream sedan costs less to insure than newer cars, luxury brands, or performance vehicles. Get quotes for the specific cars you are considering to find the actual cheapest option for your situation.
Do color and other cosmetic features affect insurance rates?
No. Insurance companies do not rate based on color, interior trim, or cosmetic features. They rate based on the car's model, year, safety features, repair costs, and claims history for that specific vehicle. Two identical cars in different colors will have the same insurance rate.