Men typically pay more for car insurance than women, especially under age 25

Insurance companies charge men higher premiums than women in most states, and the gap is largest for drivers under 25. A 16-year-old male driver costs significantly more to insure than a 16-year-old female driver on the same policy. This difference narrows as drivers age, and by the mid-60s, the gap often reverses or disappears entirely.

The reason is statistical: young men file more claims for accidents, speeding tickets, and reckless driving than young women in the same age group. Insurance companies use decades of claims data to set rates, and that data consistently shows young male drivers pose a higher risk. The difference is not a judgment about individual drivers—it reflects group averages that insurers are legally allowed to use.

However, not every state permits gender-based pricing. California, Hawaii, Massachusetts, Montana, North Carolina, and Pennsylvania ban it. In those states, insurers must use other factors like age, driving record, and location instead. Even in states that allow gender pricing, some insurers choose not to use it.

Key Takeaways

  • Young men (under 25) pay 10 to 40 percent more than young women for the same coverage, depending on the state and insurer.
  • Six states ban gender-based insurance pricing entirely, so rates are identical regardless of gender in California, Hawaii, Massachusetts, Montana, North Carolina, and Pennsylvania.
  • The male-higher-rate pattern reverses around age 60 to 65, when women sometimes pay more, though the difference is usually smaller than it is for young drivers.
  • Married drivers of both genders pay less than single drivers, and this discount often exceeds the gender-based difference.
  • Your driving record, location, vehicle type, and coverage choices affect your rate far more than gender does in most cases.

Why insurers charge men more: the data behind the rates

Insurance companies do not set rates based on assumptions. They use actuarial data—real claim records from millions of drivers—to calculate risk. Young male drivers file more comprehensive and collision claims (accidents), more liability claims (hitting someone else), and more claims overall than young female drivers in the same age bracket.

The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) data shows that male drivers aged 16 to 19 are involved in fatal crashes at roughly twice the rate of female drivers the same age. Young men also receive more traffic citations for speeding and reckless driving. Because insurance is priced on risk, higher risk means higher premiums.

This pattern is consistent across insurers and states that allow gender pricing. It is not unique to one company or region—it reflects a measurable difference in claims frequency and severity. An insurer that did not charge more for young male drivers would lose money on that group and would have to raise rates on everyone else to compensate.

States that ban gender-based pricing

Six states have decided that gender should not be a rating factor, even though the statistical difference exists. In California, Hawaii, Massachusetts, Montana, North Carolina, and Pennsylvania, insurers must charge the same rate to a man and woman with identical age, driving record, vehicle, and coverage.

In these states, insurers rely on other factors to differentiate risk: age alone, marital status, years of driving experience, accident and violation history, credit score (where allowed), and vehicle type. Young male drivers in these states pay less than they would in states that allow gender pricing, while young female drivers pay the same or slightly more.

If you live in one of these states, your gender will not appear on your quote or policy. If you move to a state that allows gender pricing, your rate may change even if nothing else about your driving or vehicle changes.

How the gender gap changes with age

The male-higher-rate pattern is strongest between ages 16 and 25. A 17-year-old male might pay 30 to 50 percent more than a 17-year-old female. By age 30, the difference shrinks to 10 to 20 percent. By age 40, it may be 5 to 10 percent or disappear entirely.

Around age 60 to 65, the pattern sometimes reverses. Older women occasionally pay slightly more than older men, though the difference is usually smaller than the young-driver gap. This shift reflects changing claim patterns: older women file more claims for minor accidents and comprehensive coverage (theft, weather, vandalism), while older men's claims decrease.

By age 70 and beyond, gender differences in rates are minimal or nonexistent in most cases. Age itself becomes the dominant factor, and gender loses its predictive power.

Other factors that affect your rate more than gender

While gender can shift your premium by 10 to 40 percent depending on age and state, other factors often have a larger impact. Your driving record—accidents, violations, and claims history—typically affects your rate more than gender does. A single at-fault accident can raise your premium 20 to 40 percent for three to five years.

Your location matters significantly. Urban drivers pay more than rural drivers because accident frequency is higher in cities. Your vehicle type also affects price: a sports car costs more to insure than a sedan, regardless of who drives it. Coverage choices—liability limits, deductible amount, and optional coverage like collision—change your quote more than gender does.

Marital status is another major factor. Married drivers of both genders pay less than single drivers, and this discount often exceeds any gender-based difference. A married 22-year-old man might pay less than a single 22-year-old woman, even though young men typically pay more.

What to do if you think your rate is unfair

If you received a quote that seems high, the gender component may or may not be the reason. Request a detailed breakdown from the insurer showing which factors drove your rate. Most companies will explain the major components: age, driving record, location, vehicle, and coverage choices.

If you live in a state that bans gender pricing and your quote shows a gender-based adjustment, contact your state's insurance commissioner. If you live in a state that allows it and disagree with the practice, you can shop other insurers—some choose not to use gender as a rating factor even where it is legal.

Bundling policies (auto plus home or renters insurance), maintaining a clean driving record, raising your deductible, and taking a defensive driving course can lower your rate regardless of gender. These changes often save more money than the gender difference itself.

How to compare quotes across insurers

When you get quotes from different companies, the gender-based difference will vary. Some insurers weight young male drivers' risk more heavily than others. One company might charge a 25-year-old man 20 percent more than a 25-year-old woman; another might charge 35 percent more.

To see the actual difference, get quotes for the same person (same age, driving record, vehicle, coverage) from at least three insurers. You will see that the gender gap varies by company. You will also see that the total premium varies far more between insurers than the gender component does within a single insurer.

This is why shopping around matters. A 25-year-old man might pay $1,200 per year with one insurer and $950 with another—a difference of $250. The gender-based adjustment at each company might only be $100 to $150 of that total difference.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I get a lower rate by not disclosing my gender?

No. Insurers require you to provide your gender on the process, and it is illegal to lie. If you misrepresent your gender, the insurer can deny a claim or cancel your policy. In states that ban gender pricing, your gender is still collected but cannot be used in the rate calculation.

Do female drivers ever pay more than male drivers?

Yes, typically around age 60 and older. Older women file more claims for minor accidents and comprehensive coverage, so some insurers charge them slightly more. The difference is usually smaller than the young-driver gap. In states that ban gender pricing, this difference does not appear.

If I get married, will my rate go down?

Likely yes. Married drivers of both genders receive a discount, often 5 to 15 percent. This discount usually exceeds any gender-based difference. The discount applies because married drivers statistically file fewer claims than single drivers.

Does my gender affect my rate if I am a teen driver on my parent's policy?

Yes. Teen drivers listed on a parent's policy are rated individually, and gender affects that rating. A 16-year-old son will typically cost more to add to a parent's policy than a 16-year-old daughter in states that allow gender pricing.

Will my rate change if I move to a state that bans gender pricing?

Yes, it may. If you move from a state that allows gender pricing to one that bans it, your rate will be recalculated without the gender factor. Young men typically pay less after such a move; young women may pay the same or slightly more, depending on the insurer and other factors.