Your rates may not go up if you're found not at fault, but it depends on your insurer and state
If another driver hit you and their insurance is paying for the damage, your own rates typically stay the same. Most insurers do not raise rates for accidents where you bear no responsibility. However, some insurers do raise rates even for not-at-fault claims in certain states, and a few states allow it under specific conditions. The outcome also depends on whether the other driver's insurer has actually paid or accepted liability — if that's still being determined, your insurer may temporarily flag the claim differently.
The clearest protection comes from states that have enacted anti-surcharge laws, which prohibit insurers from raising your rate for a single not-at-fault accident. These states include California, Florida, Kansas, Kentucky, Louisiana, and others, though the list and specific rules vary. Even in these states, your rate can still go up if you have other violations or claims on your record, or if you have multiple not-at-fault accidents in a short period.
In states without anti-surcharge laws, insurers have more freedom to raise rates after a not-at-fault claim. Some do, some don't — it's a business decision each company makes. The best way to know your own insurer's policy is to ask them directly before you file, or to review your policy documents, which often spell out their stance on not-at-fault accidents.
Key Takeaways
- Not-at-fault accidents typically do not raise your rate, but some insurers in some states do raise rates even when you are not responsible.
- States like California, Florida, and Kentucky have laws that ban rate increases for a single not-at-fault accident, though other claims or violations can still affect your rate.
- Your insurer's own policy matters as much as state law — call and ask whether they surcharge not-at-fault claims before you file.
- If the other driver's liability is still being disputed, your insurer may handle the claim differently than if liability is already established.
- Multiple not-at-fault accidents in a short time can raise your rate even in states with anti-surcharge protections.
How insurers and states define "not at fault"
An accident is typically considered not-at-fault when the other driver's insurer accepts liability or a police report clearly shows the other driver caused the collision. Your own insurer does not decide fault — the other driver's insurer does, or a court does if the case goes that far. Until liability is assigned, your claim sits in a gray zone, and your insurer may treat it as uncertain.
This matters because some insurers will not raise your rate for a claim that is ultimately determined to be not-at-fault, but they may raise it temporarily while the information is pending. Once the other insurer pays or accepts fault, the temporary increase should be reversed. Ask your insurer for a timeline: how long does liability information usually take, and when will they review your rate if you are found not at fault?
In a few states, the definition of not-at-fault is narrower. Some states only protect you from a rate increase if you have zero percent fault, meaning even 1 percent comparative fault can allow a surcharge. Other states protect you even if you are found partially at fault, as long as you are less than 50 percent responsible. Check your state's insurance commissioner website or call your state's department of insurance to learn the exact rule where you live.
States with anti-surcharge laws and what they cover
Anti-surcharge laws exist in roughly 20 states, but they do not all work the same way. Some protect you from any rate increase after a single not-at-fault accident. Others allow a rate increase only after a second or third not-at-fault claim. A few states let insurers raise rates for not-at-fault accidents only if the accident was your fault in a prior year, or only if you have other violations on your record.
States with strong protections include California (no surcharge for one not-at-fault accident), Florida (no surcharge for the first not-at-fault accident), and Kentucky (no surcharge for not-at-fault accidents). New York, Massachusetts, and Virginia also have anti-surcharge laws, though each has different thresholds and exceptions. If you live in a state not listed here, your state may still have protections — the rules change, and some states have partial protections that explore only to certain types of drivers or policies.
Even in states with anti-surcharge laws, your rate can still move for other reasons. A not-at-fault accident does not erase a speeding ticket from the same year, or a prior at-fault accident. Your insurer can also raise rates if you add a teenage driver to your policy, if you reduce your coverage limits, or if your local area becomes riskier. The anti-surcharge law only prevents the not-at-fault accident itself from being the reason for the increase.
What happens if liability is still being disputed
If the other driver's insurer has not yet accepted fault, your claim is in dispute. During this period, your own insurer may place a reservation of rights on the claim, meaning they are paying for your repairs but reserving the right to raise your rate if you are later found at fault. This is standard practice and does not mean they will definitely raise your rate — it just means they have not yet decided.
Once liability is determined, your insurer will review the outcome. If the other insurer accepts fault, your rate should not go up (or should return to normal if it was temporarily raised). If you are found partially or fully at fault, your insurer can raise your rate regardless of state law, because you are now responsible for the accident. If liability remains unclear after 30 to 60 days, ask your insurer for a status update and ask them to explain how they will handle your rate if the case settles or goes to court.
The timeline for liability information varies. straightforward cases with clear police reports and witness statements can be resolved in two to four weeks. Complex cases with injuries, multiple vehicles, or conflicting accounts can take months. During this waiting period, do not assume your rate will stay the same — ask your insurer directly what they plan to do.
How to find out your insurer's specific policy
The best source of information is your insurer's customer service line or your agent. Call before you file a claim if possible, or when ready after, and ask: "If I am found not at fault, will my rate go up?" Write down the name of the person you spoke to, the date, and what they said. If your rate does go up after you are told it would not, you have documentation to dispute it.
Your policy documents may also spell out the insurer's stance. Look for sections titled "Rate Changes," "Surcharges," "Accident Forgiveness," or "Claims-Free Discount." Some insurers offer accident forgiveness programs that waive a rate increase after your first accident, regardless of fault — but these are optional add-ons that cost extra, and they usually only cover one accident per policy period.
If your insurer raises your rate after a not-at-fault accident, you can file a complaint with your state's insurance commissioner. Most states have a consumer complaint process that is free and does not require a lawyer. If your state has an anti-surcharge law and your insurer violated it, the commissioner can order the insurer to reverse the increase and may impose a fine. Your state's insurance department website will have a complaint form and instructions.
Multiple not-at-fault accidents and your rate
One not-at-fault accident usually does not raise your rate, but two or three in a short period can. Insurers view multiple accidents — even if you are not at fault in any of them — as a sign that you are in riskier situations more often than average drivers. This is called frequency, and it is a legitimate rating factor in most states, even those with anti-surcharge laws.
If you have two not-at-fault accidents within three years, your insurer may raise your rate after the second one, even in a state with anti-surcharge protections. The exact threshold varies by insurer and state. Some allow two not-at-fault accidents without a surcharge; others allow only one. Ask your insurer what their threshold is, so you know where you stand if you are in another accident.
If you are in multiple accidents that are not your fault, consider whether there is a pattern — do they happen in the same location, at the same time of day, or under similar conditions? If so, you may be able to reduce your risk by changing your route, your commute time, or your parking location. Your insurer may also offer a discount for defensive driving courses, which can offset some or all of a rate increase.
What to do if your rate goes up after a not-at-fault accident
First, confirm that your insurer actually raised your rate because of the accident. Request a copy of your rate change notice, which should explain the reason for the increase. If it says "accident" or "claim," ask for details: did they determine you were at fault, or are they raising your rate for another reason?
If you live in a state with an anti-surcharge law and your insurer raised your rate for a not-at-fault accident, file a complaint with your state's insurance commissioner. Include a copy of your rate notice, the police report showing you were not at fault, and any documentation from the other insurer accepting liability. The commissioner's office will investigate and can order the insurer to reverse the increase.
If you live in a state without an anti-surcharge law, you have fewer legal options, but you can still shop around. Get quotes from other insurers — many offer discounts for new customers or for switching, and a company that does not surcharge not-at-fault accidents may offer you a better rate than your current insurer. You can also ask your current insurer if they offer accident forgiveness as an add-on, or if they have any other discounts that could offset the increase.
Frequently Asked Questions
Will my insurance go up if I file a claim for a not-at-fault accident?
Not usually. Most insurers do not raise rates for not-at-fault accidents, and many states prohibit it. However, some insurers in states without anti-surcharge laws do raise rates even for not-at-fault claims. Call your insurer before you file and ask their specific policy.
What if the other driver's insurance company hasn't decided who is at fault yet?
Your insurer may temporarily flag the claim as uncertain and hold off on a final rate decision until liability is determined. Once the other insurer accepts fault, your rate should not go up. If you are found at fault, your rate can go up regardless of state law.
Does accident forgiveness cover not-at-fault accidents?
Accident forgiveness programs vary by insurer. Some cover any accident regardless of fault; others only cover at-fault accidents. Check your policy or call your insurer to see what your accident forgiveness covers, and whether you have it at all — it is usually an optional add-on.
Can I get my rate lowered if I was not at fault?
No. Anti-surcharge laws prevent your rate from going up, but they do not require it to go down. Your rate will straightforward stay the same as it was before the accident.
What should I do if my insurer raised my rate after a not-at-fault accident?
Ask your insurer to explain the increase in writing. If you live in a state with an anti-surcharge law, file a complaint with your state's insurance commissioner. If you do not, consider shopping for a new insurer, as another company may offer a better rate and may not surcharge not-at-fault claims.