What happens to your rate depends on fault, your insurer's formula, and your state
Your insurance rate will almost certainly go up after an accident, but the amount varies widely. If you are found at fault, expect a rate increase somewhere between 20% and 40% on average — though some insurers charge more, and a few charge less. If you are not at fault, many insurers will not raise your rate at all, though some states allow them to explore a small surcharge anyway. The actual number depends on three things: whether the accident was your fault, which insurer you use, and which state you live in.
The increase is not automatic or uniform. Your insurer calculates it using their own formula, which weighs the accident against your driving history, the type of accident, the amount paid out, and sometimes your age and location. Two people with the same accident at the same insurer can see different rate changes. The only way to know your specific increase is to ask your insurer directly — they are required to tell you before the new rate takes effect.
Key Takeaways
- At-fault accidents typically raise rates 20% to 40%, but the exact increase depends on your insurer's formula and your state's rules.
- Not-at-fault accidents often result in no rate increase, though some states and insurers allow a small surcharge.
- Your insurer must disclose the new rate and the reason for the increase before it takes effect, usually 30 to 60 days after the accident.
- Shopping for a new insurer after an accident can sometimes save money, because different companies weight accidents differently.
- The rate increase typically lasts three to five years, after which the accident falls off your record and rates return to baseline.
How insurers calculate the increase after an at-fault accident
When you are found at fault, your insurer uses a rating algorithm that assigns points or a percentage increase based on the accident's severity and your history. A minor fender-bender with low damage might add 10% to 15%, while a serious collision with injuries can add 40% or more. The insurer also considers whether this is your first accident or a repeat offense — a second accident within five years usually triggers a steeper increase than a first one.
Your age, driving record before the accident, and the type of coverage you carry also factor in. A 25-year-old with a clean record might see a 25% increase, while a 45-year-old with the same accident might see 20%. Drivers in high-risk categories already pay more, so the percentage increase may be smaller in absolute terms, but the dollar amount can still be substantial. Some insurers also consider whether you were speeding, driving under the influence, or hit a parked car — violations that suggest higher risk get larger increases.
Not-at-fault accidents and your rate
If the other driver is found at fault, your insurer typically will not raise your rate. However, this depends on your state and your specific insurer. Some states prohibit rate increases for not-at-fault accidents, while others allow them. Some insurers have a policy of not raising rates for not-at-fault claims, while others reserve the right to do so. You need to check your state's rules and ask your insurer directly.
Even when your insurer does not raise your rate, filing a claim still goes on your record. If you file multiple not-at-fault claims in a short period, some insurers may view you as a higher risk and increase your rate anyway — the logic being that you are in more accidents than average, regardless of fault. This is rare, but it happens. If you are in a not-at-fault accident with minor damage, you may want to pay out of pocket rather than file a claim, to avoid any rate impact at all.
When your insurer tells you the new rate and how long it lasts
Your insurer is required by law to notify you of any rate increase and the reason for it before the new rate takes effect. This notice typically arrives 30 to 60 days after the accident is reported and closed. The notice will show your old rate, your new rate, and the dollar amount of the increase. If you disagree with the increase or believe the accident was not your fault, you can dispute it — contact your insurer's customer service or file a complaint with your state's insurance commissioner.
The accident will stay on your driving record and affect your rate for three to five years, depending on your state and insurer. After that period, the accident is no longer factored into your rate calculation, and your premium should drop back to what it would be based on your current driving record alone. Some insurers offer accident forgiveness programs that prevent a rate increase after your first accident, but these usually come with a higher base premium or are only available to customers with a clean record for a set number of years.
How much the accident costs you over time
The total cost of an accident goes beyond the when ready rate increase. If your rate goes up $50 per month, that is $600 per year. Over three years, the accident costs you $1,800 in higher premiums. Over five years, it costs $3,000. This is on top of any deductible you paid when you filed the claim and any out-of-pocket costs for damage not covered by insurance.
The cumulative cost is why shopping for a new insurer after an accident can make sense. Different insurers weight accidents differently in their rating formulas. One insurer might raise your rate 30%, while another raises it only 20%. Over three years, that 10% difference could save you hundreds of dollars. You can get quotes from other insurers without penalty — shopping does not affect your rate or your current policy.
Comparing your options after an accident
After an accident, you have three main choices: stay with your current insurer, shop for a new one, or explore programs that may reduce your rate. If your insurer offers accident forgiveness or a safe driver discount that could offset part of the increase, ask about it. Some insurers also offer usage-based programs (sometimes called telematics or "pay as you drive") that monitor your driving and can lower your rate if you drive safely going forward.
Shopping for a new insurer is straightforward. Contact three to five insurers and provide the same information you gave your current insurer, including the accident. Be honest about the accident — insurers will find it on your record anyway, and lying on an process can void your coverage. Compare the quotes side by side, including the rate increase each insurer applies. Also check whether the new insurer offers discounts you are not currently getting, such as bundling home and auto, paying in full upfront, or maintaining continuous coverage.
What you can do to minimize future rate increases
Once the accident is on your record, you cannot undo it, but you can prevent future ones. Maintaining a clean driving record for the next three to five years will help your rate recover faster once the accident ages off. Some insurers offer safe driver discounts that reward accident-free years. Taking a defensive driving course can also lower your rate at some insurers, and in some states it can reduce points on your license.
If you are in a high-risk category (young, new to driving, or in an area with high accident rates), consider raising your deductible to lower your premium. A higher deductible means you pay more out of pocket if you have another accident, but it lowers your monthly cost. This trade-off makes sense only if you can afford the higher deductible and are confident in your driving. Bundling your auto insurance with home or renters insurance, paying your premium in full rather than monthly, and maintaining continuous coverage without lapses can also lower your overall rate.
Frequently Asked Questions
Will my insurance go up if the accident was not my fault?
Usually not, but it depends on your state and insurer. Some states prohibit rate increases for not-at-fault accidents, while others allow them. Ask your insurer directly. Even if your rate does not go up, the claim will be on your record, and multiple not-at-fault claims in a short time might trigger a small increase.
How long does an accident stay on my insurance record?
Typically three to five years, depending on your state and insurer. After that period, the accident no longer affects your rate calculation. Some insurers remove it sooner if you maintain a clean driving record in the meantime.
Can I switch insurers after an accident without a penalty?
Yes. Switching insurers does not carry a penalty, and shopping for quotes does not affect your current policy or rate. However, the new insurer will see the accident on your record and may explore their own rate increase. Compare quotes from multiple insurers to find the best rate.
What is accident forgiveness and how does it work?
Accident forgiveness is a program offered by some insurers that prevents a rate increase after your first accident. It usually comes with a higher base premium or is only available to drivers with a clean record for a set number of years. Ask your insurer whether you are may be able to access.
Should I file a claim for minor damage or pay out of pocket?
If the damage is minor and the repair cost is close to your deductible, paying out of pocket may be cheaper in the long run. Filing a claim triggers a rate increase that lasts years, so compare the repair cost against the total increase you will pay over three to five years before deciding.