Your rate increase is not automatic, and the size of it depends on what you report and how your insurer classifies the accident

An accident does not always raise your insurance rate. Whether your premium goes up, by how much, and for how long depends on three things: whether the accident was your fault, what your policy covers, and your insurer's own rules about rate increases. Some insurers raise rates only for at-fault accidents; others raise them for any claim. Some offer accident forgiveness programs that prevent the first accident from affecting your rate at all. The steps you take in the days after the accident — what you report, how you document it, and whether you challenge the fault information — directly affect whether you pay more.

The most important factor is fault. If the other driver caused the accident, your insurer typically does not raise your rate because you did not create the risk. If you caused it, your rate will likely go up. But even that is not automatic — some insurers have accident forgiveness built into certain policies, and some states limit how much or how long an insurer can use an accident to raise your rate.

Key Takeaways

  • Not-at-fault accidents typically do not raise your rate, but your insurer must determine fault before your rate is set, which takes weeks or months.
  • Accident forgiveness programs prevent your first accident from raising your rate, but you must have enrolled before the accident happened.
  • If your insurer assigns you fault and you disagree, you can request a review or file a complaint with your state insurance commissioner.
  • Raising your deductible lowers your premium but means you pay more out of pocket if you file another claim.
  • Shopping for a new insurer after an accident can sometimes cost less than staying with your current one, even if your rate goes up.

Why not-at-fault accidents usually do not raise your rate

If the other driver caused the accident, your insurer typically does not raise your rate because you did not create the risk. The other driver's insurance should pay for the damage. However, your insurer must first determine who was at fault, and that information takes time — usually four to eight weeks, sometimes longer if the accident is disputed.

During that waiting period, your rate may appear to go up temporarily in your account, or your renewal notice may show a higher premium. This is not final. Once the other insurer accepts fault or a police report clearly shows the other driver caused the accident, your insurer will usually remove the rate increase or issue a credit. Keep copies of the police report and any correspondence from the other insurer stating they accept fault, because you may need to show these to your insurer to reverse a temporary increase.

How accident forgiveness works and whether you have it

Accident forgiveness is a program that prevents your first accident from raising your rate, regardless of fault. If you have it, your rate stays the same after an accident. The catch: you must have enrolled in the program before the accident happened. You cannot sign up after a claim and have it cover that claim retroactively.

Check your policy documents or call your insurer to learn about you have accident forgiveness. Ask specifically whether it covers the first accident, the first at-fault accident, or both. Some insurers offer it free to certain customers; others charge a small monthly fee. If you do not have it and your insurer offers it, you can enroll now to protect yourself from future accidents — but it will not help with the current one.

Disputing a fault information if you believe you were not at fault

If your insurer determines you were at fault and you disagree, you have the right to challenge that decision. Start by calling your insurer's claims department and asking for a review. Explain why you believe you were not at fault and provide any evidence: the police report, photos, witness statements, or dashcam footage. Your insurer will re-examine the claim, though they are not required to change their decision.

If your insurer stands by their fault information, you can file a complaint with your state's insurance commissioner or department of insurance. This is a free process. The commissioner's office will investigate whether your insurer followed state law in making the information. You can find your state insurance commissioner's contact information through the National Association of Insurance Commissioners website. A successful complaint can result in your insurer reversing the fault information and removing the rate increase.

Requesting a rate review or shopping for a new insurer

After an accident, your current insurer may raise your rate significantly. Before accepting it, call and ask if there are discounts you are not using — bundling home and auto, good driver discounts, low-mileage discounts, or safety feature discounts. Sometimes explore a discount you overlooked can offset part of the increase.

If your rate still feels high, get quotes from at least two other insurers. Some insurers are more forgiving of accidents than others, and a company that would charge you 30 percent more might be the same company that charges a new customer with the same accident history only 15 percent more. When you get quotes, tell each insurer about the accident so the quotes are accurate. You may find that switching saves you money even after the accident. If you do switch, make sure there is no gap in coverage — have the new policy start on the same day your old one ends.

Raising your deductible to lower your premium

If your rate increased but you want to lower your monthly payment, you can raise your deductible — the amount you pay out of pocket before insurance covers the rest. Raising your deductible from $500 to $1,000, for example, will lower your premium. However, this means if you have another accident, you will pay $1,000 instead of $500 before your insurance kicks in.

This strategy makes sense only if you have savings to cover the higher deductible and if you are confident you will not have another accident soon. If you are a new driver or have had multiple accidents, raising your deductible can leave you unable to afford repairs if something happens again. Calculate how much you would save per month and how long it would take that savings to add up to the extra deductible you would pay — if it is more than a year, the math does not work in your favor.

How long an accident stays on your record and affects your rate

An accident typically affects your rate for three to five years, depending on your state and insurer. Some insurers drop the surcharge after three years; others keep it for five. A few states limit how long an insurer can use an accident to raise rates — check your state's insurance commissioner website to see if yours does.

You can ask your insurer when the accident will stop affecting your rate. They can tell you the exact date. After that date, your rate should return to what it would have been without the accident, though it may still be higher than it was before if other factors have changed, like your age or the cost of repairs in your area.

Frequently Asked Questions

Will my insurance go up if the accident was not my fault?

Usually not, but your insurer must determine fault first, which takes weeks. Your rate may appear to increase temporarily until the other insurer accepts fault. Once they do, your insurer will typically remove the increase or credit your account. Keep the police report and any written statement from the other insurer accepting fault.

Can I get accident forgiveness after an accident has already happened?

No. Accident forgiveness must be in place before the accident occurs. If you do not have it, you cannot enroll retroactively to cover a claim you have already filed. You can enroll now to protect yourself from future accidents.

What if I think my insurer assigned fault incorrectly?

Call your insurer's claims department and request a review, providing the police report and any evidence supporting your position. If they do not change their decision, file a complaint with your state insurance commissioner. The commissioner's office will investigate whether your insurer followed state law.

How much will my rate increase after an accident?

The increase varies by insurer, state, and whether the accident was your fault. At-fault accidents typically raise rates between 20 and 40 percent, but some insurers charge more or less. Get quotes from multiple insurers to see how much your specific accident will cost with each company.

Should I raise my deductible to lower my premium after an accident?

Only if you have savings to cover the higher deductible and do not expect another accident soon. Calculate how many months of premium savings it would take to equal the extra deductible you would pay — if it is more than a year, staying at your current deductible is usually smarter.