Your rates usually won't go up if the accident wasn't your fault
If you were not at fault for the accident, most insurance companies will not raise your rates. The at-fault driver's insurance is supposed to cover the damage, and your insurer has no reason to penalize you for someone else's mistake. However, this protection is not automatic everywhere, and a few situations can still affect your premiums even when you're not responsible.
The key word here is "usually." Your state's insurance laws, your specific policy, and how your insurer handles claims all play a role. Some states have laws that explicitly prevent rate increases for not-at-fault accidents. Others leave it to the insurance company's discretion. Understanding which category your state falls into, and what your policy actually says, keeps you from being surprised when your renewal notice arrives.
Key Takeaways
- Most states prohibit insurers from raising rates for accidents where you were not at fault, but the rules vary by state and by insurer.
- Even in a not-at-fault accident, your rate may increase if your insurer cannot recover the full cost from the other driver's insurance.
- Filing a claim for a not-at-fault accident is usually safer than paying out of pocket, because it creates an official record that protects you later.
- Some insurers offer accident forgiveness programs that prevent rate increases for your first accident, regardless of fault.
- Your policy documents and your state's insurance commissioner's office can tell you exactly what your insurer is allowed to do.
How state laws protect not-at-fault drivers
Many states have enacted laws that specifically ban insurers from raising rates after a not-at-fault accident. These laws recognize that penalizing a driver for an accident they did not cause is unfair and does not reflect their actual risk. States with these protections include California, Florida, Georgia, Illinois, Louisiana, Michigan, New York, Ohio, Pennsylvania, and Texas, though the exact rules differ between them.
The catch is that these protections usually only explore if the other driver was found at fault—either by their insurance company, a police report, or a court judgment. If liability is unclear or disputed, your insurer may treat the claim differently. Some states also allow rate increases if your insurer cannot recover the full amount from the other driver's insurance, which can happen if that driver is uninsured or underinsured.
If you live in a state without explicit not-at-fault protection, your insurer has more freedom to raise your rates after any accident, even if you were not responsible. This is one reason to check your state's insurance commissioner's website or call your insurer directly before filing a claim—so you know what to expect.
What happens when the other driver's insurance won't pay
Even in states that protect not-at-fault drivers, your rates can still increase if the other driver's insurance refuses to pay or pays only part of the claim. This happens most often when the other driver is uninsured, underinsured, or disputes fault. In these cases, your own collision or comprehensive coverage kicks in to cover the damage, and your insurer may treat it more like a claim against your own policy.
If you have uninsured motorist coverage or underinsured motorist coverage, your insurer will use that to pay for the damage instead of the other driver's insurance. Depending on your state and your policy, this may or may not trigger a rate increase. Some states treat uninsured motorist claims the same as not-at-fault accidents and prohibit rate hikes. Others allow increases because the claim came from your own policy, not the other driver's.
The best protection here is to make sure the police report clearly documents that the other driver was at fault. If the other driver's insurance later denies the claim, you have an official record to dispute it. You can also ask your insurer to pursue subrogation—the legal process of recovering the money from the other driver's insurance after paying your claim—which can prevent a rate increase if they succeed.
Accident forgiveness and other rate protections
Some insurers offer accident forgiveness programs that prevent your first accident from raising your rates, regardless of fault. This is usually an optional add-on to your policy that costs a small amount each month. If you have accident forgiveness and you cause an accident, your rates will not go up. If you are in a not-at-fault accident, you would not need it anyway, but it provides a safety net if fault is disputed later.
Other insurers offer safe driver discounts or claim-free discounts that you keep as long as you do not file a claim within a certain period—usually three to five years. A not-at-fault accident may or may not count against these discounts, depending on the insurer's rules. Some treat not-at-fault claims as invisible to the discount, while others count any claim as a break in your safe driving record.
Ask your insurer whether you have accident forgiveness, what discounts you currently receive, and whether a not-at-fault claim would affect them. This information should be in your policy documents or available by calling your agent. If you do not have accident forgiveness and your insurer allows it, adding it before an accident happens is much cheaper than dealing with a rate increase afterward.
The difference between filing a claim and paying out of pocket
You might be tempted to avoid filing a claim for a not-at-fault accident and instead ask the other driver to pay for repairs directly. This feels safer—no claim on your record, no risk of a rate increase. But this approach has serious downsides that often outweigh the benefit.
When you file a claim, your insurer investigates and documents fault. That official record protects you if the other driver later disputes responsibility or if their insurance company denies the claim. If you pay out of pocket and the other driver later refuses to reimburse you, you have no recourse except small claims court. You also lose the protection of your insurer's legal team, which can be valuable if the other driver sues you or if the accident is more complicated than it first appears.
Filing a claim also creates a paper trail that proves you reported the accident promptly and honestly. If you wait weeks or months to file, or if you file after the other driver has already filed against you, it can look suspicious and make it harder to prove you were not at fault. In most states, you have a time limit to report an accident to your insurer—usually 30 to 90 days—so waiting is risky.
What to do before filing a not-at-fault claim
Before you file, call your insurer and ask three specific questions: Does your state law protect not-at-fault drivers? Does your policy have accident forgiveness? Will this claim affect any of your current discounts? Write down the answers and the name of the person who gave them to you. This creates a record if your rates do go up and you need to dispute it.
Get a copy of the police report if one was filed. The report's information of fault carries weight with insurance companies and can help your claim move faster. If no police report was filed, ask the other driver for their insurance information and take photos of the damage, the accident scene, and any visible injuries. Do not admit fault or apologize for the accident, even if you feel bad—anything you say can be used against you later.
When you file the claim, tell your insurer clearly that you were not at fault and provide all the evidence you have. If the other driver's insurance company contacts you, stick to the facts and do not agree to anything without your insurer's approval. Your insurer's claims adjuster will handle the back-and-forth with the other driver's insurance, so you do not have to manage it yourself.
How to check your state's rules and your policy
Your state's insurance commissioner's office maintains a consumer guide that explains the rules for your state. You can find it by searching "[your state] insurance commissioner not-at-fault accident" or by visiting your state's insurance department website. These guides are free and written in plain language, and they explain exactly what your insurer can and cannot do.
Your policy documents should also spell out the rules. Look for sections titled "Rate Increases," "Claims," or "Accident Forgiveness." If the language is unclear, call your insurer's customer service line and ask them to explain it. You have the right to know how your rates can change, and most insurers will answer this question directly.
If your rates do increase after a not-at-fault accident, you can dispute it. Contact your state's insurance commissioner's office and file a complaint. If your state law prohibits the increase, the commissioner can force your insurer to reverse it. Even if your state does not have explicit protection, the commissioner's office can review whether the increase was applied fairly and consistently with your policy.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can my insurance company raise my rates if I was hit by an uninsured driver?
It depends on your state and your policy. If you have uninsured motorist coverage, your own insurance pays for the damage, and your insurer may treat it differently than a not-at-fault accident covered by the other driver's insurance. Some states prohibit rate increases even in this situation; others allow them. Check your state's rules and call your insurer to find out what applies to you.
Will filing a not-at-fault claim affect my safe driver discount?
Some insurers count any claim against your safe driver discount, while others exclude not-at-fault claims. This varies by company, so you need to ask your specific insurer. If you have a large discount, it may be worth paying for minor repairs out of pocket to keep the discount, but for major damage, filing a claim is usually the safer choice.
What if the other driver's insurance says I was at fault when I wasn't?
You can dispute their information. Provide the police report, photos, witness statements, and any other evidence that shows you were not at fault. Your insurer's claims adjuster will handle this dispute on your behalf. If the other insurer still refuses to pay, your insurer can pursue subrogation or use your own collision coverage and try to recover the money later.
Does a not-at-fault accident stay on my driving record?
An accident may appear on your driving record, but whether it affects your insurance rates is separate. Your driving record is maintained by your state's Department of Motor Vehicles, while your insurance record is maintained by your insurer. A not-at-fault accident on your driving record should not raise your rates in states with not-at-fault protections, but it may still show up if someone runs a background check.
Should I add accident forgiveness to my policy?
If your insurer offers it at a reasonable cost, it is worth considering, especially if you are a younger or less experienced driver. It protects you if you cause an accident or if fault is disputed. However, it does not help with a clear not-at-fault accident, so it is not essential if you live in a state that already protects not-at-fault drivers.