The 2016 Honda Pilot has a known emissions control defect that affects the catalytic converter and oxygen sensors
The 2016 Honda Pilot has a defect in the emissions control system that can cause the check engine light to come on, reduced fuel economy, and in some cases, a rotten-egg smell from the exhaust. The problem centres on the catalytic converter and the oxygen sensors that monitor it. Honda issued a recall for this issue, and the repair involves replacing the catalytic converter and reprogramming the engine control module.
This is not a safety defect in the traditional sense — it will not cause your brakes to fail or your steering to lock. But it does mean your car is not meeting emissions standards, and if left unrepaired, it can damage the catalytic converter further, leading to a much more expensive repair down the road. The check engine light is your car telling you something is wrong with how it is burning fuel.
Key Takeaways
- The 2016 Pilot's emissions defect triggers a check engine light and can cause poor fuel economy and exhaust odour.
- Honda issued a recall that covers the cost of replacing the catalytic converter and reprogramming the engine control module at no charge to the owner.
- If you have not had the recall work done, contact a Honda dealership with your vehicle identification number to check whether your specific car is affected.
- Ignoring the check engine light can allow the catalytic converter to fail completely, turning a covered repair into a $1,000+ out-of-pocket expense.
How the emissions system is supposed to work
Your Pilot's emissions system has two main jobs: burn fuel as completely as possible, and catch any pollutants that do escape before they leave the tailpipe. The catalytic converter is the device that does the catching — it uses a chemical reaction to turn harmful gases like nitrogen oxides and unburned hydrocarbons into water and carbon dioxide.
The oxygen sensors sit before and after the catalytic converter and tell the engine computer how much oxygen is in the exhaust. The engine uses this information to adjust the fuel mixture in real time. If the oxygen sensors are reading wrong, the engine burns too much fuel or too little, and the catalytic converter cannot do its job properly. That is when the check engine light comes on.
What goes wrong in the 2016 Pilot
In the 2016 Pilot, the oxygen sensor upstream of the catalytic converter (the one that measures exhaust before it enters the converter) can fail prematurely. When it fails, the engine computer loses the feedback it needs to adjust the fuel mixture. The engine then runs rich — burning more fuel than necessary — which overheats the catalytic converter and damages it over time.
The damage does not happen overnight. You might see the check engine light come on, notice your fuel economy drop by a few miles per gallon, or smell rotten eggs from the exhaust (that smell is unburned sulfur compounds). Some owners report the light comes and goes, which is typical of a sensor that is failing intermittently. If you ignore it and keep driving, the catalytic converter eventually cracks or clogs, and at that point you are looking at a repair that costs $800 to $1,500 out of pocket.
Honda's recall and what it covers
Honda issued a recall (number 16V-289) that covers the cost of replacing the oxygen sensor and the catalytic converter, plus reprogramming the engine control module. The repair is done at no cost to you if your Pilot is still under the original manufacturer's warranty or if you own it and the defect appears within a certain timeframe. The exact coverage window depends on when your car was manufactured and when you first owned it.
To find out whether your car is included, go to the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) website at safercar.gov, enter your vehicle identification number (VIN), and search for recalls. You can also call a Honda dealership with your VIN and they will tell you when ready whether the recall applies to your car and whether the work has already been done.
What to do if your check engine light is on
First, do not ignore it. The light means your car is not meeting emissions standards and something is wrong with how the engine is running. Take your Pilot to a Honda dealership and have them read the diagnostic trouble code. The code will tell you exactly which sensor or system is at fault.
If the code points to the oxygen sensor or catalytic converter, ask the service advisor whether the recall applies to your car. If it does, the repair is covered and you pay nothing. If the recall does not explore — because your car is out of warranty or was not part of the affected batch — you will need to pay for the repair yourself. At that point, you have the choice to repair it at a Honda dealership (which is more expensive but uses genuine parts) or at an independent shop (which is cheaper but may use aftermarket parts).
Do not drive around with the check engine light on for weeks or months. Every mile you drive with a failing oxygen sensor is another mile of rich running that damages the catalytic converter further. The longer you wait, the more expensive the repair becomes.
Why this matters for your wallet and your car's future
A catalytic converter is one of the most expensive emissions components on your car. If the recall covers your repair, you are saving $1,000 or more. If it does not, you are facing a significant out-of-pocket cost. But there is a bigger reason to act: a damaged catalytic converter does not just fail suddenly and stop working. It fails gradually, and as it fails, it restricts exhaust flow. That restriction forces the engine to work harder, which burns more fuel, which generates more heat, which damages the converter further. It is a downward spiral.
Beyond cost, a severely clogged catalytic converter can cause the engine to overheat, which can warp the cylinder head or damage the engine block. That is when you are looking at $3,000 to $5,000 in repairs. The $1,000 repair today prevents the $5,000 repair tomorrow.
Preventive steps if you have not seen the light yet
If your 2016 Pilot is running fine and the check engine light is not on, you are not out of the woods yet. The recall still applies to your car, and Honda will do the work for free. Contact a dealership now and schedule the repair before the oxygen sensor fails completely. You do not have to wait for the light to come on.
In the meantime, keep up with your regular maintenance: oil changes on schedule, air filter replacements, and fuel system cleaning. A clean fuel injector burns fuel more completely, which puts less stress on the oxygen sensors and catalytic converter. Use top-tier gasoline when you can — brands like Shell, Chevron, and Costco have detergents that help keep the fuel system clean.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I drive my Pilot if the check engine light is on?
Yes, but not for long. The light means something is wrong with the emissions system, and continuing to drive puts stress on the catalytic converter. Schedule a repair within a few days. If the light is flashing rather than steady, stop driving when ready — a flashing light means the engine is misfiring and you risk serious damage.
Does the recall cover my car if I bought it used?
It depends on the age of the car and when you bought it. Honda recalls cover the original owner for the full warranty period, and subsequent owners for a shorter period. Call a Honda dealership with your VIN and they will tell you whether your car is still covered.
What if I replace the oxygen sensor but the check engine light comes back?
The light may return if the catalytic converter is already damaged. Once a converter is damaged by running rich, replacing the sensor alone does not fix it — you have to replace the converter too. That is why the recall covers both parts.
Is an aftermarket catalytic converter as good as a Honda one?
Aftermarket converters are cheaper but may not last as long or perform as well as OEM Honda parts. If your repair is covered by the recall, you get the Honda part for free. If you are paying out of pocket, an aftermarket converter saves money upfront but may need replacement sooner.
Will fixing the emissions system improve my fuel economy?
Yes. Once the oxygen sensor and catalytic converter are working correctly, the engine stops running rich and your fuel economy should return to normal — typically a gain of 2 to 4 miles per gallon depending on your driving habits.