What happens when you file a claim with Auto Owners Insurance
When you file a claim with Auto Owners Insurance, you contact their claims department by phone, online, or through their mobile app, and report the damage or loss. A claims adjuster is assigned to your case and will ask for details about what happened, when it happened, and where your vehicle is located. Auto Owners will then arrange for an inspection of your vehicle — either at a repair shop, at a drive-in claims center, or sometimes at your home — to assess the damage and determine what they will cover under your policy.
The adjuster uses the inspection findings and your policy terms to decide what repairs or replacement costs Auto Owners will pay for. You will receive a written settlement offer that explains what is covered, what is not, and how much money you will get. If you accept the offer, Auto Owners pays the repair shop directly (if you choose one they work with) or reimburses you after you pay out of pocket. The entire process typically takes one to three weeks, though complex claims or disputes can take longer.
Key Takeaways
- Report your claim to Auto Owners within a reasonable time by calling their claims line, using their website, or opening the mobile app — the sooner you report, the sooner the process starts.
- An adjuster will inspect your vehicle and determine what your policy covers based on the type of damage and your deductible amount.
- Auto Owners will send you a written settlement offer showing the repair cost they will pay and what you owe as your deductible.
- You can choose your own repair shop or use one Auto Owners recommends, and the company will typically pay the shop directly once you agree to the settlement.
- Keep all receipts, photos, and correspondence with Auto Owners in case you need to dispute the settlement or file a follow-up claim.
How to report a claim to Auto Owners
Auto Owners offers three main ways to report a claim. The fastest is usually their phone line — call the claims number on the back of your insurance card or on their website, and a representative will take your information right away. You can also start a claim online through your Auto Owners account or through their mobile app if you have one installed. Online and app-based claims let you upload photos of the damage when ready, which can speed up the inspection process.
When you report, have ready the other driver's information (if another vehicle was involved), the police report number (if one was filed), photos of the damage, and your vehicle's location. Auto Owners will ask what happened, when it happened, whether anyone was injured, and whether police were called. Answer honestly and stick to the facts — do not speculate about fault or agree to anything beyond describing what you saw. The representative will give you a claim number and tell you what to expect next.
What the adjuster does during inspection
After you report the claim, Auto Owners assigns an adjuster who will contact you to schedule an inspection. The adjuster's job is to look at the damage, determine what caused it, and estimate the cost to repair or replace your vehicle. They will take photos, measure damage, and check whether the damage is covered under your specific policy — for example, collision coverage pays for accidents, but comprehensive coverage pays for theft, weather, or vandalism.
The inspection usually happens at a repair shop (often one Auto Owners works with), at a drive-in claims center, or at your home if your car is not drivable. You do not have to use Auto Owners' preferred shop — you can choose your own — but using their network shop can sometimes speed up payment because the shop and insurer already have a working relationship. The adjuster will also verify your deductible amount and confirm that your policy was active at the time of the loss.
Understanding your settlement offer
After the inspection, Auto Owners sends you a written settlement offer. This document shows the total repair cost the adjuster estimated, subtracts your deductible, and tells you how much Auto Owners will pay. For example, if repairs cost $5,000 and your deductible is $500, Auto Owners will pay $4,500. The settlement also lists what is covered and what is not — such as rental car coverage, glass coverage, or diminished value — depending on what your policy includes.
Read the settlement carefully and compare it to repair estimates you may have gotten from your own shop. If you disagree with the amount, you can ask Auto Owners to reconsider, provide your own estimate, or request a second inspection. Some policies include appraisal clauses that let you and Auto Owners each pick an appraiser, and those two appraisers pick a third if they disagree — this is a formal way to resolve disputes without going to court. Ask your adjuster whether your policy has this option if you think the estimate is too low.
Choosing a repair shop and getting paid
Once you accept the settlement, you can take your vehicle to any repair shop you choose — you are not required to use Auto Owners' preferred network. If you use a shop Auto Owners works with regularly, the shop and insurer can often coordinate directly, and you may only pay your deductible upfront. If you choose an independent shop, you may need to pay the full bill and then submit receipts to Auto Owners for reimbursement, or the shop can bill Auto Owners directly if you sign an authorization form.
Before repairs begin, make sure the shop knows the amount Auto Owners approved. If repairs cost more than the settlement (for example, if hidden damage is found during work), the shop should contact Auto Owners for approval before proceeding. Keep all receipts and invoices — you will need them to prove what was repaired and what you paid. If Auto Owners is paying the shop directly, ask for a copy of the paid invoice for your records.
Tracking your claim status
Auto Owners lets you check your claim status online through your account or by calling your adjuster directly using the claim number you received when you reported. Their website and app usually show where your claim stands — whether it is under review, awaiting inspection, awaiting your decision on the settlement, or closed. You can also see any documents Auto Owners has on file, such as the inspection report or settlement offer.
If you have not heard from your adjuster within a few business days of reporting, follow up by phone. Do not wait passively — adjusters handle many claims at once, and a quick call can keep yours moving. If you disagree with the settlement or have questions about what is covered, ask your adjuster to explain in writing. Keep a record of every conversation, including the date, time, and name of the person you spoke with.
What to do if you disagree with the settlement
If Auto Owners' estimate seems too low or you believe they denied coverage unfairly, you have several options. First, ask your adjuster to explain their reasoning in detail and provide the inspection report. Sometimes a misunderstanding can be cleared up with a conversation. If you still disagree, get a written estimate from an independent repair shop and send it to Auto Owners with a letter explaining why you think their estimate is low.
If Auto Owners denies your claim entirely, ask for a written explanation of why — they must tell you which policy language supports their decision. You can then review your policy to see whether you think they interpreted it correctly. If you believe Auto Owners made an error, you can file a complaint with your state's insurance commissioner (the contact information is on your state's insurance department website). You can also consult with an attorney who handles insurance disputes, though this is usually a last resort for high-value claims.
Documents to keep after filing a claim
Save everything related to your claim in one folder — physical or digital. This includes your claim number, the settlement offer, the inspection report, repair estimates, receipts from the repair shop, photos of the damage, the police report (if one exists), and copies of all emails or letters from Auto Owners. If you had to rent a car while yours was being repaired, keep those receipts too if your policy covers rental reimbursement.
These documents protect you if a question comes up later — for example, if a repair fails and you need to file a second claim, or if Auto Owners later disputes something about the original claim. They also help if you need to file a complaint with your state insurance commissioner or work with an attorney. Keep these records for at least three to five years after the claim closes.
Frequently Asked Questions
How long does an Auto Owners claim usually take?
Most claims are resolved within one to three weeks from the time you report them. straightforward claims with clear damage and no dispute over coverage move faster. Complex claims — such as those involving multiple vehicles, injuries, or disagreement over the repair estimate — can take four to eight weeks or longer.
Do I have to use an Auto Owners preferred repair shop?
No. You can choose any repair shop you want. Auto Owners' preferred shops may offer faster coordination with the insurer and sometimes waive your deductible, but you are not required to use them. If you choose an independent shop, you may need to pay upfront and seek reimbursement, or ask the shop to bill Auto Owners directly.
What if the repair shop finds more damage than the adjuster estimated?
The repair shop should stop work and contact Auto Owners (and you) before proceeding with repairs that exceed the approved estimate. Auto Owners will either approve the additional cost or send another adjuster to inspect the hidden damage. Do not let the shop proceed without approval, or you may end up paying the difference yourself.
Can I get a rental car while my vehicle is being repaired?
Only if your policy includes rental reimbursement coverage — this is optional and not included in every Auto Owners policy. Check your policy documents or call Auto Owners to see whether you have this coverage and what the daily limit is. If you do have it, ask your adjuster or repair shop about rental car arrangements when you accept the settlement.
What should I do if Auto Owners denies my claim?
Ask Auto Owners for a written explanation of why they denied it and which part of your policy they are relying on. Review your policy to see if you agree with their interpretation. If you believe they made an error, you can file a complaint with your state's insurance commissioner, who can investigate whether Auto Owners followed state law.