What you need to know before replacing a car key
Changing a car key depends on what kind of key you have and what went wrong with it. A traditional metal key blank costs $5 to $15 and takes minutes to cut at a hardware store or dealership. A key fob with electronics costs $50 to $400 and usually requires programming at a dealership or by a locksmith who has the right equipment. If your key is lost or broken, you have three main routes: a hardware store, a locksmith, or your car's dealership. Each has different costs, speed, and limitations.
The first step is knowing whether you need just a physical key cut, a fob programmed, or both. Many newer cars use a key fob that must be programmed to your specific vehicle — a hardware store cannot do this. Older cars with straightforward metal keys are much cheaper and faster to replace anywhere. Your car's year, make, and model determine which option works for you.
Key Takeaways
- A basic metal key cut at a hardware store costs $5 to $15 and takes minutes, but only works for older cars without electronic locks.
- Key fobs with buttons and electronics must be programmed to your car and cost $50 to $400 depending on the vehicle and where you go.
- Dealerships are the most expensive option but can handle any key type and have your car's exact programming data on file.
- Locksmiths are often faster and cheaper than dealerships for key cutting and programming, but verify they can work with your specific vehicle before you call.
- If you have a spare key at home, you can use it while a replacement is being made, which buys you time to find the cheapest option.
Getting a basic metal key cut at a hardware store
If your car is older or uses a straightforward mechanical key without a fob, a hardware store is the fastest and cheapest option. Bring your current key or a photo of it, and the associate will cut a blank to match. The whole process takes 5 to 10 minutes. Cost is typically $5 to $15 per key.
This works only if your car does not have electronic locks, a keyless entry system, or a push-button start. If you turn a physical key in the door and ignition, you can almost certainly use a hardware store. If you press buttons on a fob or push a button to start the engine, you need programming, which a hardware store cannot do.
Hardware stores that cut keys include Home Depot, Lowe's, Ace Hardware, and most local locksmiths. Call ahead to confirm they have blanks for your car's key type, especially if you drive an older or less common vehicle.
Programming a key fob at a dealership
Your car's dealership can program any key fob for your vehicle because they have access to your car's VIN and the manufacturer's programming system. This is the most reliable option if you have lost all your keys or need a fob that works with a newer security system. Dealerships typically charge $100 to $400 for a new fob and programming combined, depending on the vehicle.
Call the dealership's parts or service department with your car's VIN and ask for the cost of a replacement key fob and programming. Many dealerships require you to prove ownership before they will program a key, so bring your registration or title. Turnaround is usually one to three business days, though some dealerships can do it the same day if you visit in person.
The downside is cost and time. If you need a key urgently and the dealership is closed or has a long wait, a locksmith may be faster. However, if your car has a complex security system or you want certainty the fob will work perfectly, the dealership is worth the extra cost.
Using a locksmith for faster key replacement
A locksmith can cut metal keys and program fobs for most vehicles at a lower cost and faster turnaround than a dealership. Locksmiths typically charge $50 to $200 for a new fob and programming, depending on the vehicle and how quickly you need it. Many offer same-day service or can come to your location if you are locked out.
Before you call, confirm the locksmith works with your car's make and model. Not all locksmiths have the equipment to program every brand of fob — some specialize in certain manufacturers. Ask whether they can program your specific vehicle and what the total cost will be, including any service call fee if they come to you.
Locksmiths are especially useful if you are locked out of your car and need a key when ready, or if you need a spare made outside business hours. However, choose a licensed, insured locksmith with good reviews. Check your state's licensing requirements — some states require locksmiths to be bonded and registered.
What to do if you have lost all your keys
If you have lost every key to your car, you have two options: tow the car to a dealership or call a locksmith who can come to you. You cannot start the car without at least one working key, so you will need to arrange transport.
A dealership can make a new key from your VIN alone, but you must prove ownership with your registration or title. This is the safest route if you are concerned about security — the dealership will reprogram the locks so old keys no longer work. A locksmith can do the same thing, but verify they offer this service before you hire them.
Cost for a complete key replacement from a dealership is typically $150 to $400 depending on the vehicle. A locksmith may charge $100 to $300. If your car is financed or leased, contact your lender or leasing company first — some require you to use the dealership for security reasons.
Replacing a broken key
If your key broke in the lock or snapped in half, do not try to force the pieces out or turn the lock further. Stop using that lock when ready to avoid damaging the mechanism inside.
For a broken key in the ignition, turn off the car and call a locksmith or dealership. Do not try to extract it yourself with pliers or tweezers — you risk breaking off more pieces inside the lock. A locksmith can usually remove the broken piece and cut a new key in one visit.
For a broken key in the door lock, use the other door to enter your car if you have a spare key. If you do not have a spare, call a locksmith. Extraction and replacement typically costs $75 to $200 depending on how badly the lock is damaged.
Making a spare key before you need one
The cheapest time to make a spare key is when you still have a working original. A hardware store can cut a basic metal key for $5 to $15. If your car has a fob, ask your dealership or a locksmith to program a spare fob while you have your original key — this costs $50 to $150 and takes one visit.
Keep your spare key in a safe place at home, not in your car or wallet. If you lose your main key, you will have a backup that works when ready without waiting for a replacement or paying rush fees. If you have a second driver in your household, give them a spare so either of you can get the car if the other loses their key.
Some newer cars come with two fobs from the factory. Check your owner's manual or the paperwork from when you bought the car. If you only received one fob, making a second one now is much cheaper than replacing both later.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I program a key fob myself?
Some car models allow you to program a fob yourself using a sequence of button presses or turning the key in the ignition. Check your owner's manual or search online for your specific year, make, and model. If your car supports this, you can buy a blank fob online for $20 to $50 and program it at home. However, many newer vehicles do not allow this and require a dealership or locksmith.
What if my key fob works but the physical key is broken?
If the fob buttons work but the metal key part is cracked or bent, you can still use the fob to unlock and start the car. Have a new metal key cut at a hardware store for $5 to $15 as a backup. You do not need to reprogram anything — the fob will continue to work as it did before.
How much does it cost to replace a key if I have insurance?
Most car insurance policies do not cover lost or broken keys. Check your policy documents or call your insurance company to confirm. Some roadside information programs like AAA offer lockout and key replacement services for members. If you have roadside information through your insurance or a membership program, they may cover part of the cost.
Can a locksmith open my car if I am locked out?
Yes, a locksmith can unlock your car without damaging it. This is different from making a new key — unlocking lets you get inside so you can retrieve your spare key or call for a replacement. Lockout service typically costs $50 to $150 depending on how difficult the lock is and whether it is after hours.
What should I do if my key is stuck in the ignition?
Do not force it. A stuck key usually means the steering wheel lock is engaged or the transmission is not in Park. Try turning the steering wheel left and right while gently turning the key. If that does not work, call a locksmith or dealership. Forcing a stuck key can break it inside the lock, making the problem more expensive to fix.