What you get in a Consumer Reports auto issue
Consumer Reports publishes a dedicated auto issue each year, usually in April, that contains vehicle ratings, reliability data, and buying guidance for new and used cars. The issue ranks vehicles by category, shows which models have the fewest reported problems, and explains what to look for when shopping. It also includes road-test results, safety ratings from federal agencies, and cost-of-ownership breakdowns.
The auto issue is one of the most detailed resources Consumer Reports produces. It covers sedans, SUVs, trucks, hybrids, and electric vehicles, with separate sections for safety features, fuel economy, and long-term reliability based on surveys of actual owners. You can buy a single print issue or access the full database through a Consumer Reports subscription.
Key Takeaways
- Consumer Reports' annual auto issue ranks vehicles by reliability, safety, and road-test performance, with data drawn from owner surveys and federal crash tests.
- The issue breaks down predicted ownership costs, including insurance, fuel, maintenance, and repairs, so you can compare total expense across models.
- Reliability ratings are based on surveys of Consumer Reports members who own the vehicles, not manufacturer claims or limited test fleets.
- You can access the auto issue in print, on the Consumer Reports website with a subscription, or through some public libraries at no cost.
- The ratings change year to year as new model years arrive and older vehicles accumulate more owner-reported problems.
How reliability ratings are built
Consumer Reports gathers reliability data from surveys sent to its members who own the vehicles being rated. Members report problems they've had with their cars over the past year, broken down by system: engine, transmission, electrical, brakes, suspension, and so on. Consumer Reports then calculates how often each problem shows up across all owners of that model and model year.
This approach differs from manufacturer testing because it reflects real-world use over years of ownership, not controlled lab conditions. A vehicle that performs well in a short test drive may have transmission issues that don't surface until 40,000 miles. Consumer Reports' member surveys catch those patterns. The more owners surveyed for a given model, the more reliable the rating tends to be.
Ratings are updated annually as new model years arrive and older vehicles accumulate more miles. A 2022 Honda Civic might have a different reliability score in the 2024 auto issue than it did in 2023, because owners have reported additional problems or the opposite.
Safety ratings and crash test results
The auto issue includes safety ratings from two federal sources: the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) and the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (IIHS). NHTSA runs crash tests in five categories—front crash, side crash, rollover, and two others—and assigns each a star rating from one to five. IIHS conducts its own crash tests and also rates how well vehicles prevent crashes through features like automatic emergency braking.
Consumer Reports also reports on safety features available in each vehicle, such as blind-spot warning, lane-keeping information, and adaptive cruise control. The issue notes which features come standard and which are optional, so you can see what you'll actually get at different trim levels and price points.
Federal ratings can vary between NHTSA and IIHS because they use different test methods and weight the results differently. Consumer Reports presents both so you can see the full picture. A vehicle that scores well on one test may score differently on another.
Cost-of-ownership estimates
Consumer Reports breaks down the total cost of owning each vehicle over five years, including purchase price, fuel, insurance, maintenance, repairs, and depreciation. This section helps you compare not just the sticker price but the real expense of keeping the car running.
Insurance costs vary by vehicle, age, and your location, so Consumer Reports uses national averages. Maintenance and repair costs are based on historical data from repair shops and manufacturer service bulletins. Depreciation is calculated from actual used-car prices tracked over time. Fuel costs depend on EPA fuel-economy ratings and current gas prices at the time the issue is published.
These estimates are useful for comparing two vehicles you're considering, but your actual costs will differ based on where you live, how you drive, and which repair shop you use. The estimates give you a framework for thinking about total cost, not a may provide of what you'll spend.
How to find and read the auto issue
The annual auto issue is published in April and sold at newsstands and online. You can also access it through a Consumer Reports digital subscription, which includes the current auto issue plus archives of past years. Some public libraries offer free access to Consumer Reports through their website, so check your library's database before paying for a subscription.
The issue is organized by vehicle category: compact cars, midsize sedans, SUVs by size, trucks, and so on. Within each category, vehicles are ranked by overall score, which combines reliability, safety, and road-test performance. You can also sort by price, fuel economy, or specific features using the online version.
The print issue includes a buying guide that walks you through what to look for in each category and highlights standout models. The online version lets you compare up to five vehicles side by side, showing reliability, safety, cost estimates, and features in a table format.
What the auto issue does not cover
Consumer Reports does not rate every vehicle on the market. Vehicles with very low sales numbers or those that are brand new may not have enough owner data for a reliability rating. Luxury brands and some imports may have smaller sample sizes, which can make ratings less stable year to year.
The issue also does not include real-time pricing or inventory information. The prices listed are manufacturer suggested retail prices (MSRP) at the time of publication, not what dealers are actually charging. For current prices and local inventory, you'll need to check dealer websites or automotive marketplaces.
Consumer Reports does not rate used vehicles individually by year and mileage. Instead, it provides reliability trends for each model across multiple years, so you can see whether a 2018 Honda Civic is likely to be more or less reliable than a 2019 model based on owner reports.
Using the auto issue alongside other resources
The auto issue is strongest for reliability and safety information, but you'll want other resources for a complete picture. Kelley Blue Book and Edmunds provide detailed pricing, incentives, and market trends. Manufacturer websites show current features and trim levels. Local dealer inventory sites show what's actually available near you.
If you're shopping for a used vehicle, the auto issue's reliability ratings tell you which models hold up well over time, but you'll also need a pre-purchase inspection from a trusted mechanic and a vehicle history report from Carfax or AutoCheck. A vehicle with a good reliability rating can still have been in an accident or poorly maintained.
For specific questions about a vehicle's features, warranty, or recalls, contact the manufacturer directly or check the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration's recall database. Consumer Reports focuses on broad patterns across many owners, not individual vehicle histories.
Frequently Asked Questions
How often does Consumer Reports update its auto ratings?
The main auto issue is published once a year in April. However, Consumer Reports updates its online ratings throughout the year as new model years arrive and as it receives additional owner survey responses. Reliability ratings can shift between the print issue and the online version.
Can I trust Consumer Reports' reliability ratings if my friends had different experiences?
Consumer Reports' ratings are based on hundreds or thousands of owner reports, so they show broad patterns, not individual experiences. Your friend's bad luck with one car doesn't mean the model is unreliable overall—and vice versa. The ratings are most useful for comparing two models you're considering, not for predicting what will happen to your specific car.
Does Consumer Reports rate vehicles that are only sold in certain states?
Consumer Reports rates vehicles sold nationwide. Electric vehicles and other models sold in limited markets may have smaller sample sizes, which can make ratings less stable. If you're looking at a vehicle with a small owner base, the rating may change more from year to year as more data comes in.
What if a vehicle I want isn't in the auto issue?
If a vehicle is too new or has too few owners surveyed, Consumer Reports may not have a reliability rating yet. You can still use the issue's safety ratings and cost estimates if they're available. For reliability information, check the manufacturer's warranty coverage and look for owner forums where people discuss common problems with that model.
Is the auto issue worth buying if I already have access to reviews online?
The auto issue's main strength is the reliability data and cost-of-ownership breakdowns, which are harder to find in free online reviews. If you're comparing multiple vehicles or trying to decide between new and used, the issue's side-by-side tables and five-year cost estimates save time. Many public libraries offer free access, so check there first.