German manufacturers are pushing back against the EU's 2035 ban on new petrol and diesel sales
The European Union set a hard important date: no new cars with internal combustion engines (ICE) can be sold from 2035 onward. But Germany's largest automakers—BMW, Mercedes-Benz, Audi, and Porsche—are publicly arguing for an exception that would let them keep selling petrol and diesel vehicles beyond that date. They're not asking to ignore the rule entirely. Instead, they want to use e-fuels (synthetic fuels made from renewable electricity) as a loophole that would let ICE engines stay legal after 2035.
This matters to you because it affects what cars will actually be available to buy, how long repair parts will remain common, and whether your next vehicle will run on electricity, petrol, or something in between. Understanding what these manufacturers are proposing—and why—helps you make sense of the conflicting messages you're hearing about the future of cars.
Key Takeaways
- German automakers want the EU to allow e-fuels (synthetic petrol made from renewable electricity) to keep ICE engines legal after 2035, rather than banning the engines themselves.
- E-fuels can theoretically run in existing petrol engines with little or no modification, which is why manufacturers see them as a path to extend ICE production.
- The EU's current 2035 rule bans the sale of new cars with combustion engines, not the fuels themselves, so the legal fight is really about whether e-fuels count as "zero-emission" under EU law.
- Even if e-fuels become legal, they are expensive to produce and will likely remain more costly than battery electric vehicles for the foreseeable future.
- This debate does not change the practical reality that battery electric vehicles are becoming cheaper and more common, and petrol engine production is already declining across Europe.
What e-fuels are and why manufacturers prefer them to full electrification
An e-fuel (also called a synthetic fuel or eFuel) is petrol or diesel made in a factory using renewable electricity, water, and carbon dioxide pulled from the air or industrial sources. The process uses electrolysis to split water into hydrogen, then combines that hydrogen with captured CO₂ to create a hydrocarbon that burns in a normal petrol engine. In theory, when you burn e-fuel, you release only the carbon that was captured to make it—making the cycle carbon-neutral.
Manufacturers like this approach because it means they can keep building engines and powertrains that are already proven, familiar to repair shops, and cheaper to produce than electric motors and battery packs. A car running on e-fuel uses the same basic engine block, transmission, and fuel system as a petrol car today. That's very different from building a battery electric vehicle, which requires entirely new manufacturing lines, supply chains for batteries, and dealer training.
From a business standpoint, e-fuels let automakers delay the massive capital investment that full electrification demands. They also appeal to owners in countries with limited charging infrastructure or those who drive long distances regularly, since an e-fuel car would have the same range and refueling speed as today's petrol cars.
The legal argument: whether e-fuels count as "zero-emission"
The EU's 2035 rule technically bans the sale of new cars that emit CO₂ from their tailpipe during driving. It does not explicitly ban petrol or diesel as fuels. German automakers argue that if you burn an e-fuel made from captured carbon, the tailpipe emissions are offset by the carbon that was removed to make the fuel—so the net emissions are zero, and the car should be legal.
The EU has not yet formally agreed to this interpretation. The bloc's current position is that the 2035 rule is meant to phase out combustion engines entirely, not to create an exception for synthetic fuels. However, Germany has significant political weight in Brussels, and the debate is ongoing. Some EU officials have suggested that e-fuels might be allowed for certain uses (like racing or aviation) but not for mass-market cars.
The practical problem is that e-fuel production is still experimental and expensive. A litre of e-fuel currently costs roughly three to five times more than petrol, and scaling production to supply millions of cars would take years and billions in investment. Even if the EU allows e-fuels after 2035, they would likely remain a premium option for wealthy buyers rather than a mass-market solution.
Why battery electric vehicles are still becoming the dominant choice
Regardless of what the EU decides about e-fuels, the economics of battery electric vehicles are moving faster than the politics. Battery costs have fallen by roughly 90 percent over the past fifteen years, and that trend is continuing. At the same time, charging networks across Europe are expanding, and most new car buyers in Germany, France, and Scandinavia are already choosing electric vehicles when they can afford them.
Automakers know this. Even as BMW and Mercedes argue for e-fuel exceptions, they are investing heavily in electric vehicle production. Audi has committed to phasing out petrol engines entirely by 2033—two years before the EU important date. Porsche is launching all-electric versions of its most popular models. These companies are not betting their future on e-fuels; they are hedging their bets by building both.
For you as an owner, this means the real shift is already happening. Petrol engine production is declining, repair shops are training on electric powertrains, and the used car market is filling with affordable electric vehicles. The 2035 rule and the e-fuel debate are important for policy, but they are not the main driver of change—cost and consumer preference are.
What this means for your current car and future purchases
If you own a petrol or diesel car today, this debate does not affect you. Petrol and diesel will remain legal to own, drive, and repair for decades. Repair parts will stay available because millions of combustion-engine cars will still be on the road. Fuel will remain available at petrol stations, and mechanics trained to service these engines will continue to work.
If you are thinking about buying a new car in the next five to ten years, you will have a choice between petrol, hybrid, and electric options—and that choice will depend on your budget, driving patterns, and local charging infrastructure. Petrol cars will likely become more expensive relative to electric vehicles as battery costs continue to fall and manufacturers shift production capacity. A hybrid (combining a petrol engine with an electric motor) remains a practical middle ground if you drive long distances or live somewhere with limited charging.
If you are buying a car after 2035, the options available will depend on what the EU ultimately decides about e-fuels and how quickly manufacturers can scale electric production. But by that point, electric vehicles will almost certainly be cheaper to buy and operate than petrol cars, and charging infrastructure will be far more common than it is today.
The difference between what automakers want and what will actually happen
German automakers are making a reasonable business argument: e-fuels could extend the life of combustion engine technology and reduce the disruption to their existing factories and supply chains. But arguments and reality are not the same thing. Even if the EU allows e-fuels after 2035, the cost of producing them at scale will likely keep them out of reach for most buyers. A car that costs 50 percent more to fuel than an electric vehicle will not compete in a mass market, no matter what the law says.
The automakers themselves understand this. They are not waiting for the EU to decide about e-fuels before investing in electric vehicles. They are building both because they know which one will actually dominate the market. The public argument about e-fuels is partly about buying time and partly about keeping options open, but it is not a bet that e-fuels will replace battery electric vehicles as the primary technology.
For you, this means you can ignore most of the noise about e-fuels and focus on what actually matters: the cost of ownership, the availability of charging or fuel, and how long you plan to keep the car. Those factors will determine what kind of vehicle makes sense for your situation far more than any EU rule or automaker lobbying campaign.
Frequently Asked Questions
Will my petrol car become illegal to drive after 2035?
No. The 2035 rule bans the sale of new cars with combustion engines; it does not ban owning or driving existing petrol and diesel cars. You will be able to keep your car, buy petrol, and find repair shops for decades after 2035. Millions of combustion-engine vehicles will still be on the road.
Can I buy a petrol car after 2035 if I want one?
Not a new one, unless the EU changes the rule or allows e-fuels. You will be able to buy used petrol cars on the secondhand market for many years. If you want a new car after 2035, your options will be electric, hybrid, or (if e-fuels are approved) vehicles running on synthetic fuel.
Are e-fuels actually better for the environment than battery electric vehicles?
E-fuels are carbon-neutral only if the electricity used to make them comes from renewable sources like wind or solar. If they are made using grid electricity from coal or gas plants, they are not zero-emission. Battery electric vehicles are cleaner in most of Europe today because the grid is increasingly powered by renewables. E-fuels may play a role in aviation or shipping, where batteries are impractical, but they are unlikely to be the primary solution for cars.
If e-fuels become legal, will they be cheaper than petrol?
Not for many years, if ever. E-fuel production is expensive and energy-intensive. Current estimates suggest e-fuels will cost two to five times more than petrol at the pump, even at scale. This makes them impractical for most drivers compared to battery electric vehicles, which are becoming cheaper to operate as electricity costs remain stable.
Should I wait to buy an electric car until e-fuels are sorted out?
No. Battery electric vehicles are already cheaper to own and operate than petrol cars in most of Europe, and that gap is widening. Waiting for e-fuels to become viable would mean paying more to fuel a petrol car for years while missing out on the savings and performance of electric vehicles available today.