Harley-Davidson's sales have fallen for three straight years, driven by an aging customer base, competition from cheaper brands, and a shift away from motorcycle ownership among younger riders
Harley-Davidson reported a 5.2% decline in motorcycle sales in 2023 compared to 2022, continuing a downward trend that started in 2021. The company's U.S. market share has contracted as the overall motorcycle market itself has shrunk. This matters to you if you're shopping for a used Harley, considering selling one, or trying to understand whether motorcycle ownership makes financial sense right now. A shrinking market typically means lower resale values, but it also means dealers may be more willing to negotiate on price.
The decline is not temporary or cyclical — it reflects structural changes in who buys motorcycles and why. Understanding these shifts helps you make a better decision about timing a purchase or sale, and it explains why dealers are offering incentives that weren't available five years ago.
Key Takeaways
- Harley-Davidson's core customer is now in their 50s and 60s, while motorcycle sales to riders under 35 have fallen sharply, shrinking the pool of future buyers.
- Used Harley prices have softened in the last two years as inventory builds and demand weakens, making it a better time to buy but a worse time to sell.
- Competition from Indian Motorcycle, Triumph, and Japanese brands offering similar styling at lower prices has pulled market share away from Harley.
- Dealer incentives and extended financing terms have become standard as manufacturers try to move inventory, which benefits buyers but signals weakness in demand.
- If you own a Harley, holding it longer may preserve more value than selling into a soft market, unless you need the cash now.
The aging Harley customer and the missing younger riders
Harley-Davidson's average customer age has climbed to approximately 50 years old, up from the mid-40s a decade ago. This is a problem because it means the company is not replacing retiring riders with new ones. Motorcycle sales to riders under 35 have declined by roughly 40% over the past decade across all brands, but Harley's decline in that age group has been steeper than the industry average.
Younger riders cite cost, insurance, and safety concerns as reasons they choose not to buy motorcycles at all. A new Harley-Davidson Street 750, the brand's entry-level model, starts around $7,500, but insurance, gear, and training add another $2,000 to $3,000 in the first year. For someone in their 20s or early 30s, that competes directly with a used car payment, which offers weather protection and cargo space. Harley has tried to address this with smaller, cheaper models, but these bikes carry lower profit margins and have not reversed the trend.
How competition from other brands is reshaping the market
Indian Motorcycle, owned by Polaris, has gained market share by offering cruiser-style bikes that look similar to Harley models but cost $1,500 to $3,000 less. Indian's Scout Bobber starts around $8,000 new, compared to Harley's Street 750 at $7,500 — but Indian's bike has more power and better resale value in some markets. Triumph, a British brand, has also captured buyers with retro-styled bikes priced between Harley and Japanese brands, offering a middle ground on price and a different brand identity.
Japanese manufacturers like Yamaha and Kawasaki have not traditionally competed in the cruiser segment, but they have held onto customers who might have bought Harley in the past. These riders often choose used Japanese bikes because parts are cheaper, insurance is lower, and the bikes require less maintenance. This shift has been gradual but consistent — Harley's share of the U.S. motorcycle market has fallen from roughly 50% in 2010 to around 35% today.
What declining sales mean for used Harley prices
When a manufacturer's sales fall, used inventory typically builds because trade-ins accumulate and fewer new bikes are sold to replace them. This creates downward pressure on used prices. A 2019 Harley-Davidson Street Glide that sold for $18,000 to $19,000 used in 2021 now typically sells for $16,000 to $17,000, depending on mileage and condition. The decline is not dramatic, but it is measurable.
The softening is most visible in the mid-range used market — bikes five to ten years old. Newer used Harleys (one to three years old) have held value better because they still carry warranty coverage and appeal to buyers who want a "new" bike without the full new-bike price. Older Harleys (15+ years) have also held relatively steady because they appeal to collectors and customizers who are less price-sensitive. The squeeze is in the middle, where most buyers shop.
Dealer incentives and financing offers are now standard
Harley-Davidson and its dealers are offering incentives that were rare before 2022. These include extended warranties, reduced-rate financing (sometimes 0% for 36 months on new bikes), and trade-in bonuses. Some dealers are also bundling gear, training, or service packages to sweeten deals. These offers signal that demand is weak enough that manufacturers need to move inventory.
For a buyer, this is good news — you have leverage to negotiate. For a seller, it means you're competing against dealer incentives, so a private sale may take longer or require a lower price. If you're trading in a used Harley to a dealer, the incentives may offset some of the price softening, but you should still shop the trade-in value at multiple dealers before accepting an offer.
Whether to buy or sell a used Harley right now
If you're thinking about buying a used Harley, the current market favors you. Prices are softer, dealer incentives are available, and you can negotiate from a position of strength. The risk is that prices may continue to decline if the sales trend does not reverse, but the decline is likely to be gradual rather than sudden. A 2020 Harley purchased today at $15,000 might be worth $13,500 in two years, but that's a slower depreciation than it would have experienced in a hot market.
If you own a Harley and are considering selling, the math is less favorable. You will face a softer market and more competition from dealers offering incentives. Unless you need the cash when ready, holding the bike longer may preserve more value — or at least delay the loss. If you do sell, a private sale will likely net you more than a trade-in, but it will take longer to find a buyer. Pricing it 5% to 10% below market comparables will move it faster in a soft market.
The long-term outlook for Harley and the used market
Harley-Davidson has announced plans to launch electric motorcycles and expand its smaller-bike lineup, both aimed at attracting younger riders. The LiveWire electric model starts around $15,000, which is expensive for an entry-level bike but may appeal to environmentally conscious buyers. Whether these moves will reverse the sales decline is uncertain — the company is fighting against a broader cultural shift away from motorcycle ownership, not just brand preference.
For the used market, this means prices are likely to remain soft for the next 18 to 24 months. If Harley's new products gain traction and sales stabilize, used prices may stabilize too. If the decline continues, used Harley values will continue to drift downward, but probably not dramatically. The brand still has strong brand loyalty and a large installed base of existing owners, which provides a floor under prices.
Frequently Asked Questions
Should I buy a used Harley now or wait for prices to drop further?
Prices are unlikely to drop much more in the next year, and waiting carries the risk that the specific bike you want sells to someone else. The current market is favorable to buyers, so if you find a bike in good condition at a fair price, buying now is reasonable. Waiting for a 10% to 15% drop is unlikely to pay off.
Will my used Harley be worth anything in five years?
Yes, but probably less than it would have been in a stronger market. A well-maintained Harley typically retains 50% to 60% of its purchase price over five years in a normal market. In the current soft market, expect closer to 45% to 55%. The exact number depends on mileage, condition, and model — cruisers hold value better than touring bikes.
Is it better to trade in a used Harley or sell it privately?
A private sale will net you 10% to 15% more than a dealer trade-in, but it takes longer and requires you to handle paperwork and liability. In a soft market, the time cost of a private sale may not be worth the extra money. Get trade-in offers from at least two dealers before deciding.
Are used Harley prices lower because the bikes are less reliable?
No. Harley reliability has not changed. Prices are lower because demand is lower and inventory is higher — a market condition, not a quality issue. Used Harleys are still well-built bikes with strong resale communities and parts availability.
What's the best time to sell a used Harley?
Spring and early summer (April through June) are the strongest selling seasons for motorcycles. Selling during this window will bring more buyers and potentially higher prices than selling in fall or winter. If you need to sell outside this window, expect to price more aggressively or wait longer.