How These Two Vehicles Differ in Size, Price, and Purpose
The Honda Passport and Toyota Highlander are both three-row vehicles, but they serve different buyers. The Passport is a body-on-frame SUV built for off-road capability and towing, starting around $48,000 to $50,000 depending on trim and year. The Highlander is a unibody crossover designed for family hauling and fuel economy, with starting prices around $38,000 to $40,000. The Passport sits higher, has a shorter wheelbase, and handles rough terrain better. The Highlander seats up to eight people (with a third-row bench), carries more cargo in everyday use, and costs less to own over time.
Your choice depends on what you actually do with the vehicle. If you tow a boat or trailer regularly, drive unpaved roads, or want a vehicle that feels like a truck, the Passport makes sense despite the higher price. If you need maximum interior space, better fuel economy, and lower maintenance costs for suburban driving, the Highlander is the stronger choice.
Key Takeaways
- The Passport costs $8,000 to $12,000 more upfront but offers truck-based construction, better towing capacity (5,000 pounds versus 3,500), and genuine off-road geometry.
- The Highlander seats eight with a bench third row, while the Passport seats seven with captain's chairs, making the Highlander better for large families.
- Highlander owners report lower fuel costs and maintenance expenses over five years, while Passport owners pay more for premium fuel and repairs but keep higher resale value.
- The Passport's body-on-frame design makes it better for towing and rough terrain; the Highlander's unibody design makes it quieter, more stable on highways, and easier to park.
- Test driving both matters because the Passport feels like a truck and the Highlander feels like a car—your comfort in each one varies by driving style.
Interior Space and Seating Configuration
The Highlander offers more usable space for families. Its three rows can seat eight people if you choose the bench seat for the middle row, or seven with captain's chairs. The third row is genuinely accessible—adults can sit there for short trips without folding the second row completely flat. Cargo space behind the third row measures 16.1 cubic feet; with the third row folded, you get 48.4 cubic feet; with both rear rows folded, 84.7 cubic feet.
The Passport seats seven with captain's chairs in the second row as standard. The third row is tighter and better suited for children or short trips. Cargo space is 16.5 cubic feet behind the third row, 46.9 cubic feet with the third row folded, and 76.5 cubic feet with both rows down. The Passport's shorter overall length (about 190 inches versus the Highlander's 194 inches) makes it easier to park and maneuver, but that same compactness means less interior volume overall.
If you regularly transport eight people or need maximum cargo room for road trips, the Highlander's extra space becomes noticeable. If you have a smaller family or prioritize maneuverability in tight parking situations, the Passport's dimensions work in your favor.
Towing Capacity and Off-Road Capability
The Passport's body-on-frame construction gives it a towing capacity of 5,000 pounds with the proper hitch setup. It also has a standard all-wheel-drive system with multiple terrain modes—Snow, Mud, and Sand—that adjust throttle response and traction control for unpaved surfaces. The frame-based design means the Passport can handle washboard roads, rocky terrain, and water crossings better than a crossover.
The Highlander's unibody design limits its towing to 3,500 pounds, and it lacks terrain-specific drive modes. It is built for paved roads and light off-road use like forest service roads. The all-wheel-drive system is competent on snow and gravel but not engineered for serious off-road work.
If you tow a boat, trailer, or camper regularly, or if you drive to remote cabins or trailheads on unpaved roads, the Passport is the practical choice. If your off-roading is occasional and your towing needs are light, the Highlander handles both adequately and costs less to operate.
Fuel Economy and Operating Costs
The Highlander achieves better fuel economy across the board. A 2024 Highlander with all-wheel drive gets approximately 23 miles per gallon in the city and 29 on the highway. The Passport, with its heavier frame and truck-based design, averages around 21 city and 26 highway. Over 100,000 miles, that difference adds up—roughly $3,000 to $4,000 in extra fuel costs for the Passport, depending on gas prices and your driving mix.
Maintenance costs also favor the Highlander. Passport owners report higher costs for brake service (due to heavier weight), suspension repairs, and tire replacement. The Passport also requires premium fuel in most model years, while the Highlander runs on regular unleaded. Insurance premiums are similar, but the Highlander's lower repair costs mean lower comprehensive and collision deductible payouts over time.
If you drive mostly highway miles and keep the vehicle for 150,000 miles or more, the Highlander's lower operating costs can offset its lower purchase price by $5,000 to $8,000 over the vehicle's life. The Passport's higher resale value—typically 5 to 10 percent better—partially offsets this gap but does not eliminate it.
Driving Feel and Comfort on Different Road Types
The Passport drives like a truck. The steering is heavier, the suspension is stiffer, and you sit higher with a more commanding view of the road. On highways, this means more road noise and a bouncier ride over bumps. On rough terrain, the same stiffness and height work in your favor—the vehicle feels planted and capable. The body-on-frame design also means more flex in the chassis, which helps absorb impacts on uneven ground.
The Highlander drives like a car. The steering is lighter and more responsive, the suspension is tuned for comfort, and wind and road noise are lower. On highways, the ride is smooth and stable. On rough terrain, the unibody construction transmits more vibration to the cabin, and the lower ground clearance limits what you can safely traverse. The Highlander excels at highway cruising and suburban driving but feels less capable on dirt roads.
Your preference here is personal. Some drivers love the truck-like feel and capability of the Passport; others find it tiring on long highway drives. Test driving both on the roads you actually use—highway, city streets, and any gravel or unpaved surfaces—will tell you which one suits your comfort level.
Reliability and Long-Term Ownership
Both vehicles have solid reliability records. The Highlander has a slight edge in reported owner satisfaction and lower rates of major repairs in the first five years. Honda Passports are reliable but have had occasional issues with transmission hesitation and suspension noise in some model years. Neither vehicle is known for catastrophic failures, and both typically reach 200,000 miles with regular maintenance.
Parts availability and repair costs matter over time. Highlander parts are more widely stocked because the vehicle sells in higher volumes. Passport repairs, especially suspension and drivetrain work, can take longer to source and may cost more at independent shops. Dealer service for both brands is comparable in price, but Highlander dealers are more numerous in most areas.
Resale value favors the Passport slightly. A five-year-old Passport typically retains 55 to 60 percent of its original price, while a Highlander retains 50 to 55 percent. This gap narrows after seven years. If you plan to keep the vehicle for ten years or longer, the resale difference becomes negligible.
Which Vehicle Matches Your Actual Needs
Choose the Passport if you tow regularly, drive unpaved roads, want a vehicle that feels like a truck, or plan to keep the vehicle for 150,000 miles or more and value resale value. The higher upfront cost and operating expenses are worth it if you use the vehicle's capabilities.
Choose the Highlander if you prioritize interior space for a large family, want lower fuel and maintenance costs, spend most time on paved roads, or plan to sell or trade in within five to seven years. The Highlander is the more practical choice for suburban and urban driving.
If you are torn between the two, rent each one for a weekend and drive them on the roads you use most. The difference in how they feel and perform will become clear quickly.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can the Highlander tow a small boat or trailer?
Yes, the Highlander can tow up to 3,500 pounds, which covers small fishing boats, utility trailers, and lightweight campers. If you tow regularly or need to pull heavier loads, the Passport's 5,000-pound capacity is safer and more practical.
Is the Passport's third row usable for adults on long trips?
The Passport's third row is tight for adults. It works for children or short drives, but adults will find it cramped on trips longer than an hour. The Highlander's third row is more spacious and better for longer journeys.
Which vehicle holds its value better?
The Passport typically retains 5 to 10 percent more of its purchase price after five years, but the difference shrinks after seven years. If you plan to keep the vehicle longer than seven years, resale value is roughly equal.
Does the Passport really need premium fuel?
Most Passport model years require premium fuel for optimal performance and fuel economy. Using regular fuel can reduce power and efficiency. The Highlander runs on regular unleaded, saving money at every fill-up.
Which one is easier to park in a parking garage?
The Passport is shorter and narrower, making it easier to fit in tight parking spaces and garages. The Highlander is slightly longer and wider, though both fit in standard parking spaces. If you park in older garages with low clearance, the Highlander's lower height is an advantage.