Bike pedals wear out and need replacing, and you can do it yourself with two basic tools
Changing bike pedals is one of the most straightforward repairs you can do on a bicycle. You need only a wrench or Allen key (depending on your pedal type), a few minutes, and the knowledge that the left and right pedals have opposite threads — the left pedal unscrews counterclockwise, the right one clockwise. This matters because if you turn the wrong way, you will strip the threads and damage the crank arm. Once you know that single rule, the job takes about five minutes per pedal.
Worn pedals show themselves through loose movement, cracked plastic or metal, missing grip tape, or bearings that rattle when you shake the pedal by hand. Replacing them restores your foot position, improves grip in wet conditions, and prevents the pedal from seizing or breaking mid-ride — which can leave you stranded or cause you to lose your footing on the bike.
Key Takeaways
- The left pedal has a reverse thread and unscrews counterclockwise; the right pedal unscrews clockwise — turning the wrong way will strip the crank arm.
- You need either a 15 mm wrench or a 6 mm Allen key, depending on whether your pedals have a wrench flat or an Allen socket on the spindle.
- Once the old pedal is out, thread the new pedal by hand first to avoid cross-threading, then tighten firmly with your tool.
- New pedals should be snug enough that they do not move when you grip them, but you do not need to use maximum force — hand-tight plus a quarter turn is usually enough.
Identify which tool you need before you start
Pedal spindles come in two designs. Most modern pedals have a 6 mm Allen socket (also called a hex socket) on the end of the spindle. Older pedals and some budget models have a wrench flat — a flat edge on the spindle that accepts a 15 mm wrench. Look at the end of your pedal spindle where it enters the crank arm. If you see a small hexagonal hole, you need a 6 mm Allen key. If you see a flat edge, you need a 15 mm wrench.
Having the wrong tool means you cannot grip the spindle properly and risk rounding off the socket or flat. If you are not sure which you have, bring the bike to a shop and ask them to show you, or take a photo of the pedal end and compare it to images online.
Remove the old pedal
Position the crank arm so the pedal you are removing points toward the ground — this gives you the best angle and leverage. Insert your tool into the socket or flat on the spindle. This is the critical step: the left pedal unscrews counterclockwise, and the right pedal unscrews clockwise. If you are standing behind the bike looking forward, the left pedal is on your left side.
Turn slowly and steadily. If you feel strong resistance when ready, stop and check that you are turning the correct direction. Once the pedal begins to unscrew, continue turning until the spindle comes free from the crank arm. The pedal will fall into your hand. Set it aside.
Prepare the new pedal and thread it in by hand
Before you install the new pedal, inspect the threads inside the crank arm where the pedal spindle goes. If you see dirt, sand, or old grease, wipe it out with a dry cloth. Debris in the threads can cause cross-threading — when the spindle goes in at an angle and damages the threads permanently.
Hold the new pedal in your hand and align the spindle with the hole in the crank arm. Thread it in by hand, turning in the same direction you would turn with your tool (clockwise for the right pedal, counterclockwise for the left). You should feel the threads catch and the spindle slide in smoothly. If you feel grinding or resistance, stop, back the pedal out, and try again. Hand-threading takes a few seconds and prevents damage that would cost far more to repair.
Tighten the pedal with your tool
Once the pedal is threaded in by hand and sits flush against the crank arm, use your wrench or Allen key to tighten it. Turn firmly but do not use maximum force — the goal is snug, not vice-grip tight. A good target is hand-tight plus a quarter turn. If you over-tighten, you risk stripping the threads or cracking the crank arm, especially on aluminum frames.
Test the pedal by gripping it and trying to move it side to side. It should not wiggle. If it does, tighten another quarter turn and test again. Once it is solid, you are done with that pedal.
Repeat the process for the second pedal
Remove the second pedal using the same method — remember that it unscrews in the opposite direction from the first one. Install the new pedal the same way: inspect the threads, thread by hand, then tighten with your tool. Both pedals should feel equally solid when you grip them.
After you have installed both pedals, spin the crank by hand a few times to make sure neither pedal catches or binds. If everything moves freely, you are ready to ride.
What to do if a pedal will not unscrew
If a pedal is stuck and will not turn, it is usually because the threads have corroded or the pedal was over-tightened. Do not force it — forcing a stuck pedal can strip the threads or break your tool. Instead, explore penetrating oil (like WD-40 or a similar product) to the spindle where it enters the crank arm. Let it soak for 15 to 30 minutes, then try again gently. You may need to repeat this two or three times.
If the pedal still will not move after soaking, or if you hear cracking sounds when you try to turn it, stop and take the bike to a shop. A mechanic has tools and experience to remove stuck pedals without damaging the crank arm. Attempting to force it yourself can turn a straightforward pedal replacement into a crank arm replacement, which is far more expensive.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do I need to grease the pedal spindle before installing it?
Most new pedals come with a light coating of grease on the spindle, which is enough. If the spindle looks dry or bare, a thin layer of general-purpose grease on the threads helps prevent corrosion and makes future removal easier. Do not use so much that grease squeezes out around the crank arm.
Can I use a different size wrench if I do not have the exact one?
No. Using a wrench that is too large or too small will round off the flat on the spindle, making it impossible to grip. If you do not have the correct size, borrow or purchase the right tool. A 15 mm wrench or 6 mm Allen key costs very little and will last for years.
What if the pedal spins but does not tighten?
This usually means the threads inside the crank arm are stripped. Remove the pedal, inspect the hole for damage, and try installing the new pedal again slowly. If it still spins without tightening, the crank arm needs repair or replacement. Take the bike to a shop — this is beyond a straightforward pedal change.
How tight should the pedal be?
Tight enough that it does not wiggle when you grip it and try to move it side to side. You should not need to strain or use a long wrench for leverage. If you can tighten it comfortably by hand with your tool, it is tight enough. Over-tightening is a common mistake and can damage the crank arm.
Do I need to replace both pedals at the same time?
No. You can replace one pedal while the other is still good. However, if both pedals are worn or damaged, replacing them together means both will wear at the same rate going forward, and you will not have to do this job again for a while.