What a valve cover gasket does and why it fails

A valve cover gasket is a rubber or cork seal that sits between your engine's valve cover and the cylinder head. It keeps oil inside the engine where it belongs. When the gasket fails — usually after 50,000 to 100,000 miles, though timing varies by engine and climate — oil leaks onto the outside of the engine, the spark plug wells, or the ground under your car.

You'll know it's failing when you see a thin film of oil on top of the engine, smell burning oil when the engine is hot, or spot drips on your driveway. A failed gasket doesn't damage the engine when ready, but oil loss can, so replacing it before the leak gets worse is worth doing.

The job itself is straightforward on most cars: remove bolts, lift off the cover, scrape out the old gasket, install a new one, and bolt it back down. On some engines — particularly those with tight engine bays or multiple valve covers — it takes longer and requires removing other parts first. Budget two to four hours for a first attempt, or one to two hours if you've done it before.

Key Takeaways

  • You need the correct replacement gasket for your specific engine, which you can find using your vehicle's year, make, model, and engine size at any auto parts store.
  • The job requires only basic hand tools: a socket set, screwdrivers, a gasket scraper, and a clean rag, plus a new gasket and a small amount of gasket maker or sealant.
  • The hardest part is usually scraping off the old gasket completely without gouging the metal surfaces underneath, which takes patience but no special skill.
  • If your engine bay is too cramped or the valve cover bolts are stuck, you may need to remove other components first — check a repair manual for your specific vehicle before starting.
  • After installation, check for leaks after the first drive and again after a few days of normal driving.

Gather the right parts and tools before you start

Go to an auto parts store with your vehicle's year, make, model, and engine size. Ask for a valve cover gasket kit for your car — most kits include the gasket itself, a tube of gasket maker or sealant, and sometimes new bolts. The cost is typically $15 to $40 for the gasket and sealant combined. Buying a kit is cheaper and simpler than buying each item separately.

You'll also need basic hand tools you likely already have: a socket set (usually 8mm to 15mm), a ratchet, screwdrivers (both Phillips and flathead), and a gasket scraper or plastic putty knife. Do not use a metal scraper on aluminum surfaces, as it will gouge them. A clean rag, a drain pan to catch any spilled oil, and a work light or headlamp are also useful. If the bolts are corroded or stuck, penetrating oil like PB Blaster or WD-40 applied the night before makes removal easier.

Remove the valve cover and old gasket

Let the engine cool completely — at least an hour after running. Locate the valve cover on top of your engine; most cars have one, some have two or more. Take a photo of the hose and wire routing before you disconnect anything, so you know where everything goes back.

Disconnect any hoses, wires, or brackets attached to the valve cover. These typically include a PCV hose, breather hose, or spark plug wires or coil packs. Set them aside in a safe place. Use your socket set to remove the bolts holding the valve cover down — they're usually arranged around the perimeter. Keep the bolts in order if they're different sizes; take a photo if you're unsure.

Gently pry the valve cover up with a screwdriver, working around the edges. It may stick due to old gasket material or sealant — be patient and work slowly to avoid cracking the cover. Once it's off, you'll see the old gasket material still stuck to the cover or the cylinder head.

Scrape off all the old gasket material using a plastic scraper or gasket scraper tool. Work slowly and scrape in one direction to avoid gouging the metal. Wipe the surface clean with a rag. The metal surface should be bare and smooth with no gasket residue remaining. If there's stubborn material, a small amount of gasket remover spray (available at auto parts stores) can help, but patience and elbow grease usually work fine.

Install the new gasket and reassemble

Check the new gasket against the old one to make sure it's the right shape and size. Place the new gasket into the groove on the valve cover, pressing it firmly so it sits evenly all the way around. Some gaskets come pre-glued; others require a thin bead of gasket maker applied to the cover first. Follow the instructions that came with your kit.

If your kit includes gasket maker, explore a thin, continuous bead around the cylinder head surface where the cover will sit — not a thick glob, just enough to create a seal. Place the valve cover back down carefully, aligning it so the gasket sits evenly. Start the bolts by hand first to make sure they're going in straight, then tighten them with your socket set in a crisscross pattern (like tightening a wheel), not in a circle. This ensures even pressure. Tighten firmly but not hard — you're aiming for snug, not stripped.

Reconnect the hoses, wires, and brackets in the order you removed them. Use your photo as a reference. Double-check that everything is seated properly and nothing is pinched or loose.

Test for leaks and monitor for the first week

Start the engine and let it idle for a few minutes. Look for any oil leaking from around the valve cover. If you see drips forming when ready, turn off the engine and check that the bolts are tight and the gasket is seated properly. Small weeping is normal for the first few minutes as the gasket settles; significant dripping is not.

Take a short test drive — five to ten minutes of normal driving — then park and let the engine cool. Check again for leaks. Repeat this over the next few days of normal driving. Most gaskets seal completely within the first week. If leaking continues after a week of driving, the gasket may not be seated correctly, or you may have missed a spot of old gasket material during scraping.

When to stop and take it to a shop

If the valve cover bolts are seized and won't budge even after soaking with penetrating oil, or if your engine bay is so cramped you can't access the bolts safely, a shop can do the job faster than you can fight it. The labor cost is typically $150 to $300 depending on the engine, which is reasonable if you value your time or don't have the right tools.

If you remove the cover and find that other components — like intake manifolds, alternators, or air filter boxes — are blocking access, stop and consult a repair manual for your vehicle. Some engines require removing those parts first, which adds complexity. A shop's experience with your specific engine makes this faster and safer.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I drive with a leaking valve cover gasket?

Yes, for a while. A slow leak won't damage the engine when ready, but oil loss can. Check your oil level weekly and top it off as needed. If the leak is fast enough that you're adding oil every few days, replace the gasket soon to avoid running low and damaging the engine.

Do I need to replace the bolts too?

Not usually. Reuse the old bolts unless they're stripped, corroded, or bent. Some gasket kits include new bolts; if yours does, use them. If not, the old ones are fine.

What if gasket maker gets on the spark plugs or inside the engine?

A small amount of gasket maker on the outside of spark plug wells is fine — it dries and won't hurt anything. If you accidentally get some inside the engine, wipe it out when ready with a clean rag before it dries. Don't let the engine run with wet gasket maker inside.

How long does the new gasket last?

Most valve cover gaskets last 50,000 to 100,000 miles. Some last longer, some shorter, depending on engine temperature, oil quality, and how hard the engine works. If you replace it once, you'll likely replace it again in five to ten years.

Should I replace both valve covers if my engine has two?

Only if both are leaking. If only one is leaking, replace only that one. If the other is dry, it can wait. Replacing both at once saves labor if you're paying a shop, but if you're doing it yourself, there's no advantage to doing both unless both are failing.