The U.S. auto industry is not in decline by the numbers that matter most — it is shifting what it builds and who buys it
Total vehicle sales in the United States have not collapsed. In 2023, Americans bought roughly 15.5 million new vehicles, down from the 17 million peak in 2015 but well above the 10.6 million sold during the 2009 financial crisis. What has changed is what kind of vehicles people are buying and where those vehicles are made. Pickup trucks and SUVs now account for about 80 percent of new vehicle sales, while sedans have nearly vanished from dealer lots. At the same time, foreign manufacturers — particularly those building in Mexico and Canada — have captured a larger share of the U.S. market than they did a decade ago. The industry is not disappearing; it is being remade.
Key Takeaways
- U.S. new vehicle sales have stabilized around 15 to 16 million units per year, which is lower than the 2015 peak but far above recession lows.
- Trucks and SUVs now represent about 80 percent of new vehicle sales, while sedans have become a tiny fraction of the market.
- Foreign automakers, especially those with plants in Mexico, have grown their U.S. market share while domestic manufacturers have lost ground.
- The shift to electric vehicles is reshaping which plants operate and which ones close, with legacy factories in the Midwest facing the biggest pressure.
- Used vehicle prices and availability have become a bigger factor in new car sales than they were before 2020.
What the sales numbers actually show
The phrase "auto industry decline" usually means one of two things: fewer cars sold, or fewer cars made in America. The first is partly true; the second is more complicated. Annual U.S. new vehicle sales peaked at 17.5 million in 2015, fell to 14.5 million in 2020 during the pandemic, and have since recovered to around 15 to 16 million. That is a real decline from the peak, but it is not a collapse. For comparison, the average from 2000 to 2010 was about 13 million vehicles per year.
What matters more to the American worker is where those vehicles are built. In 2000, about 82 percent of vehicles sold in the U.S. were made in North America. By 2023, that share had fallen to roughly 75 percent. The gap has been filled by imports from Japan, South Korea, and Germany, as well as by vehicles made in Mexico and Canada by foreign-owned plants. General Motors, Ford, and Stellantis (formerly Chrysler) still dominate the market by brand, but their combined market share has shrunk from about 60 percent in 2000 to roughly 45 percent today.
Trucks and SUVs have replaced sedans almost entirely
The most visible change in what Americans buy is the near-total disappearance of sedans. In 2010, sedans made up about 45 percent of new vehicle sales. By 2023, that number had fallen to roughly 20 percent. Pickup trucks, which accounted for about 15 percent of sales in 2010, now represent roughly 20 percent. SUVs and crossovers — which barely existed as a category in 2000 — now make up about 60 percent of new vehicle sales.
This shift is not a sign of industry weakness; it is a shift in consumer preference driven by fuel prices, road infrastructure, and financing. Trucks and SUVs command higher prices and higher profit margins than sedans, so manufacturers have every reason to build them. The problem is that this shift has left sedan-focused plants idle and created overcapacity in sedan production, which has accelerated plant closures at General Motors and Ford.
Electric vehicles are forcing factory closures and retooling
The transition to electric vehicles is the real source of disruption in the American auto industry. Building an EV requires fewer workers and different skills than building a gas-powered car. A traditional internal combustion engine has roughly 2,000 parts; an electric motor has about 20. This means that even if total vehicle sales stay flat, the number of jobs in traditional assembly plants will fall unless those plants are retooled to build EVs.
General Motors, Ford, and Stellantis have all announced plant closures or conversions over the next five years. General Motors is closing four plants in the U.S. and Canada by 2025, while Ford is idling plants in Ohio and Kentucky. Stellantis is consolidating production. At the same time, Tesla, Hyundai, and other EV makers are building new plants in the South and Southwest. The industry is not shrinking so much as it is moving and changing shape, which is devastating for workers in the Midwest but creates new jobs elsewhere.
Foreign manufacturers have grown faster than domestic ones
Toyota, Honda, Hyundai, and Volkswagen have all increased their U.S. market share over the past 15 years. Much of this growth has come from plants they own in Mexico, which now produces more vehicles for the U.S. market than any other country except the United States itself. Mexico's share of vehicles sold in the U.S. has grown from about 10 percent in 2000 to roughly 25 percent today.
This shift reflects labor costs, tariff structures, and trade agreements. A vehicle made in Mexico can be sold in the U.S. with no tariff under the USMCA (the trade agreement that replaced NAFTA). A vehicle made in Japan or Germany faces a 2.5 percent tariff. For manufacturers, Mexico is often the cheaper option, and for consumers, it means more competition and lower prices — but it also means fewer assembly jobs in the United States.
Used vehicle prices have changed the new car market
One factor that often gets overlooked in "decline" discussions is the used car market. After 2020, used vehicle prices spiked because supply was constrained by semiconductor shortages and pandemic-related factory closures. A used car that would have sold for $15,000 in 2019 might have sold for $20,000 in 2021 or 2022. This made new cars more attractive by comparison, which actually propped up new vehicle sales.
As used vehicle prices have normalized, some buyers have shifted back to the used market, which has put pressure on new car sales. This is not a sign of industry decline; it is a return to normal market conditions. However, it does mean that new vehicle sales are unlikely to return to the 17 million peak of 2015, because the used market is now a more attractive option for price-conscious buyers than it was a decade ago.
What "decline" means for someone buying or maintaining a vehicle
If you are shopping for a new vehicle, the shift in the industry means you have fewer sedan options but more truck and SUV choices. Inventory has stabilized after the shortage of 2021 and 2022, so you are less likely to pay above sticker price. If you are looking at used vehicles, prices have come down from their 2022 peaks but remain higher than they were before 2020.
If you own a vehicle and are thinking about maintenance or repairs, the shift toward foreign manufacturers and EVs means that repair shops are increasingly seeing vehicles from brands like Hyundai, Kia, and Tesla. Traditional domestic brands still dominate the road, but that dominance is eroding. For long-term vehicle ownership, this means you should research repair costs and parts availability for whatever brand you choose, because the landscape is less predictable than it was ten years ago.
Frequently Asked Questions
Are American car companies going out of business?
No. General Motors, Ford, and Stellantis are all profitable and investing billions in electric vehicle production. They have lost market share to foreign competitors, but they still sell more vehicles in the U.S. than any other manufacturers. Plant closures are real and painful for workers, but they reflect a shift in what consumers buy, not the failure of the companies themselves.
Will there be fewer cars available to buy in the future?
No. Total vehicle production capacity in North America is still very high, and new plants are being built. The constraint is not supply but the type of vehicles being made. If you want a sedan, your choices are narrower than they were in 2010. If you want a truck or SUV, your choices are wider. Availability depends on what you are looking for.
Is it a bad time to buy a car right now?
That depends on what you need and what you can afford. New vehicle prices have come down from their 2022 peaks but remain higher than they were before 2020. Used vehicle prices have also normalized but are still elevated. Interest rates matter more than industry trends — if rates are high, buying used or waiting may make more sense than buying new.
Why are so many plants closing in the Midwest?
Sedan production, which was concentrated in the Midwest, has collapsed as a share of the market. At the same time, the shift to electric vehicles requires different manufacturing processes and fewer workers per vehicle. New EV plants are being built in the South and Southwest, where labor costs are lower and there is less legacy infrastructure to maintain.