Where to get a replacement key and what each option costs

You have four main routes to replace a car key: the dealership, a locksmith, a big-box retailer like Home Depot, or an online key-cutting service. The dealership is the most expensive but handles programmed keys (fobs that unlock the car electronically). A locksmith costs less and can come to you. Big-box retailers cut basic keys cheaply but cannot program them. Online services mail you a key, which takes time but costs the least upfront.

Dealership replacement runs $200 to $500 for a programmed key fob, depending on your car's make and model. Some dealerships charge a diagnostic fee on top of the key cost. A locksmith typically charges $50 to $200 for the same work, though they may charge a trip fee if you call them to your location. Home Depot and similar stores cut a basic metal key for $2 to $10, but that key will not unlock your car remotely if your car uses a fob. Online key services cost $10 to $50 for the key itself, but you wait 5 to 10 business days for delivery.

Key Takeaways

  • Dealerships charge the most but are the only option for some newer cars with encrypted fobs that require manufacturer programming.
  • Locksmiths cost 50 to 75 percent less than dealerships and can usually cut and program a key on the same day.
  • Basic metal keys from hardware stores work only if your car has a manual lock cylinder and no electronic fob.
  • You will need proof of ownership (title, registration, or insurance card) and photo ID at any shop, whether dealership or locksmith.
  • Some car insurance policies or roadside information plans cover key replacement, so check your documents before paying out of pocket.

When you need a dealership versus a locksmith

The dealership is your only choice if your car uses a smart key or proximity fob that requires encryption specific to your vehicle's computer system. Most cars made after 2010 use this technology. The dealership has access to your vehicle identification number (VIN) in their system and can program a new fob to match your car's security settings. A locksmith can cut the physical key, but without the manufacturer's proprietary programming equipment, the fob will not work.

A locksmith works for most cars made before 2010 and for many newer vehicles if you have a basic key without remote functions. Locksmiths can also program aftermarket fobs for some models, though not all. Call your locksmith with your car's year, make, and model before you schedule; they can tell you whether they can handle your specific vehicle. If they cannot, they will refer you to a dealership or a specialized automotive locksmith who works with your brand.

What to bring and what information to have ready

Bring your photo ID and proof of ownership. Proof of ownership can be your vehicle registration, title, or insurance card — anything with your name and the vehicle identification number (VIN). The shop needs this to confirm you own the car and are not trying to make a key for someone else's vehicle. If you are locked out and cannot access your registration, bring your driver's license and the VIN from your insurance card or a photo of your car's door jamb (the VIN is stamped there).

Have your car's year, make, model, and VIN ready before you call. The VIN is a 17-character code on your registration, insurance card, or the driver's side door jamb. Locksmiths and dealerships use this to determine which key blank and programming method your car needs. If you are calling a locksmith, also ask whether they charge a trip fee or have a minimum service charge, and whether they can come to your location or whether you need to bring the car to their shop.

Programming and what happens after you get the key

If your car uses a fob, the shop will program the new key to your car's security system during the visit. This usually takes 15 to 30 minutes. You will sit in the waiting area or stay with your car while they work. Once programming is complete, test the key before you leave — unlock and lock the car, open the trunk, and if your car has a panic button, press it to confirm it works.

Keep your old key even if it no longer works. If you have a spare key at home, bring it with you; some shops can reprogram your old key instead of cutting a new one, which saves money. If you lose all your keys, the shop will need to reprogram your car's entire security system, which costs more and takes longer. Ask the shop whether they can reprogram an old key before they cut a new one.

Insurance and roadside information coverage for key replacement

Some car insurance policies include roadside information that covers lockouts and key replacement. Check your policy documents or call your insurance company before you pay for a replacement. Roadside information plans through AAA, Better World Club, or similar services often cover key replacement up to a certain amount, usually $50 to $100. If your plan covers it, you call the roadside information number and they dispatch a locksmith to you.

Manufacturer roadside information programs (like GM OnStar or Ford Roadside information) may also cover key replacement, though coverage varies by plan and vehicle age. Check your vehicle's owner manual or the manufacturer's website for details. If you have coverage, using it costs you only the deductible or a small co-pay, which is usually less than paying a locksmith directly.

Aftermarket keys and whether they are worth the cost savings

Aftermarket fobs cost less than dealership fobs — typically $30 to $80 instead of $200 to $500 — but they come with trade-offs. An aftermarket fob has the same buttons and functions as the original, but it is made by a third party, not your car's manufacturer. Quality varies widely. Some aftermarket fobs work reliably for years; others fail within months. You still need a locksmith or dealership to program it to your car, so you do not save on labor.

If you buy an aftermarket fob online, you will need to have it programmed by a locksmith or dealership, which adds $50 to $150 to the total cost. The shop may charge more to program an aftermarket fob than an OEM (original equipment manufacturer) fob because it requires extra steps. If the aftermarket fob fails after a few months, you have no warranty from the manufacturer and may need to buy another one. For most people, a locksmith's price for an OEM fob is a better deal than buying aftermarket and paying for programming separately.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can a locksmith make a key if I do not have the original?

Yes. A locksmith can cut a new key from your car's lock cylinder or from your VIN if your car's locks are standard. For fobs, they will need your VIN and proof of ownership. The process takes longer than copying an existing key, and the cost is higher, but it is possible.

What if my car key breaks in half?

If only the plastic fob casing is cracked, a locksmith can sometimes transfer the electronics to a new casing for $20 to $50. If the metal key blade is broken, you need a new key cut. Bring both pieces to the shop so they can assess whether the electronics are salvageable.

How long does it take to get a replacement key?

A locksmith or dealership can cut and program a key on the same day, usually within an hour. Online key services take 5 to 10 business days for delivery, plus you still need a locksmith to program it. If you need a key urgently, a local locksmith is your fastest option.

Will the dealership charge me if I have only one key left?

No, but some dealerships charge a higher fee if you have lost all your keys because they must reprogram your car's entire security system. If you still have one working key, bring it with you; the dealership can reprogram that key instead of creating a new one, which costs less.

Can I program a key myself?

Some cars allow you to program a spare fob yourself using a sequence of button presses and ignition turns, but this works only on certain models and only if you have at least one working key. Check your owner's manual for instructions. Most newer cars require professional programming equipment, so you cannot do it yourself.