The Volkswagen scandal was software that made diesel engines pass emissions tests they would fail in real driving

Between 2009 and 2015, Volkswagen installed defeat device software in roughly 11 million diesel vehicles worldwide—about 500,000 in the United States. The software detected when a car was undergoing an official emissions test and switched the engine to a low-emissions mode. Once the test ended and the car returned to normal driving, the software switched back off, allowing the engine to emit nitrogen oxides (NOx) at levels up to 40 times higher than legal limits.

The company knew the engines could not meet U.S. emissions standards under real-world conditions, so rather than redesign them, engineers wrote code to cheat the test. Volkswagen executives approved the strategy. The company was caught in September 2015 when researchers at West Virginia University tested a Jetta and Passat on the road and found massive gaps between lab results and actual emissions.

This matters to you because it exposed how a major manufacturer prioritized profit over the engineering integrity that keeps engines reliable and the air breathable. It also changed how emissions testing works and what happens when a recall involves software rather than a physical part.

Key Takeaways

  • Volkswagen programmed diesel engines to emit far less pollution during official tests than they did on the road, fooling regulators for six years.
  • Owners of affected vehicles could return them to Volkswagen for a buyback, trade-in credit, or an engine software update that reduced performance but brought emissions into compliance.
  • The scandal led to stricter real-world emissions testing (the WLTP standard in Europe and tighter EPA oversight in the U.S.) so manufacturers cannot hide poor performance in the lab.
  • Volkswagen paid over $15 billion in fines, settlements, and buybacks, making it one of the costliest corporate penalties in history.
  • If you own an affected VW diesel, the software fix is free and covered under warranty, but it reduces fuel economy and engine power slightly.

Which Volkswagen models were affected

The defeat device was installed in Volkswagen, Audi, Porsche, and Skoda diesel models sold between 2009 and 2015. In the United States, the main vehicles were the Volkswagen Jetta, Golf, Beetle, and Passat with 2.0-liter TDI diesel engines. Audi A3 and A6 models with the same engine were also included. Porsche Cayenne and Skoda Octavia models sold in other markets contained the software as well.

The scandal did not affect gasoline-powered Volkswagens or any diesel models made after 2015, because the company stopped using the defeat device once the cheating was discovered. If you own a diesel VW from 2009–2015, you can check whether your specific vehicle is on the recall list by entering your vehicle identification number (VIN) on the EPA's website or Volkswagen's recall portal.

What the software actually did to engine performance

The defeat device monitored steering wheel position, vehicle speed, engine temperature, and barometric pressure to recognize when the car was on a dynamometer (the treadmill-like machine used in emissions labs). When it detected a test, the engine switched to a mode that injected extra urea into the exhaust—a chemical that breaks down NOx into harmless nitrogen and water. This mode worked, but it consumed urea quickly, cost money to refill, and reduced fuel economy.

In normal driving, the software turned off the extra urea injection to save cost and improve fuel economy and power. This allowed NOx emissions to spike. On the road, affected vehicles emitted between 15 and 40 times the legal limit of nitrogen oxides, depending on driving conditions and engine load. Nitrogen oxides contribute to smog and respiratory illness, particularly in children and people with asthma.

The irony is that Volkswagen's engineers could have designed the engine to meet emissions standards honestly. They chose not to because doing so would have reduced fuel economy and power—features that helped sell the cars. The company bet that regulators would not catch the discrepancy, and for six years, they were right.

Buyback, trade-in, or software repair options

Volkswagen offered three paths for owners of affected vehicles. The first was a buyback: Volkswagen would repurchase the car at fair market value (determined by an independent appraiser) and handle the title transfer. Owners kept any trade-in value and did not have to pay sales tax on the buyback amount. This option was popular because it let owners exit the situation entirely.

The second option was a trade-in credit: Volkswagen would give owners a credit toward the purchase of any new vehicle (not just Volkswagen) equal to the buyback amount. This let owners upgrade to a newer car without the scandal attached.

The third option was a software update: Volkswagen would reprogram the engine to run the emissions-control system all the time, bringing the vehicle into compliance. The update was free and covered under warranty. However, it reduced fuel economy by 1 to 2 miles per gallon and engine power by roughly 5 to 10 percent, depending on the model. Owners who chose this route kept their cars but accepted a permanent performance penalty.

The important date to choose one of these options has passed in most states, but owners who did not act by the important date can still contact Volkswagen to discuss their situation. The company has extended some remedies on a case-by-case basis.

How the scandal changed emissions testing worldwide

Before 2015, emissions tests were conducted in controlled lab conditions on a dynamometer. Manufacturers knew the exact test procedure and could optimize engines specifically for it. The Volkswagen scandal exposed how far real-world emissions could diverge from lab results.

In response, the EPA introduced real-world driving emissions (RDE) testing in the United States starting with 2017 model year vehicles. RDE testing uses portable emissions measurement systems (PEMS)—equipment mounted on the vehicle during actual road driving—to measure what the engine actually emits. The test includes city, highway, and rural driving at various speeds and loads, making it much harder to game.

Europe went further with the Worldwide Harmonized Light Vehicle Test Procedure (WLTP), which replaced the older New European Driving Cycle (NEDC) test. WLTP is more aggressive, includes higher speeds and faster acceleration, and is harder to optimize for without actually improving the engine. Both standards now require manufacturers to monitor emissions continuously and flag any vehicle that exceeds limits by more than a small margin.

These changes mean modern cars are tested more like they are actually driven, and regulators have better tools to catch cheating. No manufacturer has attempted a defeat device since Volkswagen's was discovered.

Long-term reliability and resale value of affected vehicles

The defeat device itself does not damage the engine. The software is just code; it does not wear parts or cause mechanical failure. Owners who chose the software update and kept their cars have reported normal reliability over the years since the fix was applied. The main complaint is the slight loss of fuel economy and power, which is permanent but not severe enough to make the car undriveable.

Resale value for affected vehicles took a hit when ready after the scandal broke, but it has recovered somewhat over time. A 2012 Jetta or Golf with the software update is still a functional, reliable car—it just carries the historical baggage of the scandal. Buyers know the vehicle was cheating and may be skeptical, even though the fix is legitimate. This skepticism keeps resale prices slightly lower than comparable non-VW diesels, but the difference has narrowed as the scandal fades from memory.

If you own one of these vehicles and plan to sell it, be transparent about the recall and the fix you chose. Buyers appreciate honesty, and the software update is a documented, warranty-backed repair that brought the vehicle into compliance. The car is safe and legal to drive.

Why this matters beyond Volkswagen

The scandal revealed that a company with a reputation for engineering excellence and German precision was willing to systematically deceive regulators and customers. It showed that without real-world testing and oversight, manufacturers can hide poor engineering behind lab results. It also demonstrated that software—not just mechanical parts—can be used to cheat, and that regulators need to understand code as well as engines.

For you as a car owner, the lesson is that manufacturer claims about emissions and fuel economy are tested under specific conditions that may not match your actual driving. Real-world results vary based on your driving habits, traffic, weather, and how well you maintain the engine. The Volkswagen scandal made testing more realistic, but it did not make it perfect. Modern emissions standards are stricter and more honestly enforced than they were in 2015, which means cleaner air and more reliable engines overall.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do I need to get the software update if I own an affected Volkswagen?

If you still own the car, yes—the update is required to bring it into legal compliance with emissions standards. It is free and covered under warranty. Without it, your vehicle is technically illegal to drive in most states, though enforcement is rare. The update is permanent and cannot be reversed.

Will the software update hurt my engine?

No. The update straightforward enables the emissions-control system that should have been running all along. It does not damage the engine, but it does reduce fuel economy by 1 to 2 mpg and power by 5 to 10 percent. These losses are permanent and cannot be undone without removing the update, which is illegal.

Can I still buy a used Volkswagen diesel from 2009 to 2015?

Yes, but make sure the software update has already been applied. Ask the seller for proof of the recall completion. If the update has not been done, you can have it done yourself for free at any Volkswagen dealer. Avoid any vehicle where the seller cannot or will not provide evidence of the fix.

What happened to the Volkswagen executives responsible?

Several executives faced criminal charges in the United States and Europe. Some were convicted and served prison time; others settled with prosecutors. The CEO at the time, Martin Winterkorn, was charged but the case was eventually dismissed on technical grounds in Germany. The scandal led to major leadership changes at Volkswagen and a shift toward electric vehicles as the company tried to rebuild its reputation.

Does this mean other manufacturers are cheating too?

Not necessarily. The Volkswagen scandal was systematic and deliberate—the company programmed the cheating into millions of cars. Since then, regulators have implemented real-world testing and closer oversight, making large-scale cheating much harder to hide. Some manufacturers have been caught with smaller violations, but nothing approaching Volkswagen's scale has been discovered.