Start with your car's tire size and load requirements
The fastest way to find tires that fit your car is to look at the sidewall of one of your current tires or check your owner's manual. You'll find a code like P215/55R17 — that's your tire size, and it tells you the width, aspect ratio, wheel diameter, and load capacity. Every tire you buy must match this size exactly, or your speedometer will read wrong and your car's handling will change.
If you can't find your current tire size, open your driver's side door and look at the placard (a white sticker) on the inside edge. It lists the recommended tire size, load index, and pressure. This placard is more reliable than the tire itself, because the previous owner may have installed the wrong size. Write down the entire code — you'll need it to search.
Your car also has a speed rating printed on that same placard or in your manual. Common ratings are H (up to 130 mph), V (up to 149 mph), and W (up to 168 mph). Match the speed rating or go higher; never go lower. A tire rated for slower speeds will wear faster under normal driving.
Key Takeaways
- Find your tire size on the sidewall of your current tire, your door placard, or your owner's manual — it looks like P215/55R17 and must match exactly on any replacement.
- Decide what you need the tires for: all-season tires work year-round in most climates, while winter tires grip better in snow and summer tires handle heat better.
- Compare tires by tread warranty (how many miles the tread is may provide to last), all-weather performance ratings, and price per tire, not just the lowest upfront cost.
- Buy from a tire retailer, warehouse club, or online seller, then have them installed at a shop — installation usually costs $15 to $25 per tire and includes balancing.
- Check your tire pressure monthly and rotate your tires every 5,000 to 7,000 miles to make them last longer and wear evenly.
Choose a tire type based on your climate and driving
All-season tires are the most common choice. They handle dry roads, light rain, and light snow reasonably well, and they last longer than winter or summer tires. If you live somewhere that rarely gets below freezing and you don't drive in heavy snow, all-season tires are usually enough. They cost less upfront than buying two sets of tires.
Winter tires have softer rubber and deeper treads that grip snow and ice much better than all-season tires. If you live in a place that gets regular snow or ice, winter tires are worth the cost — they reduce stopping distance on ice by 20 to 30 feet compared to all-season tires at highway speeds. You'll need to buy a second set of wheels to swap them seasonally, or pay a shop to swap and store them. Winter tires wear faster in warm weather, so you should only use them November through March.
Summer tires are designed for warm climates and high performance. They grip well on dry pavement and handle heat without softening, but they have less tread depth and perform poorly in cold or wet conditions. Unless you live in a warm place year-round or drive a sports car, summer tires are not necessary.
Compare tires by warranty, ratings, and total cost
Tire retailers and manufacturers publish a tread wear warranty — a promise that the tread will last a certain number of miles. A tire with a 40,000-mile warranty will cost less upfront but wear out faster than one with a 60,000-mile warranty. Divide the tire's price by the warranty miles to find the cost per thousand miles. A $100 tire with a 40,000-mile warranty costs $2.50 per thousand miles; a $140 tire with a 60,000-mile warranty costs $2.33 per thousand miles, so it's cheaper in the long run.
Look for the Uniform Tire Quality Grading (UTQG) label on the tire's sidewall or the retailer's website. It shows three ratings: tread wear (a number like 500 or 620), traction (AA, A, B, or C), and temperature (A, B, or C). Higher numbers and letters mean better performance. A tire rated 620 tread wear will last about 24% longer than one rated 500, all else equal.
Don't buy based on price alone. A tire that costs $20 less per tire but wears out 10,000 miles sooner will cost you more overall. Factor in installation costs ($15 to $25 per tire at most shops), balancing (usually included), and how long you plan to keep the car. If you're selling in two years, a cheaper tire with a shorter warranty makes sense. If you're keeping the car longer, a more expensive tire with a longer warranty usually saves money.
Where to buy tires and how to get them installed
You can buy tires from a tire specialty shop (Discount Tire, Tire Rack, Costco, Sam's Club), a big-box retailer (Walmart, Target), an online seller (Amazon, Tire Rack, Costco.com), or a car dealership. Specialty shops and warehouse clubs often have the widest selection and competitive pricing. Online sellers are usually cheaper but require you to arrange installation separately.
Once you've bought the tires, you need to have them installed and balanced. Most tire shops charge $15 to $25 per tire for installation, which includes removing the old tire, mounting the new one, and balancing it. Some retailers (Costco, Discount Tire, Walmart) offer installation for free or at a flat rate if you buy from them. If you buy online, search for "tire installation near me" to find a local shop. Bring your receipt to prove you own the tires — some shops won't install tires you didn't buy from them, though most will for a small fee.
Balancing is critical. An unbalanced tire causes vibration at highway speeds and wears unevenly. Most shops balance tires as part of installation. If you're replacing only two tires, ask the shop to balance all four — it costs a bit more but prevents uneven wear.
Understand tire pressure and rotation to extend tire life
Check your tire pressure once a month and before long trips. The correct pressure is printed on your door placard, not on the tire sidewall. The sidewall shows the maximum pressure the tire can hold, which is higher than what your car needs. Underinflated tires wear faster on the edges; overinflated tires wear faster in the center. Both reduce fuel economy and handling.
Tire pressure changes with temperature — it drops about 1 pound per square inch for every 10-degree drop in outside temperature. In winter, your tires may lose 5 to 10 psi, so check them more often. Use a tire pressure gauge (available at any auto parts store for under $10) or ask a shop to check for free.
Rotate your tires every 5,000 to 7,000 miles to make them wear evenly. Front tires wear faster because they handle steering and braking, so rotating them to the rear extends their life. Most shops charge $20 to $50 for a rotation. If you buy from a tire retailer, ask whether free rotations are included — many offer them for the life of the tire.
What to do if you need tires urgently or have an unusual size
If you have a flat tire and need a replacement the same day, call a tire shop directly rather than ordering online. Specialty shops like Discount Tire and Costco usually have common sizes in stock and can install them within a few hours. Big-box retailers like Walmart may have longer wait times. If it's after hours, a roadside service like AAA can tow you to an open shop or bring a spare.
If your car has an unusual size — very large wheels, a luxury brand, or an older model — you may need to order online and wait 3 to 7 days for delivery. Tire Rack and Amazon carry a wider selection than local shops. Call ahead to confirm the shop can install tires you've ordered, and ask about any additional fees for unusual sizes.
If you drive a high-performance or luxury car, your tires may be more expensive and harder to find. Check your manual or door placard for the exact size and speed rating, then search multiple retailers to compare availability and price. Some luxury brands require specific tire models, so don't assume a cheaper tire with the same size will work the same way.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I replace just two tires instead of four?
Yes, but it's not ideal. If you replace only two tires, put the new ones on the rear axle and move the older rear tires to the front. This prevents the rear from sliding out during hard braking. If your car has all-wheel drive, replacing just two tires can strain the transmission because the new tires will spin at a different speed than the old ones. Ask your mechanic whether your car can handle a two-tire replacement.
What's the difference between a tire's sidewall size and what the door placard says?
The sidewall shows the maximum size and pressure the tire can handle. The door placard shows the size and pressure your car manufacturer recommends. Always match the door placard, not the sidewall. The previous owner may have installed oversized tires, which will throw off your speedometer and fuel economy.
Do I need to buy tires from the same brand as my current ones?
No. You can mix brands as long as the size, load index, and speed rating match. Mixing brands is common and doesn't affect your car's performance. However, avoid mixing all-season and winter tires on the same car, and don't put summer tires on the front and all-season on the rear.
How do I know if my tires are worn out?
Tires are legally worn out when the tread depth reaches 2/32 of an inch. Use the penny test: insert a penny into the tread with Lincoln's head upside down. If you can see the top of his head, the tread is too shallow and the tires need replacement. Most tires last 3 to 5 years regardless of mileage, so replace them even if the tread looks fine if they're older than that.
Should I buy the most expensive tires?
Not necessarily. Mid-range tires from established brands (Michelin, Goodyear, Bridgestone, Continental) offer good value and last longer than budget brands. Compare the cost per thousand miles of tread warranty rather than the upfront price. A $120 tire with a 60,000-mile warranty is usually a better deal than a $80 tire with a 40,000-mile warranty.