Buying tires online costs less than a dealership, but you need to handle installation separately

Online tire retailers typically undercut dealership prices by 15 to 40 percent because they don't operate service bays. You order from sites like Tire Rack, Costco.com, Amazon, or Walmart.com, then either pick them up locally or have them shipped to an installer. The installer—often an independent shop, a big-box retailer, or a tire chain—mounts and balances them for a separate fee, usually $15 to $30 per tire.

The real savings come from comparing prices across retailers and choosing where to have them installed. A set of four mid-range all-season tires might cost $400 to $600 online versus $550 to $800 at a dealership, but installation adds $60 to $120 to your total. You'll also need to factor in whether you're keeping your old tires (most installers charge $5 to $10 per tire to dispose of them) and whether you want services like wheel alignment or tire rotation included.

Key Takeaways

  • Online tire prices are typically 15 to 40 percent lower than dealership prices, but you must arrange and pay for installation separately.
  • You can have tires shipped to an independent installer, a tire chain, or a big-box retailer—not all shops accept tires you bring in, so confirm before ordering.
  • Installation fees range from $60 to $120 for a full set, and disposal of old tires usually costs $5 to $10 per tire.
  • Some online retailers offer free shipping on orders over a certain amount, and some partner with local installers to simplify the process.
  • Buying online works best when you know your tire size and have a trusted installer lined up before you place the order.

Finding your tire size and comparing prices

Your tire size is printed on the sidewall of your current tires and in your vehicle's owner manual or the driver's door jamb. It looks like this: 225/65R17. Write this down before you start shopping—every online retailer will ask for it, and you need it to compare prices across sites.

Once you have your size, search the same tire model on at least three retailers: Tire Rack, Costco.com, Walmart.com, Amazon, and Discount Tire Direct are the largest. Prices vary significantly, sometimes by $50 or more per tire. Also check whether the retailer offers free shipping—many do on orders over $50 or $75, which can save you $20 to $40. Some retailers like Tire Rack and Discount Tire Direct also show you local installers and let you reserve installation time before you buy, which removes guesswork.

Choosing an installer before you order

Not every shop will mount tires you've bought elsewhere. Call or visit your preferred installer—an independent tire shop, Firestone, Goodyear, Costco, Walmart, or a local mechanic—and ask whether they accept outside tires. Most do, but some dealerships and a few chain locations don't. Confirm the installation fee and whether it includes balancing, valve stem replacement, and old tire disposal.

If you don't have a trusted installer, use Tire Rack's or Discount Tire Direct's installer locator tool. Both show nearby shops that accept their shipments and often let you book an appointment before you order. This guarantees a time slot and ensures the tires will be there when you need them installed. Independent shops and local chains are often cheaper than big-box retailers for installation—sometimes $10 to $15 per tire less—so it's worth calling around.

Shipping options and timing

Most online retailers ship to your home or directly to your installer. Shipping to an installer is usually faster and safer because the tires arrive at a place equipped to handle them. Shipping to your home works if you have a garage or covered space, but tires left on a porch can degrade in direct sunlight and are a theft target in some areas.

Standard shipping takes 5 to 10 business days. Expedited shipping (2 to 3 days) costs extra, usually $15 to $30. Plan ahead: order at least a week before you need the tires installed, longer if you're shipping to your home and then need to transport them to a shop. If you're having tires shipped directly to an installer, confirm the installer's receiving hours and whether they charge a receiving fee (most don't).

Installation fees and what they cover

A typical installation package includes mounting, balancing, and new valve stems. The cost is usually $15 to $30 per tire, or $60 to $120 for four tires. Some shops bundle this with old tire disposal; others charge separately. Disposal typically runs $5 to $10 per tire, so budget an extra $20 to $40 if it's not included.

Wheel alignment is separate and costs $75 to $200 depending on whether it's a two-wheel or four-wheel alignment. You don't need alignment every time you buy tires, but if your vehicle pulls to one side or your tires are wearing unevenly, get it checked. Some installers offer a discount if you buy alignment at the same time as installation. Ask about this when you call to confirm they accept outside tires.

When to buy tires online versus at a dealership

Online buying makes sense if you have time to plan ahead, know your tire size, and have access to a reliable installer. The savings—often $100 to $300 for a full set—are real. It also makes sense if you want a specific tire model that your local shops don't stock; online retailers carry a much wider selection.

A dealership is faster if you need tires today or tomorrow and don't want to coordinate shipping and installation yourself. You'll pay more, but you walk out with new tires and a warranty from the dealership. Dealerships also handle alignment and other suspension work in one visit, which saves time if your vehicle needs it. For most people, the online route saves money if you can wait a week and make one phone call to an installer.

Warranty and return policies

Tires bought online come with the manufacturer's warranty, which covers defects and uneven wear for a set number of years or miles. This warranty is the same whether you buy from a dealership or online—the tire maker honors it, not the retailer. Keep your receipt and the tire paperwork in case you need to make a claim.

Return policies vary by retailer. Tire Rack and Discount Tire Direct allow returns within 30 days if the tires haven't been mounted. Costco and Walmart have similar windows. Once tires are mounted and balanced, most retailers won't take them back unless there's a defect. Read the return policy before you order, especially if you're unsure about the tire model or size.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I have tires shipped to my home and then take them to a shop?

Yes, but it's less convenient. You'll need to store them indoors and arrange transport to the installer. Most shops prefer tires shipped directly to them because it's faster and removes handling steps. If you do ship to your home, confirm the installer will accept them before you order.

What if the installer says they won't mount tires I bought online?

Find a different installer. Most independent shops, tire chains, and big-box retailers accept outside tires. Dealerships are more likely to refuse, but even some dealerships will do it for a higher fee. Use an installer locator tool or call ahead to avoid this problem.

Do I need to buy tires from the same brand as my current ones?

No. You can mix brands as long as the size and load rating match your vehicle. Your owner's manual lists the correct size and load rating. Mixing brands is common and doesn't affect safety or performance, though some people prefer to stick with one brand for consistency.

Is it cheaper to buy tires online if I already have a Costco membership?

Sometimes. Costco's tire prices are competitive, and members get free installation at Costco locations. Compare Costco's price plus installation against other online retailers plus your installer's fee. Costco often wins on total cost if you have a nearby location, but not always.

What happens if a tire arrives damaged?

Contact the retailer when ready with photos. Most will ship a replacement at no cost. If the tire is damaged during installation, the installer usually handles the claim with the retailer. This is why shipping directly to an installer is safer—they inspect tires when they arrive and document any damage before mounting.