The Thule Motion XT XXL is a large roof-mounted cargo box that holds 18.9 cubic feet of gear

The Thule Motion XT XXL is a dual-side-opening roof box designed for vehicles that need serious cargo space without a trailer. It's one of Thule's largest hard-shell options, sitting above the Motion XT L and below only a few specialty models. The box opens from both sides, which matters if you're parked tight against a wall or loading from the passenger side.

You'll pay between $500 and $700 for the box itself, depending on the finish (glossy or matte) and where you buy it. You'll also need a roof rack system if you don't have one—that's another $150 to $400 depending on your vehicle. Installation takes about an hour if you're comfortable with basic tools, or you can have a shop do it for $100 to $150.

The real cost isn't just money. A roof box adds wind noise at highway speeds, reduces fuel economy by roughly 5 to 10 percent, and raises your vehicle's center of gravity. That last part matters if you drive in snow or take sharp turns regularly. It also makes parking in low-clearance garages impossible—the box adds about 15 inches to your vehicle's height.

Key Takeaways

  • The Motion XT XXL holds 18.9 cubic feet and opens from both sides, making it useful for tight parking situations or loading from either side of the vehicle.
  • Total cost including the box, roof rack, and installation typically runs $700 to $1,200 depending on your vehicle and whether you install it yourself.
  • Roof boxes reduce fuel economy by 5 to 10 percent and add wind noise, so they're best for occasional long trips rather than daily commuting.
  • The box fits most vehicles with a roof rack, but you need to check ground clearance in your garage or parking structure before buying.

What the Motion XT XXL actually holds

The 18.9 cubic feet of space is the usable interior volume, not the external dimensions. In real terms, that's roughly equivalent to a large suitcase plus a medium duffel bag, or about four large rolling luggage pieces. Thule rates it for 165 pounds of cargo weight, though the actual limit depends on your vehicle's roof weight capacity—most cars max out at 150 pounds total, including the box itself.

The dual-side-opening design means you can open the lid from either the driver or passenger side. This is genuinely useful if you're parked against a curb or loading in a tight spot, but it also means two separate hinges and seals to maintain. The box is aerodynamic compared to older square designs, which helps with wind noise and fuel economy, though you'll still notice both.

Roof rack requirements and compatibility

The Motion XT XXL requires a crossbar roof rack with a minimum 60-inch span. Most vehicles come with factory racks or can accept aftermarket ones from Thule, Yakima, or other brands. The box itself weighs about 75 pounds, so your vehicle's roof needs to support that plus your cargo plus the rack system itself.

Check your vehicle's owner manual for the roof weight limit—this is the single most important number. A Honda Civic might max out at 150 pounds total; a Subaru Outback might handle 200. The Motion XT XXL box alone is 75 pounds, leaving you only 75 to 125 pounds for cargo on most sedans. Trucks and SUVs usually have higher limits.

Installation involves clamping the box to your crossbars using Thule's U-bolt system. If you already have a roof rack, installation takes 30 to 45 minutes. If you need to install the rack first, add another 30 to 60 minutes. Most dealers and tire shops offer installation for $100 to $150 total.

Fuel economy and noise trade-offs

A roof box increases aerodynamic drag, which costs fuel. Real-world testing shows a 5 to 10 percent increase in fuel consumption at highway speeds, depending on your vehicle's shape and how fast you're driving. At 65 mph, a car that normally gets 30 mpg might drop to 27 to 28 mpg with the box loaded. The penalty is smaller at city speeds and larger at 75+ mph.

Wind noise is noticeable but not unbearable. Most people describe it as a low whooshing sound that becomes apparent above 50 mph. It's louder with the box empty than loaded, because empty boxes vibrate slightly. Thule's aerodynamic design minimizes this compared to older boxy models, but you won't mistake it for silence.

If you drive long distances regularly, the fuel cost adds up. A 2,000-mile road trip with a 10 percent fuel penalty costs roughly $40 to $80 in extra fuel depending on gas prices and your vehicle. For occasional trips, that's acceptable. For weekly commuting, it's not worth it—you'd be better off renting a box for specific trips.

Maintenance and durability

The Motion XT XXL is made from ABS plastic with an aluminum frame. It's durable but not indestructible. The hinges and seals are the wear points. Thule covers the box for five years against manufacturing defects, but not against impact damage or normal wear.

You'll want to clean the seals twice a year and check the mounting bolts annually. Salt spray and UV exposure degrade the plastic over time, especially if you live near the coast or in a sunny climate. The matte finish hides dirt better than glossy, but both require occasional washing to prevent buildup.

The dual-side hinges are more complex than single-side designs, which means more potential failure points. In practice, Thule's engineering is solid and failures are rare, but if a hinge breaks, repair costs run $150 to $300 depending on which part fails.

Comparing the Motion XT XXL to other roof boxes

Thule makes three main sizes in the Motion XT line: L (16 cubic feet), XL (18.3 cubic feet), and XXL (18.9 cubic feet). The difference between XL and XXL is small—about 0.6 cubic feet—but the XXL's dual-side opening is the real advantage. If you only need single-side access, the XL costs $50 to $100 less and saves a few pounds.

Yakima's SkyBox is a direct competitor with similar capacity and pricing. The main difference is aesthetics and brand loyalty—both are well-made, and both have similar fuel economy penalties. Yakima's boxes tend to be slightly quieter according to owner reports, but the difference is marginal.

If you need more space, Thule's Force XT Cargo Box goes up to 21 cubic feet, but costs $200 to $300 more and adds noticeable weight and drag. For most people, the XXL is the sweet spot between capacity and practicality.

Garage clearance and parking considerations

The Motion XT XXL adds approximately 15 inches to your vehicle's height. If your garage has 6 feet 8 inches of clearance (standard in many homes), you'll have only 5 inches of margin. Measure your garage before buying. Some parking structures have height restrictions posted at the entrance—8 feet is common, which rules out most roof boxes entirely.

If you park in a garage regularly, a roof box isn't practical for daily use. You'd be installing and removing it constantly, which defeats the purpose. Roof boxes make sense for people who park in open lots or driveways, or who only use them for specific trips.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I use the Motion XT XXL on any vehicle with a roof rack?

Not quite. You need a roof rack with at least 60-inch crossbars, and your vehicle's roof weight limit must accommodate the box (75 pounds) plus cargo. Check your owner's manual for the roof weight limit before buying. Some vehicles, particularly older sedans, have limits too low to safely use a large roof box.

Does the dual-side opening really make a difference?

Yes, if you park in tight spaces or load from both sides of your vehicle. For most people who park in open lots and load from one side, the single-side XL model works just as well and costs less. The dual-side feature is useful but not essential.

How much will the roof box reduce my fuel economy?

Expect a 5 to 10 percent reduction at highway speeds, depending on your vehicle and how fast you drive. At 65 mph, a car getting 30 mpg might drop to 27 to 28 mpg. City driving is less affected. The penalty is larger at higher speeds.

Can I leave the roof box on year-round?

Technically yes, but it's not ideal. The constant drag reduces fuel economy every day, and UV exposure degrades the plastic over time. Most owners remove the box when not in use and store it in a garage or shed. Removing and reinstalling takes 15 to 20 minutes once you've done it once.

What's the difference between the XXL and the XL model?

The XXL holds 18.9 cubic feet versus 18.3 for the XL—a difference of about 0.6 cubic feet, which is negligible. The XXL's main advantage is the dual-side opening. If you only need single-side access, the XL costs less and weighs slightly less.