Matthews Auto Group is a multi-location dealership chain with stores across several states
Matthews Auto Group operates as a regional dealership network, not a single location. The company runs multiple franchised dealerships under the Matthews name, each typically handling new and used vehicle sales for specific brands. If you're considering a purchase from Matthews, you need to know which location you're visiting, what brand they carry, and what that particular store's reputation looks like—because dealership experience varies significantly by location and sales team, even within the same company.
The dealership model itself means Matthews Auto Group makes money on the sale, on financing if you use their lender, and on service contracts and add-ons. Understanding this structure helps you recognize where pressure points will come during negotiation and what you can push back on without damaging the deal.
Key Takeaways
- Matthews Auto Group operates multiple locations across different states, so your experience depends entirely on which store you visit and which brand they sell.
- Dealerships profit from the vehicle sale, financing arrangements, and add-on products like warranties and paint protection, which means these items are negotiable.
- Before visiting, research that specific location's reviews on Google and the Better Business Bureau, because ratings vary by store.
- Get a pre-purchase inspection from an independent mechanic before signing anything, especially on used vehicles, regardless of what the dealership promises.
- Know your budget and financing terms before you arrive so you can compare the dealership's offer against what your bank or credit union will provide.
How to research a specific Matthews location before you go
Start by identifying which Matthews Auto Group location you plan to visit and what brand they carry. Visit their website or call to confirm they have the vehicle type you want. Then search that specific location on Google Maps and the Better Business Bureau website. Read recent reviews, but focus on patterns rather than single complaints—one bad experience doesn't mean the store is unreliable, but five complaints about the same issue (like hidden fees or pressure tactics) tells you something real.
Check whether the location has a service department and what customers say about it. Some dealerships are known for fair service pricing; others use the service bay to upsell aggressively. If you plan to use their service after purchase, this matters. Also look for whether the store has been in business at that location for several years—turnover in management and sales staff can change a dealership's reputation quickly.
What happens during the sales process at a dealership
When you arrive, a sales associate will greet you and ask what you're looking for. Be honest about your budget and what you need, but do not volunteer that you have already been approved for financing or that you have cash. The dealership wants to control the financing conversation because that's where they make additional profit. Test drive the vehicle you're interested in, and take your time—a good salesperson will give you space to think.
After the test drive, you'll be taken to the sales office to discuss price and terms. This is where negotiation happens. The dealership will present a price, and you should counter with a lower offer based on research you did beforehand using Kelley Blue Book or NADA Guides. Once you agree on a vehicle price, the conversation shifts to financing, warranties, and add-ons like paint protection, fabric guard, or extended service contracts. Every one of these is negotiable or refusable. Do not feel pressured to buy them in the moment.
Understanding the paperwork and what you can refuse
Before you sign, you will receive a Buyer's Order or Purchase Agreement. This document lists the vehicle, the agreed price, any trade-in value, and the terms of the sale. Read it carefully. Make sure the vehicle description matches what you test drove, the price matches what you negotiated, and there are no surprise fees listed. Some dealerships add documentation fees, dealer prep fees, or advertising fees—these vary by state and by dealership, and some are negotiable.
You will also see offers for extended warranties, gap insurance, paint protection, and service contracts. Gap insurance can be useful if you're financing a vehicle and putting down less than 20 percent, because it covers the difference between what you owe and what the car is worth if it's totaled. Everything else is optional. If you don't want it, say no. The dealership will push back, but you have the right to refuse. Do not let anyone tell you that refusing these items will void your manufacturer's warranty—that is false.
Financing through the dealership versus bringing your own lender
Dealerships offer financing through banks and credit unions they work with. The dealership acts as a middleman and earns a commission based on the interest rate they find for you. This means the rate they offer may be higher than what you could get directly from your own bank or credit union. Before you visit, contact your bank or credit union and ask what rate they would offer you based on your credit. Write that number down and bring it with you.
At the dealership, listen to their financing offer, but do not commit when ready. Tell them you want to compare it to what your lender offered. If the dealership's rate is lower, take it. If it's higher, tell them you'll use your own financing. Some dealerships will try to match or beat your rate to keep the financing profit; others will let you walk away. Either way, you win by having done the homework first.
What to do after you buy: the inspection period and warranty coverage
Most states give you a short window—often three to five days—to have the vehicle inspected by an independent mechanic before the sale is final. Use this time. Take the car to a shop that does not work with the dealership and have them do a full inspection. They will check the engine, transmission, brakes, suspension, and electrical systems. This costs between $100 and $200 and can save you thousands if the vehicle has hidden problems. If the inspection finds significant issues, you can often back out of the deal or negotiate a repair credit.
After purchase, your vehicle is covered by the manufacturer's warranty for the time and mileage specified in your owner's manual—typically three years or 36,000 miles for basic coverage. This coverage is the same whether you buy from Matthews Auto Group or any other dealership. Any extended warranty you purchased is separate and adds time or mileage beyond the manufacturer's coverage. Keep all paperwork, including the Buyer's Order, the warranty documents, and the inspection report, in one place.
Red flags that mean you should walk away
Do not buy from a dealership if they refuse to let you have an independent inspection, if they pressure you to sign documents before you've read them, or if they become hostile when you say no to add-on products. These are signs that the store prioritizes the sale over your interests. Also walk away if the vehicle history report (which you should always request and review) shows multiple accidents, flood damage, or a salvage title, unless you are specifically buying a salvage vehicle and understand what that means.
Be cautious if the dealership cannot produce the vehicle's title or service records, or if they tell you the vehicle was a rental or fleet vehicle but the history report does not confirm it. These gaps suggest the dealership may not have full ownership or may be hiding something. Trust your instinct—if something feels wrong, it probably is, and there are other vehicles and other dealerships.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I negotiate the price at Matthews Auto Group?
Yes. The initial price is a starting point, not a final offer. Research the vehicle's market value using Kelley Blue Book or NADA Guides, then make a counter-offer below the asking price. Most dealerships expect negotiation and have room to move. Be respectful but firm about your number.
What if I find a problem with the vehicle after I buy it?
If you're still within the inspection period (usually three to five days), you can often return the vehicle or negotiate a repair credit. After that, the manufacturer's warranty covers defects, and any extended warranty you purchased covers additional repairs. Check your paperwork to see what's covered and for how long.
Do I have to use the dealership's service department?
No. You can take your vehicle to any repair shop you choose. Using an independent mechanic or a different dealership will not void your manufacturer's warranty. However, some extended warranties or service contracts may require you to use specific shops, so read the fine print.
What should I bring to the dealership when I go to buy?
Bring your driver's license, proof of insurance, and proof of income (pay stub or tax return). If you're financing through your own lender, bring a pre-approval letter. Bring a list of questions and the vehicle's VIN if you've researched it online. Do not bring your checkbook or sign blank documents.
Is the dealer prep fee required?
Dealer prep fees vary by state and dealership. Some are standard and non-negotiable; others are inflated and can be reduced or removed during negotiation. Ask what the fee covers and whether it's required by state law. If it's not required, push back on it or ask for a credit toward the purchase price.